I don't know whether you're accepting this at face value or just pointing out it was the justification offered for treating people with certain political leanings as people without rights.
But regardless it's worth pointing out that factoids like that are what give anti-Communists a bad name, as it's very, very wrong, particularly post WW2. Note that I'm saying that as someone who is very much on the anti-Communist side.
A little of both, I was going to point out the existence of opposition communists, but they seemed too minor to merit mention.
Unless of course you want to show me the non-trotskyists who weren't in the pay of the U.S.S.R? I admit my knowledge of the various communist parties is pretty flimsy.[0]
[0]: This is why I qualify most of my statements with things like "pretty much" or "most of" or "almost every", guess I slipped up here.
EDIT: "pay" is probably the wrong word there, maybe "under the ideological command of" would be a better description.
But, to name a couple... Spain, Italy, and the rest of the Eurocommunists (which probably should include Australia); Japan and it's very peace and anti-nuclear oriented party; China and its affiliated Marxist-Leninist-Stalinist-Mao Zedong thought-style parties, which killed more USSR troops in armed conflict than the USA ever did; the Khmer Rouge, which was effectively a murderous pariah state only supported by the PRC (ultimately being replaced by a leftist Soviet and Vietnamese-affiliated government); India with its half a dozen of Communist sects that I can never keep straight in elected office; Yugoslavia with its market socialism and Non-Aligned foreign policy.
There are even oddities like Albania, which took an ultra-pro-Soviet position that outpaced the Soviet Union's CP (it argued that it was turning too far away from Stalin). And ideologically the Cuban Communist Party had few moorings, mostly providing a gloss for nationalism until it actually achieved power.
Even in the USA, although CPUSA was effectively defined as the group of people with slavish devotion to the USSR, it constantly shed members or purged them, who formed their own groups that were anti-Soviet in principle, though many still grudgingly thought it was the lesser of two evils when it came to foreign policy. And the UK Communist left was infamous for its variety of views leading to a "one person, one party" system.
I'd say the biggest issue with your claim, though (aside from ignoring truculent Trotskyites, whose level of influence has persistently remained stuck at zero) is it ignores the China-USSR split. This isn't to the credit of those Communists who weren't on the USSR's side; they were the cheerleaders of the Khmer Rouge, Cultural Revolution, and Shining Path. Most USSR-affiliated ones, by contrast, steadfastly supported parliamentary tactics because they were more likely to rebound to Soviet benefit.
It was a very real and relevant split.
You're right, I was thinking of western Communist parties, but you already covered those. Have an upvote.
Are you kidding me?
Maoist parties (prevalent in Western Europe, especially with younger people) were against the USSR.
The New Left was anti-USSR.
In the UK too, the prevalent notion was anti-USSR.
As were tons of other communist party genres (like those based on the "Frankfurt School" of thinking, or those influenced by "Worker's councils" etc etc).
Not sure about here in the USA, but after the 1965 the USSR was not supporting this communist party:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maki_%28historical_political_p...
> EDIT: "pay" is probably the wrong word there, maybe "under the ideological command of" would be a better description.
The biggest obvious exception are Maoists, who were quite numerous Communists but very much not under the ideological command of the USSR.
If they were honest, they would have allowed discussion and dialog rather than the McCarthyite witch hunts and branding communism as AIDs-spreading terrorists strapped with nuclear suicide bombs.
They didn't even trust in their own ideology to survive a rigorous examination, and that's why they turned to demonization.
Basically any tin-pot dictator who wanted our support could declare themselves "anti-communist" and they had it. And many, many did so. No matter how obvious it should have been that we did not want to support their actions.
I'd liken it to religious fanatics who seem incredibly fearful of other religions. If they're so sure they've got "the way," then their beliefs should be able to stand up to scrutiny or comparison with other belief systems.
No, the foreign policy actions were very rational. It's not like they got duped by some dictator posing as "anti-communist".
They knew what they were getting and what they were supporting (as all historical accounts and de-classified documents show).
They just wanted to gain influence to those parts of the world (for resources, trade routes, military bases etc) at any cost.
But you're right, they're still out there causing havoc.
That's totally wrong. Especially in Hoover's time.
Tons of countries with ruling communist parties had broken ties with USSR or were independent in the first place, if not outright hostile (like China).
And there were also lots of non ruling communist parties, especially in Western Europe and UK, that were anti-USSR, anti-Stalinist, etc.
In the US, the so-called New Left, was decidedly anti-USSR too, (which is one of the reasons for the "New" moniker).
And that's before we add other communist parties, that were in "war" with USSR, like the Trotskyists.
Let me help:
http://www.trumanlibrary.org/whistlestop/study_collections/c...
Basically, every communist (Read: Marxist-Leninist/Stalinist/etc) party that existed during the 20th century took its orders from the U.S.S.R. The authoritarian form of Marxism practiced by the Bolsheviks would never fly with the population of the United States, so the Soviets would use the sympathies of American communists to leak info and sabotage national defense programs.
This meant that every communist was a de facto U.S.S.R spy in the eyes of the USA.
The above document is a report to President Truman in 1946 about the ideological underpinnings that would go on to cause the cold war.