News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by songgao on Saturday June 15, 2013 @01:48PM (#5885736)
This is disgusting. A news agency that is known for defending its own governments' dirty stuff, twisting truth, and manipulating public opinions, is now appreciating a freedom fighter and a human rights activist.

It's apparently not because what Snowden did matches their core values, or they want the same thing happen in China. Oh yes, they certainly like Snowden. It's because Snowden exposed some bad things done by US authorities, and they can use this as political tool; furthermore they can finally take this and say to Chinese people, hey, US does this too. You like the freedom in US? That's all bullshit.

If you are interested in what their reactions were when this kind of thing happened in China, back in 2010, this [1] (google translate: [2]) was xinhuanet's opinion on Chinese human rights activist, Nobel Peace Prize recipient, Liu Xiaobo [3]. They described Liu Xiaobo as an evil man used by western countries to attack Chinese government, while the truth is Liu Xiaobo spent years striving for Chinese people's freedom, human rights, and constitution enforcement in China.

Xinhuanet basically writes what the government tells them to write, and say what the government tells them to say.

[1] http://news.xinhuanet.com/world/2010-10/15/c_12664760.htm

[2] http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=zh-CN&u=http:...

[3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liu_Xiaobo#Nobel_Peace_Prize

EDIT: typos

Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by joe_the_user on Saturday June 15, 2013 @02:17PM (#5885824)
A news agency that is known for defending its own governments' dirty stuff, twisting truth, and manipulating public opinions, is now appreciating a freedom fighter and a human rights activist.

Oh indeed, like the New York Times, say?

Obviously, the point isn't that China has democratic integrity.

Rather, it is that China is happy to push the theme that the US is not looking that much better than China given this scandal. And that's good for everyone, in the sense that it keeps Snowden safe and it puts pressure on the US to really prove that it takes democracy and transparency seriously.

Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by songgao on Saturday June 15, 2013 @02:19PM (#5885831)
I wouldn't trust China for a safe shelter. If you are used as a tool, you never know when it's gonna change.
Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by jafaku on Saturday June 15, 2013 @03:05PM (#5885967)
I wouldn't trust USA for a safe shelter. If you are used as a tool, you never know when it's gonna change.
Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by wavefunction on Saturday June 15, 2013 @03:48PM (#5886090)
don't be a tool then, is the lesson
Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by gwgarry on Saturday June 15, 2013 @09:03PM (#5886919)
Snowden's job is done. They will leave him alone as the US leaves alone dissidents once they have briefed the CIA and various other organizations and given testimony on how they have a secret, secret plan on the basis of which the US can start a war with the country.
Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by coldtea on Saturday June 15, 2013 @05:40PM (#5886374)
>This is disgusting. A news agency that is known for defending its own governments' dirty stuff, twisting truth, and manipulating public opinions, is now appreciating a freedom fighter and a human rights activist.

So, exactly like the major US news outlets, from the Times to the Post to CNN? It's very hard, as a European, to find any news coverage of world affairs in the US that doesn't subscribe to the official Washington party line (with small diversions, according to which of the two parties the outlet/author supports).

>If you are interested in what their reactions were when this kind of thing happened in China, back in 2010, this [1] (google translate: [2]) was xinhuanet's opinion on Chinese human rights activist, Nobel Peace Prize recipient, Liu Xiaobo [3]. They described Liu Xiaobo as an evil man used by western countries to attack Chinese government, while the truth is Liu Xiaobo spent years striving for Chinese people's freedom, human rights, and constitution enforcement in China.

So?

There is a way to strive for your people's "freedom, human rights, and constitution enforcement" that's in accordance to your countries and your people's needs (even if your government hates it) AND there is another way to fight for "freedom, human rights, and constitution enforcement" that serves the agenda of foreign powers. The second way is mostly how you earn a "Nobel Prize" (which Obama also got, oh, the irony).

It's difficult to convey the above distinction to an American, not because they can't understand it, but because they haven't experienced it. See, the US is a world leader, so there's not another country that can even think of using people to influence American politics, topple politicians, grab it's resources, etc. Things that happen all the time in smaller countries -- and more often than not, those people ("freedom fighters", etc) are agents of US foreign policy (or French, or UK, etc -- it's what's called neo-colonialism).

Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by tptacek on Saturday June 15, 2013 @06:10PM (#5886445)
Unfortunately, the idea that you'd compare Xinhua to CNN says more about your biases than it does about Xinhua or CNN. Xinhua is an instrument of the Chinese state.
Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by gasull on Saturday June 15, 2013 @07:07PM (#5886599)
You are implying CNN isn't an instrument.
Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by rejschaap on Saturday June 15, 2013 @07:16PM (#5886623)
At least not an instrument of the state.
Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by coldtea on Saturday June 15, 2013 @09:46PM (#5887062)
No, it's a private corporation in bed with the state.
Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by tptacek on Saturday June 15, 2013 @07:16PM (#5886622)
Have you ever listened to Alex Jones on the radio? You might like him.
Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by chris_wot on Saturday June 15, 2013 @11:31PM (#5887325)
He was using a reasoned argument. There's no need to insult the man.
Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by gasull on Saturday June 15, 2013 @07:42PM (#5886691)
Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by coldtea on Saturday June 15, 2013 @09:45PM (#5887054)
In case you were confused, I've never compared Xinhua to CNN. In fact, I never even MENTIONED Xinhua. What I said was that CNN, NYT etc all conform to the official Washington party line.

But now that you brought it up, I can also say this: CNN is as much an instrument of the US state, as Xinhua is.

Of course CNN is privately run, and also pays lip service to journalistic independence and stuff, but that's just how this thing works over there. That's like Google saying "Don't be evil" or McDonalds touting the quality of it's products: i.e. only for very naive people.

You might like this:

"As Major Thomas Collins, of the U.S. Army Information Service acknowledged: "Psyops personnel, soldiers and officers, have been working in CNN's headquarters in Atlanta through our programme 'Training With Industry'. They worked as regular employees of CNN. Conceivably, they would have worked on stories during the Kosovo war. They helped in the production of news.""

Or this:

"In an extraordinary directive to its staff, Cable News Network has instructed reporters and anchormen to tailor their coverage of the US war against Afghanistan to downplay the toll of death and destruction caused by American bombing, for fear that such coverage will undermine popular support for the US military effort".

Or this:

In a second memo leaked to the Post, CNN’s head of standards and practices, Rick Davis, expressed concern about reports on the bombing of Afghanistan filed by on-the-spot reporters. Davis noted that it “may be hard for the correspondent in these dangerous areas to make the points clearly” about the reasons for the US bombing. In other words, the CNN official feared that overseas correspondents might be intimidated by local opposition to the US military intervention and allow such sentiments to influence their reports.

To ensure that every CNN report always includes a justification of the war, Davis prescribed specific language for anchors to read after each account of civilian casualties and other bomb damage. He suggested three alternative formulations:

* “We must keep in mind, after seeing reports like this from Taliban-controlled areas, that these US military actions are in response to a terrorist attack that killed close to 5,000 innocent people in the US.” * “We must keep in mind, after seeing reports like this, that the Taliban regime in Afghanistan continues to harbor terrorists who have praised the September 11 attacks that killed close to 5,000 innocent people in the US.” * “The Pentagon has repeatedly stressed that it is trying to minimize civilian casualties in Afghanistan, even as the Taliban regime continues to harbor terrorists who are connected to the September 11 attacks that claimed thousands of innocent lives in the US.” Davis concluded with an ultimatum to journalists concerned that they may sound like parrots for the White House: “Even though it may start sounding rote, it is important that we make this point each time.”

http://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2001/11/cnn-n06.html

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Mockingbird

http://www.counterpunch.org/2000/03/26/cnn-and-psyops/

Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by olalonde on Saturday June 15, 2013 @04:23PM (#5886182)
> say what the government tells them to say.

While it might be, this is not necessarily true. If Snowden were to win the Nobel peace prize, there would most likely be US newspapers describing him as an evil man and a traitor. The same newspapers would probably describe a Chinese whistleblower as a hero. All of that without government intervention. Just like in the US, a lot of people in China blindly support their government without having a gun pointed at their head. This might somehow be related to the Stockholm syndrom or simply a strong sense of nationalism.

Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by SilasX on Saturday June 15, 2013 @09:43PM (#5887046)
Before anyone else does it, let me adapt the old joke:

An American and Chinese businessman are talking about their respective governments.

The American says, "See, you in China don't have the liberties that we do. Why, if someone exposed an unflattering truth about the US government, they would be lauded as heroes for standing up for our rights! You can't say that about your own country."

The Chinese responds, "Not true, not true. If someone exposed unflattering truths about the US government, they would be very welcome here too!"

Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by justinschuh on Saturday June 15, 2013 @03:19PM (#5886007)
I'd say what Snowden is doing fits fits their core values and goals perfectly. He's spreading gross misinformation and propaganda that's damaging to the US government and major US based technology companies. The fact that he may be doing it out of well-intentioned ignorance rather than willfully doesn't strike me as a big sticking point from their perspective.

[edit: I'm not surprised this is getting downmodded without any actual counterarguments. My comment is a bit too flippant, and the Snowden story really plays to the prevailing biases of the tech crowd. Still this whole episode does have me a little saddened by how otherwise intelligent people can behave so irrationally when something fits what they want to believe.]

Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by forgottenpaswrd on Saturday June 15, 2013 @09:06PM (#5886928)
"He's spreading gross misinformation and propaganda that's damaging to the US government and major US based technology companies."

It is not propaganda if it is true, like the members of congress have admitted.

American companies and country own the world, they have power to abuse and they do. Is that hard to understand?

Like any other Empire, they fall down over its own weight.

Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by justinschuh on Sunday June 16, 2013 @10:04AM (#5888463)
We already know the majority of his claims are not true, or are grossly misrepresented. The latest bit of noise is a congressman with no background on intelligence who misunderstood a briefing he received and just made an ass of himself in public. Just like all the other articles on this, we'll get corrections and clarifications over the next several days that basically amount to a retraction, but I expect that's not what you'll remember.
Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by coldtea on Saturday June 15, 2013 @09:49PM (#5887070)
>I'd say what Snowden is doing fits fits their core values and goals perfectly. He's spreading gross misinformation and propaganda that's damaging to the US government and major US based technology companies.

Err, what? Perhaps you haven't been following the news. Or 10,000 HN stories on this and related issues.

As for it being "damaging US government and major US based technology companies", OK, I get what your priorities are...

Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by justinschuh on Sunday June 16, 2013 @10:11AM (#5888478)
I expect I've been following it much more closely than you, and for much longer, because I have professional experience with much of what's being covered. That's why I'm distinguishing between the headlines and the actual underlying stories, and taking note of the major corrections that follow every unbelievable headline.

Just for some context, here's some of comments on the subject on HN six months ago:

* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4979800

* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4979641

Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by wavefunction on Saturday June 15, 2013 @03:49PM (#5886092)
oh man...
Re:“Whistleblower welcome in China” by gwgarry on Saturday June 15, 2013 @09:01PM (#5886910)
Kettle, I mean American, meet pot, I mean Chinese.