Over 60% showed up to the gubernatorial elections won by Schwarzenegger [a] and Ventura [b]; you know, the former body builder and the former wrestler, who co-starred in Predator... Wasn't George Clooney born in Kentucky? He might be a "rich old white man" at this point, but do you think Mitch McConnell (or any incumbent, for that matter) would stand a chance against him?
If Brad Pitt, James Franco, Shaquille O'Neal, or Ashton Kutcher ran for office... they'd win. And they'd be better representatives, because they're not career politicians, and they don't know how the system works. Then watch as normal people are suddenly tuning into CSPAN to catch a speech by Sen. Pitt or Rep. Shaq. I'm surprised the major parties didn't court celebrities after 1984, when a former actor captured the highest number of electoral votes in history...
"It's Charisma, Stupid" is focused on presidential elections, but pg remarks near the end that he's "not saying that issues don't matter to voters. Of course they do." Yes, issues do matter to voters. But voters are generally a minority, at least in non-presidential elections. The majority cares more about movies and sports because celebrities are interesting. Existing politicians are boring.
I read the other day that Allen Iverson is basically broke, recently divorced, had a house foreclosed, and doesn't know what to do with his life after basketball...
a. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_gubernatorial_recall...
b. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minnesota_gubernatorial_electio...
http://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21579483-jerry-b...
His tenure, as many know, immediately followed Schwarzenegger's, who was less successful.
In fairness, though: Brown seems to be exceptionally good this time around, and I'd bet that most people believe Arnold's problems didn't stem from too much partisanship or a lack of good faith effort.
I can see celebrities doing it for the fame though-- specifically to show that they're "more than" an actor, singer, athlete, or whatever.
Or maybe the solution is just to pick celebrities that hold themselves to high standards. So... not Nicolas Cage.
Are there good grounds for thinking it was ever much more "by the people for the people" than it is now?
Teddy Roosevelt's national parks.
Would he have been able to run on his own at that point? I suspect not - he would have been viewed as too progressive by the people in charge.
For the record, I used to really like this guy, until I read more about the era from some real (not high-school) history books and analysis pieces.
[1]http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/most-americans-suppor...
The house is suppose to represent the people. Also, each senator receives a written transcript of every meeting, so why not leave and just read it on the plane?
Not to mention, if the people do not know what is in this briefing it should really be the senators duty to leave by the logic you used. They should only vote on what the people want and have no reason to waste their time attending something that is not for the people. In other words, why attend something that does change their constituents minds?
Politicians should be disallowed from consecutive terms. They can run only when they're not already in office, preventing them from spending all their time on reelection, and (hopefully) leading them to fight for what the people want.
..of course, how much time would then be spent picking and grooming a successor?
Also, thank you for posting that Ted talk!
Edit: Changed "fully" to "full".
From the Wikipedia article: > FairVote [argues Approval Voting] can result in the defeat of a candidate who would win an absolute majority in a plurality system, can allow a candidate to win who might not win any support in a plurality elections
This sounds like a good thing. You end up with an elected official that satisfies most of the population.
51% of voters think Alice would be the best person to lead, they'd be OK with Bob but think Carol and Dan are morons. 49% think Carol would be the best person to lead, they'd be OK with Bob but think both Alice and Dan are morons.
So now if we use normal majority voting, Alice wins and 49% of voters have an elected official they think is a moron.
With Approval Voting, Bob will win. Sure, he might have been everyone's second choice, but he's EVERYONE's second choice. So now we're all reasonably happy.
It reminds me of an immune disease -- if your very means of getting well is broken, how do you get well?
Politicians are skipping out of their responsibilities.
Politicians spend much of their time in office fundraising for re-election.
Politicians raise much of their election financing from corporate interests, not the people, and thus have a diminishing obligation to the people.[1]
A vast minority of people elect our politicians because 50% of eligible voters don't go to polls.
Most are rich old white men, not a representation of the people.[2]
We can do better.
[1]http://www.ted.com/talks/lawrence_lessig_we_the_people_and_t...
[2]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_current_United_States_S...