Re:Does America need a Pirate Party?
by Apocryphon on Friday June 14, 2013 @02:19PM
(#5881480)
You're speaking from an Objectivist position, aren't you?
In this case, I would say no. What I said is a very basic observation. Why do you ask?
A religious devotion to rationality is the most insidious form of irrationality.
I completely agree. I would have phrased it as:
A religious devotion to "rationality" is the most insidious form of irrationality.
Scare quotes are the great hallmark of a rationalist. </sarcasm>
Well, rationality can't be irrationality, and vice versa, so that's why scare quotes are necessary.
Kirk would infamously defeat Spock at chess by making surprise moves that made no sense, thus confusing and destabilizing his opponent. A good rationalist should see genuine irrationality as part of their toolbox.
I thought you were basically trolling me before.
> A good rationalist
"Rationalism" is actually an error. It means thinking in a way that's disconnected from percepts. Rationalism is the opposite of "empiricism," which is also wrong. It means thinking without abstraction.
tl;dr: being a "rationalist" is not good. Being "rational" is.
> should see genuine irrationality as part of their toolbox
Being genuinely irrational is never going to help you accomplish anything. Kirk was feigning irrationality.
Re:Does America need a Pirate Party?
by eli_gottlieb on Saturday June 15, 2013 @03:34AM
(#5884427)
Except that Spock is a total strawman of a brainy person in the first place.
Random deviations from what your opponent thinks is your strategy are in fact known-good components of good strategy.
I agree with you. They are a progressive party, they are anti-individual rights, and that's why they have "Pirate" (literally a thief) in their name.
The cause of liberty cannot be advanced by backing movements that do not base their ideas on a rational foundation.