News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by rosser on Thursday June 13, 2013 @03:20PM (#5876008)
The US is not a "Democracy", and never has been. It's a Republic.

You conflate those two things at your peril.

Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by mtgx on Thursday June 13, 2013 @03:25PM (#5876031)
Which "democracy" isn't a republic? I don't think any country actually has direct/pure democracy. They are all republics and have representatives and Parliaments.

That being said, US could use a whole lot more "democracy" into its system. I don't think the delegate system works very well. Gerrymandering has also been abused for decades.

Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by Ma8ee on Thursday June 13, 2013 @03:42PM (#5876114)
Many European democracies, such as Sweden, Denmark, and of course United Kingdom, are monarchies. We don't have presidents, but kings and queens. Not that it matters that much, since the monarchs have very little real power, and usually the prime ministers have more of the same role as the US president. One difference is of course that the prime ministers are elected by the parliaments and not directly by the people.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by jlgreco on Thursday June 13, 2013 @04:30PM (#5876374)
If we are being pedantic, then the US president is not elected directly by the people either. Presidents are elected by the electoral college.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by mpyne on Thursday June 13, 2013 @05:33PM (#5876728)
Sadly that's not always a strictly pedantic point. Even besides Bush v. Gore, it also has led to the concept of "Battleground States" which I find abhorrent to a proper republic.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by baddox on Thursday June 13, 2013 @11:23PM (#5878105)
You're always going to have "battleground regions" unless you can guarantee a uniform population density and uniform distribution of political tendencies across the entire nation.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by nitrogen on Friday June 14, 2013 @03:16AM (#5878700)
Battleground regions aren't as big of a deal when a 1% change in the popular vote of a state no longer results in a 100% change in the electoral vote.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by jlgreco on Thursday June 13, 2013 @05:34PM (#5876741)
Very true. The "pedantic" is misleading.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by claudius on Thursday June 13, 2013 @06:09PM (#5876903)
The way the head of state is chosen doesn’t really matter with regards to whether the state is a republic or a monarchy. Monarchies have crowned head of states, republics don’t. For example, the Holy Roman Empire (aka this bundle of German states existing in the middle ages) was a monarchy, but the emperor was elected (by a set of dukes and such), whereas the UK is a monarchy while the queen isn’t elected.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by rosser on Thursday June 13, 2013 @03:28PM (#5876044)
And that's exactly why it's important to make the distinction. Calling the US a "Democracy" suggests the power lies with the people. It doesn't.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by mindcrime on Thursday June 13, 2013 @04:06PM (#5876245)
Calling the US a "Democracy" suggests the power lies with the people. It doesn't.

It's supposed to, and if it doesn't, that only tells us that things have gone very wrong. But you don't have to have direct democracy (as opposed to representative democracy) to adhere to the idea that the ultimate political power rests in the hands of the people.

Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by CapitalistCartr on Thursday June 13, 2013 @05:06PM (#5876589)
Supposed to, according to whom? In the original constitution, members of the Senate were chosen by State legislatures; the president was chosen by the members of the Electoral College who were not simply tokens, but really had the choice. The vote was restricted to white male landowners.

Most importantly, the point of having a constitutional republic is the constitution protects the minority from the tyranny of the majority.

Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by baddox on Thursday June 13, 2013 @11:16PM (#5878089)
Actually, calling the US a republic suggests the power lies with the people. That's what "republic" means, and is why the last six letters of the word are "public."
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by marshray on Thursday June 13, 2013 @11:51PM (#5878167)
What do the first four letters of "democracy" mean?
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by baddox on Friday June 14, 2013 @12:10AM (#5878240)
It means the people, of course. But I'm not disputing rosser's claim, I'm just pointing out that the same is true of the term "republic."
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by CCs on Thursday June 13, 2013 @04:35PM (#5876395)
"Dictatorship of the majority" vs "Rule of law" http://www.diffen.com/difference/Democracy_vs_Republic
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by frisco on Thursday June 13, 2013 @04:31PM (#5876378)
Switzerland is a direct democracy.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by brazzy on Thursday June 13, 2013 @05:11PM (#5876607)
No. It's a federal parliamentary republic (just like the USA), but allows citizen-initiated referendums to challenge all laws passed by the parliament, or even to change the constitution.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by pbhjpbhj on Friday June 14, 2013 @11:54PM (#5883915)
>allows citizen-initiated referendums to challenge all laws passed by the parliament, or even to change the constitution //

Wouldn't you say that fits within the term "direct democracy"?

Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by brazzy on Monday June 17, 2013 @06:32AM (#5892366)
No, but it's probably as close as you can practically come at scale. A real direct democracy would have all relevant decisions made by citizens collectively, not just potentially challenged.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by pbhjpbhj on Monday June 17, 2013 @10:10AM (#5893210)
It's possible for the citizenry to alter any decision directly without recourse to elections. That's why I'd say it is a form of direct democracy.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by dragonwriter on Friday June 14, 2013 @02:49PM (#5881690)
> Which "democracy" isn't a republic?

Many countries that are, like the US, representative democracies are, unlike the US, not republics (an obvious example is the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, which is a constitutional monarchy rather than a republic, but nevertheless also a representative democracy.)

Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by tbrownaw on Thursday June 13, 2013 @05:19PM (#5876656)
Which "democracy" isn't a republic? I don't think any country actually has direct/pure democracy.

The state of California is closer than most I think. IIRC part of their budget troubles were because some issues require a referendum.

Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by arjie on Thursday June 13, 2013 @03:25PM (#5876025)
A curious distinction. To me it appears as if the US is a constitutional democratic republic and an indirect democracy. The two terms are not in opposition.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by jetti on Friday June 14, 2013 @02:10PM (#5881416)
The CIA World Factbook[1] calls it a "constitution-based federal republic" but also adds that it has "strong democratic tradition".

[1] https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/...

Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by rosser on Thursday June 13, 2013 @03:27PM (#5876038)
The point of making the distinction is to emphasize where the power actually lies.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by alexqgb on Thursday June 13, 2013 @03:51PM (#5876159)
There is no "the power" in a system of divided government. That's the whole point of a system of divided government. Power is distributed. The people have some, their representatives have some, the judiciary has some, the executive has some, the press has some, etc. Ideally, the distribution is designed in a way that maintains a stable set of checks and balances between the various centers.

More to the point, "Democracy" has a fairly broad meaning, and encompasses a range of systems and traditions. You'd have to be exceedingly pedantic to insist that using it to describe any form aside from a pure, direct democracy is a misuse of language.

Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by baddox on Thursday June 13, 2013 @11:19PM (#5878097)
Anyone can argue all day over the semantics of "where the power actually lies." I would say that it lies in the hands of people who frequently use physical weapons to harm and threaten to harm others, which for the most part is government.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by pvnick on Thursday June 13, 2013 @03:28PM (#5876045)
Well if you're going to be pedantic than so am I. The US is a "representative democracy" in that we collectively vote on those people who make decisions, the idea being that average citizen is a better judge of character than of policy.

So yeah, still technically a democracy, just not a direct democracy.

Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by trippy_biscuits on Thursday June 13, 2013 @04:32PM (#5876380)
We said the following in grade school on a daily basis, long ago.

"I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all."

Finding democracy is an exercise left to the reader.

Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by rosser on Thursday June 13, 2013 @03:32PM (#5876069)
It's not pedantry. Calling this country a "Democracy" suggests that the citizenry has the power. We don't.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by sopooneo on Thursday June 13, 2013 @04:18PM (#5876306)
Will you challenge us to find quotes from major figures of American history referring to the nation as a democracy?
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by rosser on Thursday June 13, 2013 @04:58PM (#5876538)
It wouldn't do very well for American politicians to point out the power imbalance that happens to be in their favor...
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by chris_j on Thursday June 13, 2013 @03:40PM (#5876100)
Would you mind precisely defining what you mean by "republic"? Growing up in the UK, I was taught that a republic is a country with a non-hereditary head of state. Under that definition, the USA would be a republic, as would China and Russia, whereas countries like the UK, Spain and Thailand would not. However, it sounds like it has a subtly different meaning in this and other online discussions and I'd be very grateful for help in understanding that meaning.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by sirclueless on Thursday June 13, 2013 @08:17PM (#5877568)
A republic is usually defined in positive terms: any government that is determined somehow by the public. That's basically equivalent to your definition that it is any government that is not private property to be handed down by heredity.

Some people use the term "republic" to imply "merely a republic" in the sense that the country in question is not a direct democracy. I am not sure whether this betrays that they think of government as having one dimension of variety from hereditary monarchs to direct democracy, whether they think that republics and democracies are incompatible forms of government, or whether they realize that democracy is merely one form of a republic and choose to simplify for effect when they say things like "The USA is not a democracy, it is a republic."

As usual, wikipedia is pretty good on the subject:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic

Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by w_t_payne on Thursday June 13, 2013 @05:57PM (#5876848)
Democracy is not an either/or label; it is a term that encompasses a range of different systems and cultures. For example, the US system is definitely more "democratic" than the Iranian system, although they both involve voting. Conversely, the Swiss system is arguably more democratic than either the US or Iran.

However, it is worth noting that attempting to rank systems by quantity-of-democracy-nature stops being useful pretty quickly, and it becomes helpful to introduce other terms/variables/factors/axes along which to measure and evaluate political systems.

Equally, once certain baselines are met, the exact mechanics of the system quickly stop being as important as less tangible factors such as civil society mechanisms and cultural biases:- Particularly the professional culture of the legislature:- Ability of legislators to set aside party politics to work in the national interest; To preserve the integrity of the political system from corruption, and maintain the ability to make decisions without bias in the face of attempts to lobby and influence behaviour.

Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by mindcrime on Thursday June 13, 2013 @04:04PM (#5876239)
It's loose use of language, but given that we are a democratically elected representative republic, which has Enlightenment ideals baked right into the founding documents, I think using "Democracy" to refer to the US is "correct enough" in most contexts. Certainly we aspire, at least nominally, to "liberal, democratic ideals" where "liberal" refers to the "classical liberal" mindset, not what passes for liberalism today.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by staunch on Thursday June 13, 2013 @05:14PM (#5876632)
I think the single biggest thing technologists could do is try to turn the US into a direct democracy.

It's probably the only way out of the downward spiral we've found ourselves in.

Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by dragonsky on Thursday June 13, 2013 @09:47PM (#5877849)
And have the majority voting for what ever is pushed on Fox news?

Direct democracy can only ever work when a significant majority of the population is well educated and engaged in the process of government. Anything else and they will vote for what every makes their immediate lives more palatable.

It is very rare for somebody to make a decision that will make life more difficult in the short term in anticipation of the greater good in the long term.

The whole point of representative democracy is that our representatives are supposed to be wiser than the majority of the public, and therefore be able to make the difficult decisions on behalf of the people, whilst understanding that the people themselves may not, due to self interest, be able to make those decisions themselves.

Even in Ancient Greece, the bastion of all things democratic, only a very small part of the population were able to vote. You had to be a landholder with a fair amount of money. Sound familiar?

I would love to live in a world where individuals were able to take the long view and vote based on the greater good. Unfortunately we are a long way from that. What we have, whilst suffering form increasing influence from well funded interests, is the best that the world has seen.

Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by tbrownaw on Thursday June 13, 2013 @05:22PM (#5876673)
Because direct democracy has worked so unbelievably well in the past, yes?
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by epsylon on Friday June 14, 2013 @04:43AM (#5878920)
It's a moot argument since we do not live in the past. The context has changed, technology has advanced, and we don't have to replicate strictly identically the structures of the past.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by staunch on Thursday June 13, 2013 @06:32PM (#5877041)
No one has ever had the ability to do it like we could now.
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by tbrownaw on Thursday June 13, 2013 @09:32PM (#5877803)
Re:Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony ... by shadowfox on Thursday June 13, 2013 @06:13PM (#5876917)
Maybe I don't completely understand the distinction. Care to elaborate?