A significant chunk of the money Reuters pays for the reports, which they recoup through subscriptions, winds up going to pay for the production of the reports anyway. The only thing that surprises me about this is how much money they are likely leaving on the table. They should let people bid for early access.
However, if "everyone" knows that some companies can buy these reports minutes ahead of time, then when people lose out on trades in the minutes afterwards, isn't it the fault of the people taking the trade?
It's not wise to trade with people who might have more knowledge than you. It seems like there's a reasonable expectation that the people on the other sides of these trades should know about the paid access.
We have decided that it should be illegal for public companies to give information selectively for the purposes of trading. We could easily change this law, but history has shown us that it isn't heavy handed and does have a positive impact on the market.
It was already known that they released the data 5 minutes early to subscribers who wished to pay more. It's not really a stretch to think they'd offer tiers for people who wished to pay more.
The data is, after all, legally theirs to release, and Michigan University knew and approved it.
If this is something people don't like then they can vote with their feet and move to a different news source.
Once again Nanex is all over this.