Re:The BBC's hi-tech failure: Don't Mention It
by macspoofing on Thursday June 13, 2013 @11:18AM
(#5874488)
I just don't think a large enterprise would engage in an internal $100 million project to build a CMS.
I'm not saying private enterprises can't fail or don't fail. They just wouldn't fail in this specific way at that magnitude.
Re:The BBC's hi-tech failure: Don't Mention It
by ceejayoz on Thursday June 13, 2013 @11:31AM
(#5874574)
Massive write-offs for failed projects and acquisitions are pretty common in large enterprises.
Re:The BBC's hi-tech failure: Don't Mention It
by macspoofing on Thursday June 13, 2013 @11:43AM
(#5874635)
Failed acquisitions are pretty common, failed projects too. I'm not disputing that, and that wasn't my argument. I added a clarification to my post.
Re:The BBC's hi-tech failure: Don't Mention It
by andyjohnson0 on Thursday June 13, 2013 @11:44AM
(#5874645)
"I just don't think a large enterprise would engage in an internal $100 million project to build a CMS."
Isn't this a circular argument? If a company doesn't want to build a system in-house then its only other option is to contract another company to build it. At some point, someone has to build the system.
Your last two points contradict your first two. There's nothing unique about a government's ability to make terrible decisions. I'd say one difference is that private enterprises typically go under if the mistake is big enough, and they have no great interest in telling the public about their mistakes.