News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by mtgx on Sunday June 09, 2013 @08:08AM (#5848571)
This is becoming a lot more common lately. The discrepancy between how much jail time the people who upset the government get, and the people who commit real crimes is getting bigger. And that's without counting the complete lack of interest in prosecuting bankers and other corporations that are very friendly to the government. Justice is becoming increasingly more unequal.
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by flexie on Sunday June 09, 2013 @10:05AM (#5848943)
It's the war on terrorism. Every time you hear officials talk about terrorism, replace terrorism with "the devil".

"an act of terrorism" == "an act of the devil"

The war on terrorism is our witch-hunt.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by jmduke on Sunday June 09, 2013 @02:35PM (#5849951)
Except there is no canonical proof of the devil, and there are people who detonate explosives at the Boston Marathon.

I'm not saying what happened in the article is okay, nor am I saying things like PRISM and the PATRIOT Act are necessary sacrifices for the war on terror, but there are people in the world who do very very bad things to innocent people.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by effbott on Sunday June 09, 2013 @03:19PM (#5850106)
True, but the risk of dying at the hands of these people is extremely slim. According to tabular data found here[1], which chronicles US terrorist incidents and assassinations dating back to 1865, only 5031 people have been killed by terrorists in the last 148 years. That comes out to approximately 34 deaths per year!

That number is trivial compared to other causes of death. Here's a sampling of some death statistics from the year 2006 [2]:

  Fireworks discharge:                           8
  Fall on and from stairs and steps:         1,818
  Bitten or struck by dog:                      32
  Contact with venomous snakes and lizards:      8
  Accidental drowning and submersion:        3,579
  Exposure to electric transmission lines:      93
  Transport accidents:                      48,412
  Contact with hot tap-water:                   32
  Terrorism:                                     0
You're more likely to be killed by hot tap-water than you are by a terrorist.

[1](http://www.johnstonsarchive.net/terrorism/wrjp255a.html)

[2](http://www.nsc.org/news_resources/injury_and_death_statistic...)

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by wycats on Sunday June 09, 2013 @03:28PM (#5850144)
The problem with this sort of analysis is that there are EXTENSIVE efforts to reduce the amount of terrorism.

You might not like it, but the efforts are not trivial.

You're looking at the number of terrorism incidents AFTER efforts to mitigate them, and then concluding it's not a real issue. That's like saying that vaccinations aren't important because we haven't had a large number of Measles incidents lately.

We absolutely need better information, as citizens, to help weigh the relative success of these programs, but pretending to be sure that they aren't affecting the numbers is silly.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by csallen on Sunday June 09, 2013 @03:54PM (#5850266)
Good point.

Still, I can't help but hypothesize that the primary reason terrorism is such a rare occurrence in America is because intelligent people living comfortable lives without mental illness (read: the vast majority of the US) very rarely want to kill en masse. Or kill at all, really. If the opposite were true, I highly doubt our current counter-terrorism efforts would be good enough to prevent disaster after disaster.

For example, we were completely unable to predict and prevent events such as the Colorado theater shootings, the Newtown school shootings, the marathon bombings, etc. And the list of foiled Islamic plots since 9/11 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_foiled_Islamic_terroris...) can almost be counted on two hands.

Our justice system promises pretty severe retribution on those who would commit acts of terrorism against US citizens. The threats of ostracism, humiliation, prison time, and execution act as deterrents, because we've proven again and again that they're basically inescapable. Consequently, most reasonable people don't even consider terrorism.

It seems to me that punishing the guilty is far more effective than spying on the innocent.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by wycats on Sunday June 09, 2013 @04:06PM (#5850331)
Rational, reasonable response. Kudos!

Thought experiment: imagine if half of these foiled plots had occurred. In other words, imagine if every 6 months or so we had a terrorist attack that killed a dozen people (and sometimes more).

Do you think the American public would take the HN line that it's still a very small number of total deaths, similar to the number of people dying from hot tap water? Or would they elect politicians with a very aggressive anti-privacy regime that would be "necessary" to eliminate these routine acts of terror?

At the end of the day, politicians are elected by the people, and I suspect that even the best politician would need to have a somewhat aggressive surveillance regime purely to avoid being replaced by someone who would throw caution to the wind in response to routine attacks.

I'm sure someone will respond that there are basically no real thwarted attacks, but I don't believe that. The Wikipedia article you posted reflects my sense of the frequency of attempted attacks. You can also claim that these attacks would have been thwarted without any surveillance, but that isn't my understanding of how law enforcement works in general.

What we should be pushing for is a far more open understanding, by the citizenry, of the scope of data collection and how that data can be used by law enforcement operations.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by jlgreco on Sunday June 09, 2013 @04:18PM (#5850398)
> Thought experiment: imagine if half of these foiled plots had occurred. In other words, imagine if every 6 months or so we had a terrorist attack that killed a dozen people (and sometimes more). > Do you think the American public would take the HN line that it's still a very small number of total deaths, similar to the number of people dying from hot tap water? Or would they elect politicians with a very aggressive anti-privacy regime that would be "necessary" to eliminate these routine acts of terror?

The conditions of your thought experiment are not realized but the American public still reacts as you hypothesise they would if terrorist attacks were a semi-annual occurrence.

People are fucking awful at reasoning about rare but dramatic events. This should come as a surprise to nobody.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by VladRussian2 on Sunday June 09, 2013 @03:43PM (#5850214)
>The problem with this sort of analysis is that there are EXTENSIVE efforts to reduce the amount of terrorism.

the question here whether there are EFFECTIVE efforts. As Boston Marathon shows - no. Like in other times and other countries, anybody who wants is still able to commit such atrocious terrorist acts, despite the EXTENSIVE efforts. Governments just like EXTENSIVE efforts.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by wycats on Sunday June 09, 2013 @03:47PM (#5850228)
That's like saying that if there are any reports of measles, the entire vaccination regime is a failure.

I agree that we need to know more about the efforts to understand if they're working.

I disagree that the small number of terrorist attacks is evidence that the efforts we're using to combat the attacks aren't necessary.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by jacquesm on Sunday June 09, 2013 @04:04PM (#5850313)
I have this banana in my ear to keep the crocodiles away.
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by orthecreedence on Sunday June 09, 2013 @05:03PM (#5850589)
There are EXTENSIVE efforts in place, but I am willing to bet they are less than effective. I'd like to see a comparison of how many real terror attacks there are on US soil post-9/11 vs pre-9/11. I'm willing to bet they are very similar.

I think the methods used to sniff out terrorism are the same as they used to be, except now government agencies want to spy on everyone instead of just suspected terrorists.

Not to mention that every method we know about to stop terrorism since 9/11 has been reactionary; it has been a reaction to something that already happened. Not something that could happen.

I feel no safer from terror attacks now than I did before 9/11. Truth is, I never worried about them before and I don't worry about them now. It just doesn't happen that often. As stated, I'm tens of thousands of times more likely to die in a car ride on the way to a building that will be bombed than to die in the bombing itself.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by einhverfr on Sunday June 09, 2013 @10:38PM (#5851973)
There have been long-standing and extensive efforts to reduce deaths in traffic accidents too (in fact over time far more extensive than our antiterrorism efforts), and yet in the month of September, 2001, 20% more people in the US died in traffic accidents than in acts of terrorism. Once you aggregate beyond a year, the risk of terrorism is insignificant.

If you don't believe that, let's stop enforcing traffic safety laws, stop requiring manufacturers to include safety features in their cars, and stop designing traffic intersections with safety in mind and see what happens.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by leot on Sunday June 09, 2013 @04:45PM (#5850509)
I think, perhaps, that the problem with terrorism is that the distribution of terrorism event impacts is likely heavy-tailed -- i.e., the probability of one "black swan" event (nuclear, biological, chemical) is higher than a normal distribution model of event impacts would suggest.

But, to me, this means that the national security apparatus should be exclusively focused on reducing the probability of those most-terrible events, and instead leave the small-scale stuff to standard law enforcement. I.e., if the # of deaths is almost certainly < 200 (say), normal law enforcement procedures apply. If more than 500, then every resource can and should be brought to bear to prevent it.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by SilasX on Sunday June 09, 2013 @09:51PM (#5851814)
Sorry for the derail but: How ... how do you get killed by contact with hot tap water? Is that like unexpectedly boiling water coming out on babies, the elderly, and the very frail?
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by ppod on Sunday June 09, 2013 @04:52PM (#5850543)
> but there are people in the world who do very very bad things to innocent people.

And we have some very good laws to deal with that. Laws against murder for example. I think the analogy between 'terror' and 'devil' is a good one, because it captures the almost mystical 'special' evil that 'terrorist' implies. It's a childish, primitive term, with the same kind of semantic effect as the word 'baddie' in reference to an action movie.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by pizza234 on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @05:20PM (#5870820)
First of all, the Boston marathon bombing has nothing to do with terrorism, based on the current information.

There is people indeed who does very very bad things to innocent people, and many of them are in the USA government.

Posts like yours show how effective the governments' brainwashing is. Lots of innocent people dies in war bombings, and they're not necessary.

Do you have any idea of how many people died at the hands

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by noonespecial on Sunday June 09, 2013 @10:56PM (#5852034)
I keep saying it but it bears repeating. Above street level all justice is just politics.

Add in "terrorism" and it becomes completely non-deterministic. The charges may as well be completely invented. There is literally no way to predict the punishment any particular action might provoke. The complete failure of the rule of law. It's just rule by fiat.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by kiba on Sunday June 09, 2013 @08:38AM (#5848666)
Becoming more common lately? Or it is becoming more apparent to you lately? I would like a citation on wrongful prosecution activities.
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by jasallen on Sunday June 09, 2013 @09:27AM (#5848815)
This isn't a reference library. In the absence of a citation, I think its perfectly acceptable to automatically read that (or any comment post or blog) as "My perception is..." and move on without criticizing.
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by tome on Sunday June 09, 2013 @10:27AM (#5849004)
I think it's perfectly acceptable to ask that perceptions be stated explicitly as such, rather than leaving statements open to easy misinterpretation.
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by ctdonath on Sunday June 09, 2013 @11:07AM (#5849137)
I think it's perfectly absurd to expect that a brief intelligent comment on a social chat board be expected to include encyclopedic completeness and citations to ward off every conceivable casual wanton misinterpretation.
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by tome on Sunday June 09, 2013 @11:16AM (#5849162)
What's wrong with saying "This seems to be becoming a lot more common lately" rather than "This is becoming a lot more common lately"?
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by jasonlotito on Sunday June 09, 2013 @11:31AM (#5849234)
What's wrong with saying "This is becoming a lot more common lately" and without any supporting evidence, assuming opinion, rather than "This seems to be becoming a lot more common lately"? I think you would do well to answer that question first, as your question presupposes this question has already been answered, when it fact it has not.

Indeed, you have broken your own rule and left your comment open for easy misinterpretation.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by tome on Sunday June 09, 2013 @11:58AM (#5849340)
Well, I prefer the latter because it leads to a community where I can take more posts at face value and thus learn quicker. I don't think it's unreasonable to encourage this kind of behaviour. It seems to have very little cost.

> Indeed, you have broken your own rule and left your comment open for easy misinterpretation.

Have I? What's easy to misinterpret?

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by chc on Sunday June 09, 2013 @12:39PM (#5849502)
I think to most people, the fact that a comment is a statement of a person's opinion is part of the face value.
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by tome on Sunday June 09, 2013 @12:51PM (#5849545)
If that's the culture of HN then I bow to it.

However, I've never interpreted our community to be like that. On this forum I don't expect to hear

The discrepancy between how much jail time the people who upset the government get, and the people who commit real crimes is getting bigger

without evidence any more than I expect to hear

database server X is becoming faster than database server Y

without evidence.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by willurd on Sunday June 09, 2013 @02:04PM (#5849833)
Most people? Or are you projecting. I would like a citation on this.
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by tome on Sunday June 09, 2013 @02:17PM (#5849876)
Comedic interlude appreciated :)
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by willurd on Sunday June 09, 2013 @02:28PM (#5849924)
Glad somebody picked up on it :)
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by jasonlotito on Sunday June 09, 2013 @04:27PM (#5850434)
As I said:

I think you would do well to answer that question first, as your question presupposes this question has already been answered, when it fact it has not.

Asking why X is superior to Y is nothing more than an attempt to place the burden on someone else rather than yourself. You presupposed that Y is superior to X without any proof being offered.

It's akin to me asking you "When did you stop beating your wife," or other questions like that.

> Have I? What's easy to misinterpret?

So, specifically, with your statements, you make it seem like you've already proven your side, when in fact, you've done no such thing. It's disingenuous and manipulative. So, either you meant to be that way (dishonest), or you simply made a mistake of not backing up your opinion (What you are arguing against).

So, considering the later is what you are arguing against, it's very easy to assume you are simply trying to be dishonest. I'd like to think better of HN, and assume that people generally speak their opinion, and only assume they are speaking fact when they are providing sources or it's something I also know about.

> Well, I prefer the latter because it leads to a community where I can take more posts at face value and thus learn quicker.

Their is asking for clarification, and asking for clarification rudely, which is what I saw happening, as did others, I imagine. Their is value in asking for citations, no one questions that. The GP was clearly stating an opinion based on his own observations. The question in response was of little value because it was merely being antagonistic.

> I don't think it's unreasonable to encourage this kind of behaviour.

Peppering phrases with weasel words? People should just say what they think, rather than qualify every statement with qualifying statements. Case in point:

> It seems to have very little cost.

Citation needed.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by tome on Sunday June 09, 2013 @04:38PM (#5850480)
Your response makes me wonder if we're even talking about the same issue.

> > It seems to have very little cost.

> Citation needed.

Yes you're right. I should have said "I think it seems to have very little cost".

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by jasonlotito on Sunday June 09, 2013 @08:55PM (#5851583)
> Your response makes me wonder if we're even talking about the same issue.

We are. That you are confused is clear by other remarks, and it's almost time for GoT, so I don't feel like spending the time restating what has already been said.

> I should have said...

I know what you meant. I didn't really need a citation. I've already made it clear my stance on the matter.

However, that you would make such an error and then question whether we are talking about the same issue should be troublesome for you. In a topic on this very subject, you yourself can't meet your own standards of clarity. So, if you said something different then what you meant, how can you presume to understand those that attempt to hold conversations with you?

It's far easy to assume opinion then to assume perfect English. Especially on a board where English is not always the first language, and the subtleties of "It seems to have very little cost" and "I think it seems to have very little cost" is meaningless to all but a rare few.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by ctdonath on Sunday June 09, 2013 @02:23PM (#5849900)
Nothing.

What is wrong is nitpicking apart the nuanced difference when it was just a casual intelligent comment made in a social setting, where reasonable expectation is to get the point rather than belabor its numerous subtle variants pursuant to wanton misinterpretation.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by saraid216 on Sunday June 09, 2013 @02:33PM (#5849939)
Personally, I've given up on misinterpretation and just assume bad faith when it comes to comments shaped like the thread parent's. I dismiss and, by virtue of scrolling down, take a look at the respondents to see if anyone has anything useful to sub in.
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by naasking on Sunday June 09, 2013 @10:40AM (#5849040)
Well, as but one example, computer crimes are more harshly punished than in the past, and sometimes get harsher sentences than causing bodily harm.
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by gasull on Sunday June 09, 2013 @02:03PM (#5849828)
"Hacker Faces More Jail Time Than The Convicted Steubenville Rapists He Exposed"

http://techcrunch.com/2013/06/09/hacker-faces-more-jail-time...

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by dragontamer on Sunday June 09, 2013 @11:18AM (#5849173)
And for another, we used to wait till people were sentenced / punished before claiming that they were punished.

This is an article about their prosecution. Prosecutors push for the maximum sentence that they can possibly get, and have done so since the dawn of time. Whether or not they are _actually_ sentenced depends on the judge.

As far as I can tell, this is a hit-piece by the defense team of these three individuals to drum up public support, and hope for a reduced sentence.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by coldtea on Sunday June 09, 2013 @01:06PM (#5849596)
>And for another, we used to wait till people were sentenced / punished before claiming that they were punished. This is an article about their prosecution. Prosecutors push for the maximum sentence that they can possibly get, and have done so since the dawn of time. Whether or not they are _actually_ sentenced depends on the judge.

One: how did that work out for Aaron Swartz? I'm asking because the same BS was said in the defence of the prosecutors actions then.

Second: Citation needed, that prosecutors have "since the dawn of time" pushed for the same kind of sentences in the same kind of cases. Merely pushing for a little more doesn't qualify -- this is an extreme blow up of the actual offence here.

Third: I'm appalled by your casual dismissal of this, as "it's how it's always been". Even with the actual sentencing depending on the judge, this over-blowing of offences is a moral and legal problem that should stop. The prosecutors should push for the sentence that is appropriate to the crime, as they perceive it, not to "the maximum sentence they can possibly get". Their job is to serve justice, not to put as many people in jail as they can.

Fourth: Who said that asking for the "maximum sentence" is a harmless tactic? Who said it doesn't impact the jury's decision and the sentence that the judge will give? If the offence is something that should get 10 years in prison, and they ask for life, then maybe this will provoke a sentence of 15 years. The same tactic also can lead to innocent people plea to guilty, instead of risking a potential 5 or 10 years in prison (where they would actually take their chance for their actual lower appropriate sentence).

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by dragontamer on Monday June 10, 2013 @11:24AM (#5855015)
Aaron Swartz decided it wasn't worth fighting the good fight. I hate to speak ill of the dead, but it was his decision to give up, not his defense team's. It is very difficult to call someone who commits suicide a Martyr. I'm sorry, but that is how it is.

No one knows how Aaron Swartz's case could have ended up. All we know is that he gave up... in the way that hurt his friends and family the most.

Prosecutors push for the maximum because we have an adversarial system in the USA. It is the prosecutor's job to push for the worst, and it is the Judge / Jury's job to decide when the prosecutor has gone too far. It is the defense team's job to argue against the prosecutor.

If you don't know what an "adversarial system" is, start here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adversarial_system

It is the Judge and jury's job to give the correct sentence, not the prosecutor's job.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by tzs on Sunday June 09, 2013 @12:10PM (#5849388)
> Well, as but one example, computer crimes are more harshly punished than in the past

Computer crimes cause more damage than in the past.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by aptwebapps on Sunday June 09, 2013 @12:34PM (#5849482)
What about Weev? Specifically, the crime he was charged with, not whatever other stuff he got up to before. There was zero damage from that, except to AT&T's reputation.
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by naasking on Sunday June 09, 2013 @12:28PM (#5849456)
DDoS hardly cause damage, just loss of revenue, yet they carry very stiff penalties.
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by NoPiece on Sunday June 09, 2013 @12:38PM (#5849501)
If you've ever had to stay up all night trying to get a site back up during a DDoS attack you'd know there was more damage than just lost revenue.
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by Glyptodon on Sunday June 09, 2013 @02:15PM (#5849869)
Not decades in prison worth of damage.
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by tptacek on Sunday June 09, 2013 @04:15PM (#5850386)
Has someone been sentenced to decades in prison for DDoS attacks?
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by Falling3 on Sunday June 09, 2013 @01:54PM (#5849792)
Legal damages precisely include lost revenue.
Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by einhverfr on Sunday June 09, 2013 @10:33PM (#5851962)
I think the reference is to the war on whistleblowers. That part is more common. Also it is true that protesters are treated worse more recently than they have been for a few decades.

The problem though is that if you go back more than a few decades, it is not clear the trend is downward so much as cyclical.

Re:How three pacifists were convicted as terrorists by fpp on Sunday June 09, 2013 @05:07PM (#5850609)
We have seemingly already gone back that far into dark times that any criticism can only be voices as comedy, fairy tales or sarcasm - here's the one for this:

How do you know that monopoly is an old game - because the rich also go to jail.