News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rand Paul Bill Would Curb NSA on Phone Records by uvdiv on Saturday June 08, 2013 @07:35PM (#5846756)
Text of the proposed law:

"The Fourth Amendment to the Constitution shall not be construed to allow any agency of the United States Government to search the phone records of Americans without a warrant based on probable cause."

http://www.paul.senate.gov/files/documents/EAS13699.pdf

("Fourth Amendment Restoration Act of 2013")

Re:Rand Paul Bill Would Curb NSA on Phone Records by dkulchenko on Saturday June 08, 2013 @08:15PM (#5846877)
Is that the entire bill?

Seems extremely narrow-scoped and with no terms defined. IIRC, the ongoing spying is not even warrantless - they're operating under a broad-scope warrant issued by FISC, so this bill would do absolutely nothing.

Re:Rand Paul Bill Would Curb NSA on Phone Records by uvdiv on Saturday June 08, 2013 @08:23PM (#5846903)
Yes, the entire rulemaking part.

It's true the Verizon spying had a secret-court FISA warrant, but was that warrant required to have "probable cause"?

Re:Rand Paul Bill Would Curb NSA on Phone Records by mpyne on Saturday June 08, 2013 @08:45PM (#5846972)
I believe the answer might actually be yes to that as well. Remember the NSA treats analysis (search) of information as different from collection of information.

Doesn't matter though, the proposed law talks about search of American phone records which the NSA is already forbidden (even with PRISM) from looking at.

In other words the new content of this law would be exactly zero, if that's all it purports to add.

Re:Rand Paul Bill Would Curb NSA on Phone Records by einhverfr on Saturday June 08, 2013 @11:12PM (#5847377)
Is it more likely than not that looking at all social graph info from phone records over an indefinite period of time will show evidence of terrorist activity? If so, probable cause is met.

What's lacking is particularity which is entirely missing in the text of that law.

Re:Rand Paul Bill Would Curb NSA on Phone Records by mtgx on Sunday June 09, 2013 @01:48AM (#5847740)
Haven't you heard? The way they do it now is that the NSA secretly spies on people, and then they give the info to FBI, which now has "probable cause".

These guys are hellbent on finding every possible loophole in the Constitution, and (ab)using it to the extreme. They've forgot all about the spirit of the Constitution.

It must help that they have a Constitutional lawyer in office helping them discover all these loopholes. And here we thought that because he was a Constitutional lawyer, he was going to use that knowledge to uphold the Constitution. The joke's on us, I guess.

Re:Rand Paul Bill Would Curb NSA on Phone Records by gizmo686 on Saturday June 08, 2013 @11:26PM (#5847412)
As someone without training in law, that wording seems extremely odd.

It seems like it is not a piece of legislation, but rather an interpretation of the amendment; where I thought that interpreting the constitution was the job of the court. If this wording works, than wouldn't it give Congress the ability to work around the constitution simply by passing laws saying that <insert clause here> shall be interpreted to make <insert law here> constitutional.

Re:Rand Paul Bill Would Curb NSA on Phone Records by anigbrowl on Sunday June 09, 2013 @12:38AM (#5847603)
Yeah, it's just grandstanding designed to impress the simple-minded.
Re:Rand Paul Bill Would Curb NSA on Phone Records by saraid216 on Sunday June 09, 2013 @04:57AM (#5848126)
More importantly, it's an indication that the average citizen who he expects to hear about this wouldn't realize how superficial it is.

It got on Hacker News.

Re:Rand Paul Bill Would Curb NSA on Phone Records by loteck on Saturday June 08, 2013 @11:17PM (#5847396)
As has been covered, the government already obtains a FISA warrant in order to "search" the records they are gathering en masse.

Nice try, Rand, but some people still read the text of bills.