News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by gyardley on Friday June 07, 2013 @06:17PM (#5842390)
While you never know who's armed and who's not, in these cases they're probably just as worried about the destruction of evidence - a polite knock on the door and an 'excuse me, sir, we're the FBI' might give him time to erase or destroy something.
Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by pyre on Friday June 07, 2013 @06:30PM (#5842484)

  | While you never know who's armed and who's not
This may be true, but if the person has no history of violence, isn't wanted for a violent offence, has no registered firearms, and is not known to have any radical anti-government / Michigan Militia-type views, then there is probably no reason for such an armed assault.

  | in these cases they're probably just as worried
  | about the destruction of evidence
So a group of men armed with assault rifles is necessary to prevent destruction of evidence, because a couple of agents armed with handguns would have encouraged resistance?
Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by mpyne on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:43PM (#5843074)
"Registered firearms" in a nation with the 2nd Amendment? Even in states that require it I wouldn't trust that info with my life. :)

And either way I don't see why you'd not be OK with rifles but would be OK with handguns. Once you're OK with the arresting officers being armed the rest is just a matter of degree.

Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by pyre on Friday June 07, 2013 @09:41PM (#5843277)

  | the rest is just a matter of degree.
Exactly. Sending a couple of armed officers vs. a SWAT team with snipers and helicopters. Let's not forget that the US taxpayers are footing the bill if every arrest involves a highly-trained 10-person team donning assault rifles, etc.
Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by gyardley on Friday June 07, 2013 @11:07PM (#5843566)
Man, I don't know. If I was a lot stupider and could get the drop on them, I might like my chances against two agents with handguns.

A SWAT team, on the other hand - I don't care how dumb, drunk, or high I am, if ten officers with heavy weaponry come with a helicopter escort, I know I'm going to lose.

Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by pyre on Friday June 07, 2013 @11:21PM (#5843594)
Same with a tank, and the National Guard. Should they get involved too? :P
Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by mpyne on Friday June 07, 2013 @11:32PM (#5843624)
A tank would have a much higher risk of needless collateral damage compared to rifles, and the NG couldn't play anyways due to Posse Comitatus Act restrictions (except possibly if they were activated under the state governor's authority, I forget the specifics).

Either way the comment didn't say that "more force is always better" like you seem to go along with, only that a couple of agents with handguns are in a different category than a bunch of agents with rifles available. But once you have a bunch of agents with rifles, adding a tank or soldiers doesn't significantly change the risk equation for the Feds so even their ORM analysis would say not to do it.

Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by newbie12 on Friday June 07, 2013 @10:45PM (#5843472)
Only five states require firearms registration (as opposed to the near-universal, one-time federal background check at purchase).
Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by jessaustin on Friday June 07, 2013 @10:05PM (#5843353)
In this circumstance, police used to just detain the guy after he left for work, or after the whole family went out to eat. Very few houses are occupied 24 hours a day.

The problem with that policy was that police didn't get to shoot enough dogs.

Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by icebraining on Friday June 07, 2013 @06:21PM (#5842419)
Is there no middle ground?
Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by vampirechicken on Friday June 07, 2013 @07:00PM (#5842643)
If they don't use the gear, they can't justify it.
Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by damoncali on Friday June 07, 2013 @09:21PM (#5843209)
While I'm no cop and such actions are concerning to me - let me play devil's advocate. If you have to train a group of men to apprehend a wide variety of suspects/fugitives/badguys in a manner that is fast, effective, and as safe as possible, it makes sense that you keep the procedures, tactics, and equipment used consistent.

After all, pointing an M16 at someone wont hurt them any more than pointing a .38 special at them, but it's a hell of a lot less tempting to run/fight back against an overwhelming force.

That they seem heavy handed in this case is just a result of it being on the edge of the range they need to cover.

Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by icebraining on Friday June 07, 2013 @09:33PM (#5843256)
All of that makes sense under the premise that the SWAT team should be used to apprehend an individual which is not know to be part of any criminal group nor has committed a violent act.
Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by damoncali on Friday June 07, 2013 @09:59PM (#5843335)
I suspect they wanted to get in very quickly, but I think it might have made more sense to send two guys to wait for him to come out of his house rather than send 12 to kick in his door. I have limits as to how far I can argue their point. It does seem somewhat excessive. But you never know the details.
Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by lostlogin on Friday June 07, 2013 @09:12PM (#5843169)
While >in America< you never.... This reads better. In other countries you could never rule it out either, but the chance is magnitudes smaller.