News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do It Yourself Biohacking by dkarl on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @12:01PM (#583371)
What? You say you’ve never had a day of genetic engineering lessons? You don’t remember anything from high school biology? Well luckily for you,joining the DIYbio community is as simple as going to DIYbio.org and reading the forums.

So now I can become a bio script kiddie?

I don't see the point of following some instructions and congratulating myself on the results. Should I feel cool by association with the practicing biologists who figure out the principles, design the gear, and write up the instructions? What's the point unless you understand what you're doing and create something novel, with unique value?

There are plenty of hobbies where you don't have to be accomplished or original to give pleasure to yourself and your friends. Cooking and baking, for example. I can't imagine spending my time on DIY biology unless I decide to go hard-core into the subject.

Re:Do It Yourself Biohacking by HeyLaughingBoy on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @12:12PM (#583410)
A different way to think of it is that you're reading someone else's source code in order to learn from it. Just because that's where you start, doesn't mean you can progress beyond that point.
Re:Do It Yourself Biohacking by dkarl on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @03:12PM (#583795)
The problem is that in a biology lab, there's a lot more behind the materials and the tools than there is behind source code, and stuff isn't as neatly parameterized. Just from high school biology I can name three different ways to create a vaccine for a virus, and checking my knowledge on Wikipedia reveals a bunch more. Yet there are still many viruses we can't vaccinate against. Stuff in biology is incredibly complex and specific. Adapting a successful technique to a very slightly different situation can be straightforward, or it can be a major research project. You could easily pick, as your first "original" project, something that would require a scientific breakthrough to accomplish, and it would take you years to advance to the point of even realizing it. If that sounds rewarding to you, you're probably already professionally involved in an intellectual field deeply enough that you want your hobbies to have entirely different rewards and challenges.

Feynman's memoirs are some of the most intellectually macho posturing I've ever read, and even he stuck mostly to physics when he was doing physics. He favored hobbies like safecracking, drumming, and drawing, all of which could be summed up as showing off and getting laid. People looking for a professional-level intellectual challenge from their hobbies are in the wrong line of work.

Re:Do It Yourself Biohacking by Femur on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @12:04PM (#583382)
I would love tweaking with some stuff, but I guess it would be an extension of my current hobby of growing tropical plants. Making mango's purple, or kiwis caffeinated...

I would put some serious time into a hobby like that if the resources were available.