News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Cross-Platform Myth by patio11 on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @11:07AM (#583214)
My Mac-using business associates have told me a hundred times that my (Java Swing) program is an abomination unto the eyes of Jobs and will never sell until I embrace the One True Way to do a Mac interface. (I'm a Windows programmer at heart and my Mac port most certainly has issues -- some of which I'm cognizant of, and some of which I addressed over the years.)

But regardless of my friends' feelings on the matter, my stats just do not say that Mac users are rejecting the program. They convert at fully twice the rate of Windows users. If anything I need to look at what I've screwed up in doing a Windows-y interface that wasn't Windows-y enough, apparently!

Re:The Cross-Platform Myth by 9oliYQjP on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @11:39AM (#583307)
Do you have any competition? Mac users will tolerate a Java Swing app. But once a native Cocoa (or even Carbon) equivalent app (most features/functionality being the same) comes out, they'll switch.

I hate using Java Swing apps. It's an accumulation of minor irritants that cause this hatred:

1. the inability to interact with OS X Services;

2. copy/paste not working exactly like Cocoa apps;

3. font rendering being messed up;

4. the fact that the menu system is usually different than a Cocoa app and that I can't customize keyboard shortcuts as easily.

.

.

.

However, the presence of all of these irritants doesn't mean I won't tolerate a Java Swing app if I absolutely must, because there isn't another feature/functionality equivalent application out there.

Re:The Cross-Platform Myth by reitzensteinm on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @11:28AM (#583274)
I doubt it's hurting your sales much, but just because your Mac conversion rate is 2x your Windows conversion rate it doesn't mean it's not hurting at all. Mac conversion rates for shareware seem to be way higher overall (certainly been my experience).
Re:The Cross-Platform Myth by mcav on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @11:15AM (#583236)
Yeah. Unfortunately (or fortunately, depending on your position), users are often content with "good enough". The apps I mentioned (Adobe CS4, Firefox, MS Office) obviously haven't suffered in the marketplace. People complain, but enough buy that it really isn't a huge issue.

That said, having a truly native interface can't hurt: if you were to pit a native interface against a non-native one, the non-native application would have a hard time competing.

Re:The Cross-Platform Myth by CalmQuiet on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @12:15PM (#583416)
But I think that the three examples you mention have very little competition ( or competition that has major problems) for OS X users.