News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Painful Decision by hvs on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @10:38AM (#583171)
I'm not a member of the Rails community, so I'm curious as to why this "Women in Programming" issue seems to focused solely on that community. Women are underrepresented in almost all development communities and it seems odd to focus on one specific community. It would be strange to talk about "the lack of female representation in the C++ community" rather than the development community in general, so why is this different?

I'm not trying to stir the pot or anything, I'm legitimately curious.

Re:A Painful Decision by mechanical_fish on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @12:02PM (#583374)
All I know about this is what I learned from Giles Bowkett:

http://www.ultrasaurus.com/sarahblog/2009/04/gender-and-sex-...

who sounds dead-on correct to me:

I put huge slides with four-letter words on the screen when I give presentations, but it never makes anybody feel uncomfortable. But that’s because there’s an art to these things, and I know every time I do it that I might go too far and have to eat my pride and apologize. You did it wrong. The fact that anybody blogged about it means you did it wrong. So you have to just accept that and be a man about it instead of arguing with her. If a woman tells you that putting giant sexually suggestive images in front of her made her uncomfortable, you don’t get to bicker about that.

It's not so much that the Rails community has a particularly unusual problem with women. It's that, when one tone-deaf guy lights a match at a Rails conference, apparently nobody knows how to put out the fire before it burns down the community. It's a shame.

Re:A Painful Decision by Tichy on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @05:10PM (#584034)
What if that woman happend to be a member of an ultrareligious sect and has no humor whatsoever. What if other women don't mind at all? Don't know what incident happened (was there an incident?), but is it not yet another cliche that women in general have to be offended by certain pictures? What about the women IN the pictures, would they be offended?

I don't want to recommend to use offensive pictures in presentations (some men might be offended, too), but I am pretty sure that such things are NOT the reason for "underrepresentedness" of women.

Re:A Painful Decision by menloparkbum on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @05:20PM (#584052)
What if one of the women in the audience was your mom? What if one of the women in the presentation is your mom? What if you're the conductor of a train and you're approaching a fork in the track: If you steer one way, you'll run over five porn stars. If you steer the other way, you'll run into a presenter at RailsConf. What if this conversation never ends? What if we're all just living inside of a computer simulation? Woah.
Re:A Painful Decision by joecode on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @05:34PM (#584069)
You are. Just you, tho.
Re:A Painful Decision by joecode on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @03:33PM (#583848)
"If a woman tells you that putting giant sexually suggestive images in front of her made her uncomfortable, you don’t get to bicker about that."

Isn't this a sexist viewpoint itself? As if a woman's reasoning doesn't matter, just that you have offended, oh my, a female?

Re:A Painful Decision by mechanical_fish on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @04:31PM (#583966)
I have no idea what you're talking about. But, nevertheless: It doesn't matter who you offend or why. If a person comes up to you and says "I'm not really a person; I'm really a tower of cats in a cunningly designed human suit, and your LOLcat photos offended me," the correct answer is still "Gosh, I'm terribly sorry. I didn't mean to offend. I really had no idea that cats would take my presentation in that way."

After which you back carefully away and hope they don't come to your next talk.

You should not respond with a passionate defense of free expression unless the person who approaches you is a cop trying to arrest you. [1] In general, nobody is trying to deny you the right to advertise your beliefs out loud. When they complain, you should assume that they are merely inviting you to walk back what you said before they commence avoiding you like the plague.

Of course, if you really hate cats, you can always just respond with "good, I'm glad I offended you, you terrifying feline monstrosity!" Because very few Rails consulting customers are cats, that might not cost you much. Although, come to think of it, some Rails customers probably do employ cats, or people who love cats and care about their feelings. And there are many others who will feel mighty uncomfortable when the managers of the framework that lies beneath their million-dollar website become more concerned with aggressively asserting the universal freedom to hate cats than with keeping people like Mike Gunderloy on the team. What kind of priority is that? Enough with the sophomoric flamewar, already!

---

[1] In which case, of course, you still shouldn't respond with a passionate defense. You should call up your lawyer and let her respond.

Re:A Painful Decision by joecode on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @05:32PM (#584066)
That's pretty hillarious. But still I think it is useful when you offend a person to try to understand why. If there's something to it, then you apologize, and learn a lesson. But if you apologize wihtout learning anything, your apology is an empty one. Meanwhile, if they're just being hyper-sensitive for no good reason, I am quite happy to pop their bubble.
Re:A Painful Decision by mechanical_fish on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @06:11PM (#584130)
if you apologize wihtout learning anything, your apology is an empty one.

Not at all. The apology -- which one should issue immediately and without hesitation -- is full of meaning. Very important meaning. Just not literal meaning.

What is the apology saying?

"I hear you and I understand that you were really offended."

"I am trying to listen to you."

"I am not trying to hurt you on purpose."

"I am not trying to deliberately start a giant flame war that tears our community apart."

"I am open to reconsidering what I said, and the way I said it, in light of your interpretation of my words."

"I have basic social skills and recognize the role of Apologizer when I see it." (See: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=240170 )

What the apology is not: An admission of guilt, an admission that you did something illegal or even something wrong. You do not have to break down in tears. You don't have to agree with the complainer. You don't have to change your mind.

What you have to do is signal some sympathy: That you're a civilized person who is open to "trying to understand" the offended person. That you want to de-escalate the situation rather than start a fight. That you're not a troll -- that is, someone who (a) deliberately introduces a topic that is likely to be offensive and then (b) continues to push the buttons of any offended people until a giant flame war breaks out.

Re:A Painful Decision by joecode on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @06:32PM (#584158)
There's some truth to that, of course. But I don't think apologies should always be issued, in any circumstances. Coddling people is often annoying. It slows things down and keeps people from being direct with one another. Sometimes a fight is actually better. Also, a little bit of confrontation keeps people from raising too many spurious complaints.

Which method works better all depends on the circumstances, I guess.

Re:A Painful Decision by raganwald on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @03:52PM (#583901)
One could equally say that if I tell you that putting the word "Nigger" in a slide makes me feel uncomfortable, you don't get to bicker about that. It's just one of those things that matter if other people's feelings matter.

I discovered this the hard way when I repeated a joke about Jews to a Jewish friend. As she put it, "Jokes are all in the delivery, and you have to be Jewish to deliver that joke."

Re:A Painful Decision by joecode on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @05:14PM (#584042)
No, its not really the same thing. Because there is a very obvious reason that people are upset by that word. My point is merely that you need to explain your reasons, not merely point out your skin color or gender, as if that itself were a reason. Your Jewish friend, for example, has given a very good reason for why jokes about Jews by non-Jews are generally offensive.

In fact, there are cases where using that word in a presentation would be perfectly legitimate, i.e. in a presentation about racist epithets. If someone objected to that, I would bicker with them, regardless of their skin color.

Re:A Painful Decision by raganwald on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @06:47PM (#584186)
Your Jewish friend, for example, has given a very good reason for why jokes about Jews by non-Jews are generally offensive

By way of conversation, not argument, I will share that at the time, her explanation was unsatisfying. I felt that she was saying "You Can't Say That" arbitrarily. Why was it ok for one person to tell that joke and not another? I didn't feel she was explaining the reasoning behind the rule, just telling me the rule.

But time has passed, and now I understand that a joke about cultural stereotypes often means one thing when told by an outsider, another thing when told by an insider to an outsider, and a third thing when told by an insider to another insider.

And of course, outsiders are sometimes oblivious to the nuances.

Re:A Painful Decision by decode on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @10:59AM (#583202)
I'm not in the Ruby community, but here's what I've gathered:

There was a talk at the Golden Gate Ruby Conference called "CouchDB + Ruby: Perform Like a Pr0n Star", which featured an extended porn-industry metaphor and what some have described as softcore porn in the slides. This talk created a lot of discussion in the Ruby community, in particular about the effect this kind of talk has on the female attendees, and the general atmosphere of the conference. It also caused the Ruby community to introspect on what kind of environment they are creating and how it affects people who are not heterosexual males who may wish to participate in that community.

See the links posted above by swombat for some of the discussion.

Re:A Painful Decision by dkarl on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @12:16PM (#583417)
Wow, and some people think the "social skills for nerds" links are off-topic for HN. Clearly many people in computing are ruled by their adolescent impulse to make people uncomfortable, at great cost to the community. Worse, they congratulate themselves for it. For the general good, here's the Cliff's notes for making people uncomfortable:

1. Gratuitous transgression is easy.

2. Necessary transgression is art -- intrinsically critical and enlightening. It's hard to pull off.

3. Compulsive transgression with no regard to the difference between #1 and #2 is juvenile.

Re:A Painful Decision by hvs on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @11:21AM (#583255)
Huh. Yeah, I could see how that might generate discussion.

As a heterosexual male, I would be uncomfortable being at a presentation that used pornographic imagery throughout. Call me a prude, but certain things simply don't belong in a professional environment.

Re:A Painful Decision by batasrki on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @12:01PM (#583368)
Not only that, but when the issue was brought into the spotlight, the "leaders" of the Rails community dismissed as "edgy". Some have even applauded it. This is a major reason for Mike leaving.
Re:A Painful Decision by raganwald on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @03:28PM (#583828)
When the issue was brought into the spotlight, the "leaders" of the Rails community dismissed as "edgy".

Porn is not edgy. Walking into Oracle's Head Office and shitting on their conference table is edgy.

http://twitter.com/raganwald/status/1641756320

Re:A Painful Decision by Tichy on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @05:13PM (#584040)
So are there even less women in Rails than in other IT sectors? Or is it all just speculation? I could imagine applauding someone taking a stand against political correctness in certain circumstances.
Re:A Painful Decision by badger7 on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @12:05PM (#583387)
Ditto. I used to be a member of a guitar forum where religion was banned from discussion. All well and good, but I left in the end because whilst it wasn't discussed, I couldn't stand to read endless lyrics about the wonder of god, and every other piece of advice being to "join in with your local church band". You can, apparently, smother a whole lot of guitar discussion with just a smattering of religion, and all without any actual discussion. In the end, I wasn't comfortable there due to something that was nothing at all to do with guitars.

I can ignore religion when I want to, and I can destroy an illogical belief system with the best of 'em, but, I'm much more likely to just find somewhere with less barriers to the subject at hand. It was unprofessional of them to disallow discussion of religion with wishy-washy rules, and it's unprofessional to plaster coding in porn, soft or otherwise.

Re:A Painful Decision by Tichy on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @05:49PM (#584099)
Found it on slideshare: http://www.slideshare.net/mattetti/couchdb-perform-like-a-pr...

So it was one guys idea of a joke - big deal (and no actual nudity).

Re:A Painful Decision by swombat on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @10:40AM (#583175)
Actually, just last week there was a panel on "women in technology" at Geeknrolla, so it's definitely not a rails-only issue.

More info here: http://uk.techcrunch.com/2009/04/23/just-a-girl-why-we-put-o...

Re:A Painful Decision by hvs on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @10:45AM (#583179)
Oh, I definitely don't believe it is a Rails-only issue, it just seemed odd that the loudest discussion going on right now seemed to be focused on Rails. It just feels odd to attach it to a specific technology.
Re:A Painful Decision by curoi on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @11:35AM (#583291)
It most certainly isn't a Rails-only issue. Women in technology seems to be a perennial discussion point with little change in the composition nor the results.

One reason that Rails seems to be the loudest right now is because Rails attracts (and was begun) by very outspoken, opinionated, people.

Re:A Painful Decision by dkarl on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @06:07PM (#584123)
I think some progress is being made in terms of making workplaces more hospitable to women. Sexual harassment has been a recognized issue for a long time now, but geeks consider themselves too passive and harmless to harass anybody, so they have been slow to catch on. The underrepresentation of women in technology has stimulated some self-reflection about how the workplace atmosphere might put off technologically capable and interested women.
Re:A Painful Decision by Tichy on Tuesday April 28, 2009 @06:35PM (#584162)
Still wondering how the "underrepresentation" is being measured. Who defines the appropriate percentage of women in technology, so that we can conclude that there are too few of them?

While I would prefer to have more female colleagues, I don't believe men and women can be compared just like that.