News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by Samuel_Michon on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:58AM (#5826422)
> track down the producers of child porn

Nowadays, the vast majority of producers of ‘child porn’ are kids themselves. The combination of webcams, Internet access, and sexual curiosity guarantees that images of underage nudity will only be more prevalent as time goes on.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by ErrantX on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @12:03PM (#5826464)
That's simply not true. CP is a massive black market business - operated by sex slave gangs in various parts of the world (e.g. Eastern Europe).

They are sophisticated and wealthy operations, which is why it is next to impossible to make any inroads into catching them.

Hence targeting the consumers (which I agree is like closing the stable door...)

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by Dylan16807 on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @02:14PM (#5827442)
Okay maybe comments get dead from certain words in them. Let me try reposting a redacted version of Samuel_Michon's post:

I think you’re missing my point: there are millions of teens experimenting on the Internet, [...] in front of webcams. The number of people involved with what you describe is orders of magnitude smaller.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by Samuel_Michon on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @02:36PM (#5827594)
Thanks for that, and best use of ‘[...]’ ever. Given how people think, those blanks will be filled in with way dirtier words than I used before.
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by ErrantX on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @02:58PM (#5827784)
I missed your use of the word "producers" in the original post. So, yes, raw numbers... but that's only a minore part of the picture.

The kind of material you describe is very much borderline, and not really the sort of CP that the law is largely concerned with (despite the high profile examples that hit the media).

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by Samuel_Michon on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @03:27PM (#5827980)
> The kind of material you describe is very much borderline

Do you think there are limits to what young people will do in front of a webcam? Or do you believe only older teens perform such acts? Which part do you think is considered ‘borderline’ by law?

> not really the sort of CP that the law is largely concerned with

I’d be very interested in a copy of the book you’ve got that mentions which laws count and which ones don’t. As you admitted to yourself, there have been plenty of cases in which teens using webcams have been convicted for producing and distributing child porn.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by ErrantX on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @08:02PM (#5829521)
> Do you think there are limits to what young people will do in front of a webcam?

You misunderstand; by borderline I mean that the observed age of the participant is subjective. And it relates back to the age old issue; at 17 years 364 days it's illegal, the next it's legal.

As an expert analyst you have to give it some degree of leeway because it's very hard to judge the difference.

> Or do you believe only older teens perform such acts?

Well, yes, to a certain extent. It's getting worse because younger generations are more sexualised, but for younger teens on-webcam activities are more often related to coercion (MSN is still a favourite avenue for grooming).

> As you admitted to yourself, there have been plenty of cases in which teens using webcams have been convicted for producing and distributing child porn.

Plenty amongst.. millions (by your count). I never saw a case (out of the hundreds I worked on and many more I saw) of that sort, but when they happen they make the media (because, rightfully, it is ridiculous).

The guidance may have changed in recent months, as I am not 100% current, but not very long ago CPS feedback was that prosecutions were targeted at those seeking younger pornography, particularly of the "commercial" variety, or those actively grooming youngsters.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by cabalamat on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @05:57PM (#5828916)
The argument against piracy is it reduces the amount of new content that gets produced.

If states believe this argument, they should legalise the distribution of child porn where no money changes hands. Alternately, if they don't believe it, they should stop trying to shut down The Pirate Bay and other Torrent sites.

They cannot have it both ways, without being hypocrites.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by netrus on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @01:02PM (#5826923)
The CP topic is not about teenagers, but about children less than 10 years (you might easily find a 18+ photo model that looks like 14 if that's your thing). Last time I checked, sexting was not a big issue around kindergartens...
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by Samuel_Michon on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @01:14PM (#5827034)
> The CP topic is not about teenagers, but about children less than 10 years

I don’t know where you get that idea. The law makes no such distinction. Nude depictions of individuals who appear to be younger than 18 years of age are usually illegal. In many countries, this includes drawings and animations. In other countries, the subject doesn’t even have to be nude, striking a suggestive pose can make the image illegal.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by ErrantX on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @02:53PM (#5827737)
In practice the law is interpreted though. Not just for CP!

When an analyst looks through some images they have to make a subjective judgement because it is very hard to judge age in many cases.

To be clear; striking a suggestive pose is very very rarely illegal in itself. It may be classified on a relevant scale as part of the investigation (e.g. COPINE) but that is only because it is of obvious relevance to the charge/conviction.

If someone was caught with "suggestive" images on their computer in the UK, for example, the CPS wouldn't prosecute (because it's not actually illegal).

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by pessimizer on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @10:39PM (#5830054)
In practice (at least in the US), people have been prosecuted for images that were clearly of adults dressed as children, and images that were drawings of children.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_status_of_cartoon_pornog...

And though it was struck down in 2002:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_Pornography_Prevention_A...

In the UK, Operation Ore resulted in the arrests of 3,744 people, of which very few had any tangible evidence of having, ever purchasing, or accessing child pornography.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Ore

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by netrus on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @01:24PM (#5827107)
Have a look at Wikipedia: "Most possessors of child pornography who are arrested are found to possess images of prepubescent children; possessors of pornographic images of post-pubescent minors are less likely to be prosecuted, even though those images also fall within the statutes.[19]"
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by betterunix on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @02:17PM (#5827456)
Those prosecutions are rare because they are hard to win. If there were a reliable way to prove that a picture or video involves someone younger than 18, those prosecutions would be far more common. It is not as though the prosecutor receives a case of someone has pictures that appear to be of minors, and they say, "Gee, I think we can let this slide. Those girls are clearly sexually developed!"

At the end of the day, a prosecutor's career depends on their ability to win cases. Prosecutors choose cases they believe they can win, regardless of whether or not those cases actually make sense.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by Samuel_Michon on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @01:38PM (#5827225)
Thanks for confirming what I wrote earlier. If I drive 3 miles faster than the speed limit, I usually won’t have the highway patrol chasing me, but that doesn’t mean I’m not breaking the law.

Just because you don’t consider it child porn if it’s graphic depictions of persons over 10 years of age, that doesn’t mean it’s permitted by law.