News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by contingencies on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @11:31PM (#5823533)
The Wikipedia article at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flywheel_energy_storage claims that, in comparison to batteries, flywheels are not as adversely affected by temperature changes, can operate at a much wider temperature range, and are not subject to many of the common failures of chemical rechargeable batteries. They are also less potentially damaging to the environment, being largely made of inert or benign materials. A flywheel can potentially have an indefinite working lifespan. Flywheels built as part of James Watt steam engines have been continuously working for more than two hundred years. Another advantage of flywheels is that by a simple measurement of the rotation speed it is possible to know the exact amount of energy stored. Flywheels with Magnetic bearings and high vacuum can maintain 97% mechanical efficiency, and 85% round trip efficiency.

Why aren't these in wide deployment yet as local storage for renewable energy sources? The biggest problems seems to be overall mass, cost, and space efficiency. None are great concerns for long term energy storage solutions for off-grid buildings. In short, these things sound fantastic. Anyone know where to buy one large enough to store power for a small draw, solar sourced home?

This site explains a lot more about the concept, and engineering considerations behind two functional prototypes: http://home.earthlink.net/~fradella/homepage.htm

Flywheels in vehicles were the subject on an article in the Economist in late 2011: Road tests have shown that, thanks to modern materials and clever design, a flywheel as small as a hockey puck can reduce fuel consumption by more than one-fifth. In electric hybrids only 35% of the kinetic energy lost during braking is retrievable. With flywheels more than 70% is. http://www.economist.com/node/21540386

And someone just got funded on Kickstarter: http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1340066560/velkess-energ... .. they claim Energy storage flywheels have been in use for over 100 years and are some of the highest performing energy storage technologies ever developed. Traditionally, they have suffered one fatal flaw... they are extremely expensive! Velkess has invented a way of making energy storage flywheels at such low cost it will be dramatically less expensive than even the most economical energy storage technologies available today. Phys.org discussion of this effort: http://phys.org/news/2013-04-velkess-flywheel-flexible-energ...

Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by ars on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @01:33AM (#5823895)
The biggest problem is they don't store enough energy. Or in other words, they don't store enough per how much they cost.

The energy capacity goes up linearly by mass, but goes up by the speed squared. So all the effort has gone toward increasing the speed.

But the trouble is that the force on the flywheel also goes up by the speed squared. The only materials strong enough are wound carbon fibers - and they are very very costly.

If you increase the mass instead you need very very large and strong bearings, and they tend to fail. For high speed, low weight, you barely need any bearing at all - magnetic bearings are preferred if you can manage it.

Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by contingencies on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @01:51AM (#5823947)
Thanks for your summary.

The kickstarter project was targeting 15kWh which should be more than enough for a low draw residential setting. For a one-off prototype, they asked for US$50,000 funding.

Let's guestimate that with mass-manufacturing the same product could be built for US$30k, and that's going to provide a probable rated lifespan of around 20 years with zero maintenance.

Contrast batteries, which might cost 30% of that (random figure taken from a solar site) but only last 3-6 years. Sure, they are portable, but they are horrible for the environment and a pain to replace.

I still see a huge market for these.

See also a 1979 presentation from an MIT guy: http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1979STIN...8010639M Technical and economic performance analyses indicate that, contrary to general thought, a flywheel system will be competitive if not superior to more conventional systems utilizing either present day or advanced batteries. This derives from the ability of the flywheel to perform the functions of dc-to-ac inversion and optimal impedance matching between the PV arrays and the load in addition to providing energy storage.

Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by ars on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @02:08AM (#5823975)
> This derives from the ability of the flywheel to perform the functions of dc-to-ac inversion and optimal impedance matching between the PV arrays and the load in addition to providing energy storage.

We don't need this anymore. This stuff is easy with modern power electronics, so if this is what makes it competitive, then it's not.

I also suspect the reliability is not there yet for 20 year operation.

And it's not like people haven't tried - I've read about a large number of companies that have tried, and yet they all seem to vanish.

Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by jacquesm on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @03:53AM (#5824237)
Not all of them disappeared:

http://afstrinity.com/

It looks like they pivoted to other storage systems and are now finding their way back to flywheels.

Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by ars on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @03:57AM (#5824250)
They are one of the early ones: http://www.nytimes.com/1994/06/22/business/flywheels-to-powe...

But it's been 20 years and no flywheels ever made it to market.

Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by jacquesm on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @04:17AM (#5824288)
Actually, they did sell a whole pile of them for ride-through power in hospitals and other facilities where power availability is critical.
Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by ars on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @05:00AM (#5824402)
For land installation right? Not cars?

That's still cool though - are they still in use? Why don't they sell them now?

Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by jacquesm on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @06:48AM (#5824694)
Definitely not for mobile applications. I don't know why they don't sell them now, probably they got overtaken by developments in UPS technology. Since they started working on that we've seen 2 battery technology revolutions and a whole new family of semiconductors. On the plus side there are now usable passive magnetic bearings based on the Halbach principle and high tensile carbon compounds to help maintain structural integrity at high velocity.

Flywheels have always intrigued me, the planetary rotation is testimony to how much energy can be stored in one :) A couple of billion years and it's still spinning.

A few years ago AFS had a car prototype with a cluster of bottle sized high speed flywheels in the trunk and under the hood, it was quite a neat package but very expensive and limited range.

The most practical use of flywheels for transportation was probably the gyro bus, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gyrobus another concept that just won't die until someone brings enough garlic, silver and wooden stakes.

Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by contingencies on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @08:16AM (#5825053)
Another link on cars (trams in Holland actually, with backing from Alstom): http://sciencewriter.org/flywheels-spinning-into-control/
Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by contingencies on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @02:21AM (#5824004)
> We don't need this anymore

My understanding is that AC/DC conversion is lossy and rule of thumb figures online quote 10-15%.

> I also suspect the reliability is not there yet for 20 year operation.

A lot of products already on the market have 20 years lifespans quoted, eg. Socomec FLYWHEEL, Vycon.

> I've read about a large number of companies that have tried, and yet they all seem to vanish.

Sources? I am genuinely curious.

Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by ars on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @03:50AM (#5824231)
> My understanding is that AC/DC conversion is lossy

We don't need to do this all that often, and the flywheel is lossy too. And you can get 96% efficient power supplies http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/80_PLUS

Plus you can use http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotary_converter and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor-generator which are basically the same thing, minus the energy storage part.

> A lot of products already on the market have 20 years lifespans quoted, eg. Socomec FLYWHEEL, Vycon.

This could be new - I haven't been following this recently.

> Sources?

When people first started focusing on automobile energy efficiency flywheels were the thing. They eventually gave up and switched to hybrids, and/or batteries.

Note the date: http://www.nytimes.com/1994/06/22/business/flywheels-to-powe...

I don't really have any links from stories from years ago, but this one is high profile and recent:

http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2012/apr/9/feds-call-ban...

The stores would have a pattern: Some young new company proudly showing off its new technology to the fawning journalist - and then that would be the last you would ever hear of them. (Someone once told me to put their names in a google news alert then forget about it - most of the alerts would never trigger a second time.)

Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by contingencies on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @07:13AM (#5824795)
> We don't need to do [AC/DC conversion] all that often, and the flywheel is lossy too. And you can get 96% efficient...

Sure, even looking at that page 10-15% does seem a regular rule of thumb though. Many devices in the home (computers, displays, etc.) require DC. Photovoltaics produce DC, but not necessarily at a level suitable for variable, direct load by devices. So in a sustainable source powered situation, you have to pay for this loss somewhere: either in storage or inversion or both. It would seem that the 1979 author was refering to the flywheel's potential toremove the 'double tax' for storage and inversion. The listed 'motor generator' benefits (load and spike isolation, etc.) would also seem to apply.

> this one is high profile and recent

Beacon are often referenced. It seems they were revived and the major facility they built is still in operation. They cited a combination of DOE policy and 'the current political environment' as their cause of temporary bankruptcy.

Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by gcb0 on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @12:53AM (#5823779)
Because you can't shake it.
Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by contingencies on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @12:55AM (#5823784)
Surely if it's buried, as seems to be the general consensus for cheapest mode of safe deployment, then it doesn't shake? Also, these have been deployed successfully in cars and on various other types of vehicles (cranes, etc.) so the physical stability issue is certainly not a big one. My high school physics is terrible but the keyword vacuum might have something to do with that. Data centers would be concerned about safety in earthquakes, too, but flywheels like this one seem widely deployed: http://www.socomec.com/range-dynamic-energy-storage_en.html?...
Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by dredmorbius on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @01:55AM (#5823951)
"Surely if it's buried, as seems to be the general consensus for cheapest mode of safe deployment, then it doesn't shake?"

The ground occasionally shakes, depending on where you are.

The Earth also rotates on its axis. And with the speeds and energies with which grid storage flywheels operate, that's a significant engineering concern.

The real killer though is cost / KWh of energy storage. For Beacon's designs it's about $10,000/KWh capacity (not $1000/Wh as I wrote above). Which is high. Liquid metal or molten salt batteries, or simple thermal storage (again, likely salt) could likely compete with this.

Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by ars on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @03:54AM (#5824241)
> The Earth also rotates on its axis. And with the speeds and energies with which grid storage flywheels operate, that's a significant engineering concern.

You can align the angle of the flywheel to match the angle of the earth at your latitude, which helps with that. However if you do that the flywheel is titled, so the bearings are uneven, and then you need some shielding above the flywheel - you can't just have the earth be the walls.

But it means that the bearings experience much less force, so it can be worth it.