News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by graue on Monday June 03, 2013 @02:40AM (#5811724)
People really just don't seem to understand that experiences with social media are specific to the individual. I guess it's understandable. I see the same Google Maps as everyone else does. I see the same Hacker News as everyone else who visits HN.

But Facebook isn't like that. Your Facebook timeline is based entirely on your friends and how you interact with Facebook.

And so, every few weeks it seems, we get these posts from some techie who believes that his (it's always a man) experiences with social media are universal.

It just ain't so. This may be a pat little summary of why using Facebook is unrewarding for the author, but to generalize that to a "failed" experiment for everyone, would require talking to other humans about how they experience Facebook — i.e., doing actual research. (Even then, the conclusion would only hold, at best, for the types of humans with whom the author has spoken.) And as usual for these rants, there's no evidence this research has been done.

This piece of writing, therefore, does not contribute meaningfully to the discussion around Facebook.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by calinet6 on Monday June 03, 2013 @07:03AM (#5812506)
Brilliant. This is a perfect analysis of this article.

People are using Facebook because they want to, not because some weird social power is forcing them to. My friends love it, my parents love it, heck my grandma thinks it's absolutely magical. We get to share things and communicate with family in a way we've never been able to ever. It's not replacing the deep connections and interpersonal relationships—you need to actually meet up with someone and talk to them in person or on the phone for that. But we already have ways to do that!

The annoying people on Facebook are the ones who don't like it, like the author of this article. They're the ones that just post "Dang Facebook sucks more every day" or useless stuff like that and never actually use it for its capabilities. They expect Facebook to do their social for them, when it's really just a tool that you have to use optimistically.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by alphang on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:03AM (#5812705)
Funny you should mention 'forcing them to':

"I'll wake up in the morning and go on Facebook just ... because," Casey says. "It's not like I want to or I don't. I just go on it. I'm, like, forced to. I don't know why. I need to. Facebook takes up my whole life." http://kottke.org/13/05/wanting-to-be-liked

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by antoko on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:36AM (#5812843)
replace "facebook" with "HN" in the quote above... How many of us could have said that?

Are we forced to be here?

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by xtracto on Monday June 03, 2013 @11:34AM (#5813846)
And Reddit, and Slashdot and WoW and usenet...

Aren't there studies that find there is an element of addiction to browsing the internet?

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by jamesjguthrie on Monday June 03, 2013 @12:11PM (#5814054)
"Withdrawal symptoms: If the person stops using the Internet, they experience unpleasant feelings or physical effects."

It's a bit like having a drug addiction really.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_addiction_disorder

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by CyberDroiD on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:32PM (#5815787)
Wanting to stay connected and communicate with other humans is not a disorder, it's actually quite healthy!

I think it is fascinating that people feel compelled to visit Facebook or any website, and don't know why. It's like calling someone every morning: you want to communicate. If you stop doing that suddenly, you'll miss it.

Calling it an 'addiction' or 'some strange social force' or other conspiracy ideas are interesting, but flawed arguments.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by qu4z-2 on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @02:53AM (#5818047)
I somewhat question the effectiveness of ... let's say Reddit as actual communication, though. Maybe I'm projecting, but I find my online social interactions are nice, but don't really compare to actually hanging out with friends, or even taking time to do something I enjoy, like cooking a nice meal or whatever.

At the end of a couple of hours of commenting on people I know's pictures of cats or whatever I look back and think "Wow, where'd that time go?" whereas if I've done something "productive" I feel much better. It's possible that's just because I've filed time-on-the-internet under "wasting time" and so I'm judging myself, but I think the feeling bad was the reason I decided I shouldn't do it, not the other way 'round.

Sorry, that turned into a ramble.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by fudged71 on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:41PM (#5815860)
To me, it's the fear of missing something important. Something that I would regret not seeing.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by hkmurakami on Monday June 03, 2013 @03:03AM (#5811807)
I'm not a heavy FB user, but having lived in various places around the world, it's one of the few ways I can passively keep in touch with what my dear friends have been up to half way around the globe.

That is real value that Facebook does deliver, something I must admit despite my wide ranged mistrust and distaste for various other aspects of the service.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by Vivtek on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:45AM (#5812085)
That's its value to me, too. I sit in Budapest and I'm actually in closer contact with my old high school friends in Indiana than I have ever been. And my kid's friends' parents in Puerto Rico. And yeah, some people here in Budapest. It does exactly what I want it to do, and it's way more effective than remembering to send Christmas cards.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by Larrikin on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:15AM (#5812752)
I travel a lot and have done multiple study abroads on different continents when I was in college. I find this to be a gift and a curse of Facebook. Its great when they are genuinely interesting people that you share lots of interest with. But its awful when you have a good night or even a good week with the person and then you friend them on Facebook only to find out later you don't have much in common with them. It really dampers your mood when you look back at the old pictures and you're having a good time with someone you deleted because of all their irrelevant wall spam and complaints. Some relationships are much better when they are fleeting and you only have the good memories.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by freehunter on Monday June 03, 2013 @09:29AM (#5813095)
Well, friending someone on Facebook is starting a relationship with that person. Just like I wouldn't call someone the next day if I didn't want to start a relationship with them, I wouldn't friend them either.

Friending them just to realize you have little in common is akin to dating someone only to realize you have little in common.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by bradleysmith on Monday June 03, 2013 @01:06PM (#5814397)
This is also where I receive value from facebook; I grew up in Saudi Arabia and all my childhood friends scattered around the globe. There is no other tool like facebook that lets me both maintain meaningful contact with friends & find undiscovered friends spanning large geographies. Relatedly, I've always found facebook's geography-based search tools (friends/posts & content in a city/region)have left much to be desired.

I agree with the article author's opinion that Facebook IS growing less useful for me. As Graue said in above post, though, this really only applies to me and my reactions to MY OWN social circle.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by taproot on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:05AM (#5811973)
And that thin veil is held together by its complicated breakups, baby pictures and cat memes. If it wasnt that everyone enjoyed sharing these things id hate to think what might happen.

Im in the same boat as you here. And it worries me. Imagine if we had to go back to the old days of using msn status updates and actually having to gasp converse with one another in order to get our fill of socal interaction.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by spinchange on Monday June 03, 2013 @07:24AM (#5812564)
Imagine gasp coming to point in life where your children & those of friends and loved ones make up some of most meaningful "content" there is.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by threeseed on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:39AM (#5812070)
Have never seen a single baby picture or cat meme or anything like it on Facebook. And several of my friends have kids.

There is a temptation when people comment on Facebook to extrapolate their experience with the vast array of different societies, social norms, perspectives, ages, interests, backgrounds, maturities etc.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by taproot on Monday June 10, 2013 @07:09PM (#5858171)
You guys. Almost had me goin for a second.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by dagw on Monday June 03, 2013 @06:06AM (#5812342)
I get maybe 1 baby picture pr 50-100 message and even less cat memes. Don't think I've seen a single complicated breakup.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by Semaphor on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:56AM (#5812113)
One baby picture so far on FB and that was in a private message. The only source of memes is Mr. Takei. We have evening planning chats with people from (guesstimate) 10-15 different countries (all living in our town in Germany), groups for special topics. Conversing gasp with people who moved back to their home country is another regular activity. And it's all held together by an interface that makes it really easy even for the most non-tech people.

So right now the first few stories in my news feed only has 3 posts I find interesting. And? I look at my feed every now and then and if often there is nothing interesting it doesn't hinder me. Some stuff is really interesting and helps me break out of the internet bubble I'm in bust mostly facebook is groups and chat for me. And that's why I love it.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by onedev on Monday June 03, 2013 @10:30PM (#5817335)
I love baby pictures, they're really cute. I love seeing my friends' and family's babies grow up through pictures on FB because I can't always be there in person.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by femto on Monday June 03, 2013 @03:02AM (#5811803)
> I see the same Google Maps as everyone else does.

Not for much longer [1,2].

[1] http://www.smh.com.au/digital-life/consumer-security/how-goo...

[2] http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2419020,00.asp

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by ianstormtaylor on Monday June 03, 2013 @02:51AM (#5811767)
Completely agree. Most every point he makes doesn't apply to my use of Facebook.

The one that is interesting is his comparison to Google and SEO. In Google's world there are three players: (1) the searchers, (2) the advertisers and (3) the black hats who try to game the system. Unfortunately for Facebook, (2) and (3) are the same, so the people they make money from are also the people who are degrading the system. They don't have Google's luxury of cracking down hard on (3) because that's who their income comes from, which ends up sucking for the rest of us.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by thenomad on Monday June 03, 2013 @05:57AM (#5812312)
Also the content creators on whose sites ads are placed (and to whose sites the search results point), surely?
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by taproot on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:10AM (#5811984)
Muddling the term black hat and "black hat seo" on the internet, hn no less. You certainly have the balls I lack.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by dclowd9901 on Monday June 03, 2013 @03:01AM (#5811798)
> And so, every few weeks it seems, we get these posts from some techie who believes that his (it's always a man) experiences with social media are universal.

Moreover, if my news feed of middle-Americans-quite-pleased-to-share-indiscriminately is any indication, Facebook is what most people need. MOST PEOPLE. This whole elitist attitude in the tech community is breeding "innovators" who don't have the first clue what the world really wants or needs.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by nextw33k on Monday June 03, 2013 @03:17AM (#5811839)
I feel that you are missing his point.

There is a trend towards emotional populist content on social networks. It's interesting to you because it's your friends and it feels personal.

However in a broader context its creating a society that is inward looking (walled garden of your friends) and concerned with re-enforcing social norms (the like button).

How does this activity improve us as a society? Where is the creativity and freedom?

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by potatolicious on Monday June 03, 2013 @09:52AM (#5813244)
Your comment is fair, but I think you've imagined a creative, free society where the walled garden didn't exist - where it never existed in actuality.

People have always been insular and self-contained within their circles. Said circles form early in life and change very slowly. Even when you move people around geographically, they quickly fall back into the same closed circles. In these circles they reinforce whatever social memes have developed - inside jokes, similar views, etc.

Very few people in the world (though they do exist) actually continually meet new people outside of their existing groups.

So sure, Facebook doesn't improve us as a society, nor is it a magical bastion of creativity and freedom - but life never was, and Facebook hasn't made it worse. Facebook is merely a magnification of who you are. If you were prone to sharing stupid motivational pictures, now your'e sharing a lot of them. If you surrounded yourself with constantly insightful, smart people, now you get to talk to a lot more of them, a lot more frequently.

Facebook is what you make of it. I have a habit of squelching friends who don't post meaningful things. Click on the top right corner of their post and you can adjust their weighting in your feed - I have many people who essentially no longer contribute to my feed, and that's fine. Looking at my front page right now, nearly all of the information is stuff I actually care about.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by icebraining on Monday June 03, 2013 @03:46AM (#5811925)
A single social networks doesn't have to be everything and all-encompassing to be useful; the place where you organize a family lunch is usually not the same where you run a LAN party or perform body painting.

I do wish that social network wasn't Facebook, though.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by saraid216 on Monday June 03, 2013 @12:37PM (#5814208)
> There is a trend towards emotional populist content on the internet.

Fixed that for you.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by foobarbazqux on Monday June 03, 2013 @03:18AM (#5811845)
> And so, every few weeks it seems, we get these posts from some techie who believes that his (it's always a man) experiences with social media are universal.

On the other hand, technical people are like rats. They're the first to pile on to fresh meat (there was even a prominent website by this name...), and they're the first to flee when the place is burning down.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by threeseed on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:35AM (#5812058)
Your argument made sense in the years past where there only were technical people on the internet. But now it is less so. People are comfortable making their own choices on the internet and don't need the recommendations or advice of technical people like they did it in the past.

Look at the success of Pinterest or Instagram for example. Neither grew because of technical people.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by sergiosgc on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:01AM (#5812692)
Pinterest and Instagram grew out from the base of early smartphone adopters. These is as techy a group as you can find...
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by moheeb on Monday June 03, 2013 @01:47PM (#5814650)
Early smartphones mostly came out in the mid 2000s...way before Instagram or Pinterest.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by sergiosgc on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @04:45AM (#5818325)
Dating the smartphone revolution at anytime before the first iPhone is disingenuous and you know it. Even then, the bulk of Internet-using smartphone users were tech heads.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by johnjlocke on Monday June 03, 2013 @03:39AM (#5811900)
Having an original opinion is a dangerous thing...mmm, boy.

Fitting in with your surroundings is still a function of the lizard brain, is it not?

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday June 03, 2013 @03:01AM (#5811800)
Yep - this is an old thing, it applies to twitter, LiveJournal or to any other social network where you pick who you read. It's more about your choices than anything else: If you don't like the content you're reading, read different people.

However ... Facebook is probably the only social network where I feel a high level of obligation to add people like Aunt Jemima, and Bill who I went to college with, years ago. It's "for" keeping in touch - i.e that's how most people use it. It's the fallback social network for contacts who don't fit into other, targeted social networks.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by curiousdannii on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:34AM (#5812833)
But that obligation doesn't mean anything about what you read. Add them and ignore them if you want.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by smith7018 on Monday June 03, 2013 @11:18AM (#5813755)
Thank you.

I'm beginning to wonder if I'm the only person out there who has used the "unfriend" button before. I've deleted hundreds of people; many of whom I only met for one night 5 years ago or didn't even talk to way back in high school. Now, my Facebook feed has content that only features people I care to hear from and "interest pages," which is sorta meh. It's really not this social media wasteland I keep reading about?

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by saraid216 on Monday June 03, 2013 @12:39PM (#5814215)
I never friended people I didn't wish to hear from to begin with. I've only ever unfriended one person, and I've never broken the 200-friend threshold, so I can't claim to have unfriended hundreds.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by smith7018 on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:29PM (#5815749)
Well, congratulations on Facebooking more intelligently than most, I guess?
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by mike_herrera on Monday June 03, 2013 @02:23PM (#5814868)
> And so, every few weeks it seems, we get these posts from some techie who believes that his (it's always a man) experiences with social media are universal. ... > And as usual for these rants, there's no evidence this research has been done. This piece of writing, therefore, does not contribute meaningfully to the discussion around Facebook.

Too harsh. I agree that there is not enough rigor to speculate on the universal experience, but this absolutely has value in the larger Facebook discussion.

The increasing frequency of these anecdotal experiences is a hint that there exists a segment of frustrated users. It would be a mistake to summarily ignore their frustration due to the presentation of the argument.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by onedev on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @12:32AM (#5817734)
You have to remember Facebook's scale.

These "increasingly common" anecdotes are from the same demographic of people.

Facebook is used by 1.15 BILLION people. Think about that for a second. It's an absolutely staggering number and they're adding MILLIONS of new users every single day.

Do you think the people in Africa, South America, Iceland, and even China, are going to have the same experiences as the person writing this article?

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by samikc on Monday June 03, 2013 @03:02AM (#5811804)
Agree to what you say. Facebook is great in some cases, like finding your old buddy from college or school. I use FB to find them, but after that I get their email ids and from then on its email communication. So for me FB is the place to find people.

But FB is not for getting news about the topics I like; because, IMHO like the OP, Facebook news feed is broken for this purpose. Yes it is broken if you like to get news and information related to your interests. The prime reason, which I have discovered over the years of using FB, is I like things which my friends do not like a lot and vice-versa. I cannot blame Facebook for this. So when they like something which I do not, I still get the news in the feed. The same thing is happening in Twitter.

I felt that it would be better if we can follow information we like rather than the people we like. This way we will be able to get the information that we want/like rather than the noise. A critical step towards this is tags and if we can follow a tag it would be better [1].

[1] Disclaimer: I have created a website to do just that. Link is https://www.scoopspot.com/ .

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by scholia on Monday June 03, 2013 @12:12PM (#5814061)
I agree, but people have always followed the information they want.

Online, that's as old as Usenet, and it continued through topics on CompuServe and AOL. It continues today through specialised forums and bulletin boards, especially the forums on subject-based websites. Good ones include AV Forums, Hydrogen Audio, DPReview, Doom9 etc.

Anyone who thinks Facebook is, or is meant to be, a substitute for Doom9 is extremely dim.

A lot of Facebook is social grooming and phatic communication http://grammar.about.com/od/pq/g/phaticterm.htm

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by kalleboo on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:56AM (#5812917)
I think Facebook is getting into "follow information" as well. Recently I've started getting items in my newsfeed from pages I've never visited or liked, with the header "<page> posted about <topic from my profile>"
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by myoffe on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:10AM (#5811982)
I Agree. The difference between a blogger and a researcher is that the former can say what the heck he wants on the internet and state it as an objective and universal truth. While a researcher, on the other hand, must back his claims with some evidence.

So this post should just be downvoted. Another guy with an opinion on the internet, nothing to get too excited about.

It seems that the more controversy you create, the more popular you get on HN, regardless of whatever you have any ground to your claims.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by wavefunction on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:13PM (#5816926)
Soon, you will not see the same Google Maps as everyone else:

http://www.forbes.com/sites/anthonykosner/2013/06/01/the-new...

So, enjoy your once democratic access to information.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by onedev on Monday June 03, 2013 @02:43AM (#5811732)
I completely agree with you. I think you've hit the nail on the head exactly.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by alphang on Monday June 03, 2013 @05:53AM (#5812297)
I agree that his piece isn't well-researched, and the title is sensationalist, but I share most of his experiences and sentiments. I hope a more quantitative research around this area does emerge though.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by deluko on Monday June 03, 2013 @02:17PM (#5814832)
People also love Yahoo Mail (and loved the previous, more-horrendous version, too). Doesn't mean it couldn't be better.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by papsosouid on Monday June 03, 2013 @11:01AM (#5813652)
>(it's always a man)

Oh right, I forgot that having both an opinion and a penis is a crime. How does being a man have anything to do with it at all? Plenty of non-technical people have come to very similar conclusions, some of them have even been women. You are seeing what you want to see.