News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Georgify: Make Hacker News More Readable by lmm on Friday May 31, 2013 @06:37AM (#5797766)
I think your habit of complaining in the guise of asking for explanation whenever you get downvoted constitutes gaming of the moderation system, which presents a greater danger to HN than even outright trolling. I want to discourage that behaviour, and will downvote it whenever I see it. I also find it rather distasteful that you're so defensive about being downvoted given that you of all users can clearly afford the karma.
Re:Georgify: Make Hacker News More Readable by ColinWright on Friday May 31, 2013 @06:48AM (#5797797)
I appreciate your candour - it's useful to see another point of view, and I will take it into account.

Having said that, I usually don't see the reasons for the down-votes, and I genuinely do want explanations. I don't mind the down-votes - whether or not I can "afford the karma" is beside the point. Down-voting people is a part of how the site works, causing comments and submissions to bubble up and/or down, and I think that's a good thing. Not being given the chance to learn something or to see an alternate point of view is disappointing.

But when someone disagrees with a comment and just performs a "drive-by down-vote" I think it's of negative value to the site, and I'd like to discourage that. Sadly, I suspect that ship has sailed.

So again, thank you for the feedback. If we're ever co-located, and you think you can stand my company, I owe you a coffee. FWIW, I've upvoted your comment, even though I (obviously) don't agree with it.

Re:Georgify: Make Hacker News More Readable by lmm on Friday May 31, 2013 @07:09PM (#5801788)
I think everyone wants to know the reason when they're downvoted - I certainly do. So asking for it isn't really adding new information to the conversation. I do wish there were a way to downvote and provide explanation (even a slashdot-style "select reason from a small dropdown"), but I can only trust there are good reasons for the absence of such a thing.

Not to mention that AIUI replying to a post you downvoted negates the effect of the downvote? Which makes the request for explanation doubly suspect.

I'd be very happy to meet when you're next in London (well, not in the next couple of weeks as I'm busy moving house, but in general). [email protected]