Having said that, I usually don't see the reasons for the down-votes, and I genuinely do want explanations. I don't mind the down-votes - whether or not I can "afford the karma" is beside the point. Down-voting people is a part of how the site works, causing comments and submissions to bubble up and/or down, and I think that's a good thing. Not being given the chance to learn something or to see an alternate point of view is disappointing.
But when someone disagrees with a comment and just performs a "drive-by down-vote" I think it's of negative value to the site, and I'd like to discourage that. Sadly, I suspect that ship has sailed.
So again, thank you for the feedback. If we're ever co-located, and you think you can stand my company, I owe you a coffee. FWIW, I've upvoted your comment, even though I (obviously) don't agree with it.
Not to mention that AIUI replying to a post you downvoted negates the effect of the downvote? Which makes the request for explanation doubly suspect.
I'd be very happy to meet when you're next in London (well, not in the next couple of weeks as I'm busy moving house, but in general). [email protected]
I tried an approach here: http://userstyles.org/styles/71445/better-hacker-news-design
I don't think it reaches the quality of this submission - i am not enough of a visual designer for that - and maybe it is also not what you search for, but you could give it a try. I tried to maintain a bit of what defines the original design, like the orange header, maybe it is that what you are missing.
Quick feedback, I don't like the white text in the top bar, and you seem to have shrunk the width. I do like the different font, and am undecided about the blue links.
But I'll certainly give it a go. Thanks.
With that said, I personally think it needs less whitespace and smaller fonts. I'm not a fan of Georgia either.
Off-topic: Also, I'm tired of all these Hacker News iPhone apps, scrapers, browser plugins and whatnot. It gets too "meta" for me that these things are posted constantly.
It just feels, well, I don't know, "Energy Free", "Hypnotic", "Soporific". There's no sharpness, no hustle, no contrast, but those are terms that make you think of image contrast and sharpness, and that's not what I mean.
My father was a sign-maker, and he loved jobs that were specified by an architect. Why? Because they produced gorgeous designs that were harmonious and free flowing. The signs were specified to fit with the color scheme and blend with the decor. As a result, he would always be called back 6 months later to augment or replace the signage.
I wonder if I feel a little the same here. I'm slowly being hypnotized by "beautiful design."
I hate it.
I'm sure it's technically very clean, elegant, and "nice", but more and more as I look at the "gorgeous" and "beautifully designed" sites pointed to from HN, I just feel like my face is being pushed through mush.
I know that sounds entirely negative, and I'm sorry about that, but the obsession with blended buttons and perfect pastels and crafted corners and so on just makes the whole thing feel wishy washy.
Am I alone in this? I'm sure lots of people love it, and I hope you get lots of great comments, but I just thought I'd mention that not everyone is the same in their perceptions.
Please, can someone with design skills equal to the ones demonstrated here have a go at something with a bit more "edge."
Oh, and here's the discussion from last time:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2410195
It's great to see that many of the comments from that discussion were taken on board and acted on.
Added in edit: I see that this is a controversial comment. It's getting both upvotes and downvotes, so people clearly agree, and disagree. But I think this comment is genuinely of value. If you create something and there were dissenting opinions, would you not like to hear them? Do you only want "Yes Men" in your entourage? Dissenting opinions can be hard to take, but if you block them out you get an echo chamber. Please, if you think this comment is of negative value and doesn't belong on HN, tell us why. For the downvoters, that's certainly your right and privilege, but ask yourself: are you downvoting because you think this comment doesn't belong on HN, or simply because it's an opinion contrary to yours? FWIW, I've upvoted the submission.