That analogy might be valid if 50-90% of Model-Ts were used for bank robberies, and all those other things, and exclusively.
At some point it crosses the lines of being a legitimate business and becomes a caterer for criminal enterprises.
Having 1 legitimate customer does not excuse you from willingly servicing the needs of 9 criminals.
LR went out of their way to hide the tracks of money transactions.
But apparently if you signed up to them and put as a reason "to buy cocaine" this was fine by them
basically - I don't think the US gov't is going to cede the digital currency space quietly.
more important than the anonymity issue facilitating money laundering (which is a consideration) - is preserving the sanctity of the US dollar in world trade. to give one example - most oil is priced in US dollars, around the world. the dollar, including all the manipulative tricks we can pull with the fed, is the basis for our economic power and likely a key driver in all the shenanigans we pull around the world so the government would be complete fools to allow bitcoin or similar to turn into anything other than a science project.
It sounds like there's considerable evidence that the owners were fine with supporting illegal transactions. So, no one really contests their arrests.
The problem is that the service they created is/was used by many people to store and transfer legitimately earned money.
The end result is that many cybercriminals are no longer able to access the money they illicitly earned, yet many regular working people, often in foreign countries where they can't use Paypal or otherwise, can't access their actual funds. Those people had nothing to do with LR's management, nor the criminals who were using the service.
It's nuts that the US can step in and shut down a foreign company like this. I understand cracking down on any of the exchangers that operated in the US, but it's really not the US's business if foreign parties in foreign countries exchange money with a foreign company.
What if the only reason it was cheaper for legal uses is that they were being subsidized by the illegal uses? What if the pricing LD offered would not have been a workable business model if they hadn't allowed money laundering?
(I don't know the facts here. I'm just offering a possibility.)
Dwolla has a $.25 fee for example and while I'm sure a bunch of criminals use Dwolla, it would not stand out as suspicious.
Liberty Reserve wasn't in the business of actually converting money in their system to or from real-world currencies, and handed off tasks such as indentity verification and anti-fraud to the companies who actually exchanged those bits for real money.
In some regards, LR was very similar to a protocol.
1. http://web.archive.org/web/20130424151449/http://www.liberty...
That is why this is blowning up that strong in mainstream media which unquestionable accepts the idea that all the over 1m users are just money launderers.
My guess is that current legislation is not strong enough to bring Bitcoin down and cases like these help to propagate the only-pedophiles-and-terrorists-want-anonymity meme.
If they come after bitcoin and you make the same comment, I'll be more sympathetic.
Reading an indictment to determine whether the accused did something wrong is about as sensible as watching Fox News to determine whether Barack Obama is a socialist. All indictments paint the defendants as guilty.
And since when is working around the law a crime? It's almost by definition not a crime, because the whole idea is to accomplish the goal you set out to achieve without breaking the law.
I really don't see why everyone is assuming these guys are in the right. I don't see much to support that claim.
>I really don't see why everyone is assuming these guys are in the right. I don't see much to support that claim.
You don't see much to support that claim in the indictment? No kidding.
| And since when is working around the
| law a crime?
Finding a loophole in the law, may make what you did technically legal, but it doesn't make it all of the sudden a 'good' thing. If I found a loophole in the laws that let me defraud you of all your money, while technically staying inside of the law, would I not still be a fraudster/conman, even if I didn't run afowl of any 'fraud' laws?What you mean to say is that there are some things which are contemptible but still technically legal. But the converse is also true: Some things remain legally prohibited that would otherwise be morally unobjectionable. Legality and morality are independent variables.
Whether doing a thing is 'good' or not has nothing to do with whether that thing is legal, "technically legal" or totally illegal. All its legal status tells you is whether you can expect to be convicted of it if accused.
| Defrauding someone will cause you to be
| guilty of fraud, because that's what
| "defraud" means.
The legal definition and the 'common' definition of something don't always match up.Its very much like how urber or air bNb are finding ways around existing constrictive regulations designed to protect existing incumbents.
I mean really, what business is it of the governments is it who i send my money to??
| I think theres a rather large difference between finding away around the
| law to defraud/steal from someone and finding a way to send money
| cheaper/easier then existing methods.
| I mean really, what business is it of the governments is it who i send my
| money to??
My response about fraud was an example to highlight how 'working around the
law' doesn't necessarily mean that you are or aren't doing something. You may
not be doing it by the legal definition, but you can still be doing it by the
'common' definition. | designed to protect existing incumbents
So, you're saying that tenants breaking their lease agreements is a good thing.
Because the tenant is 'disrupting' the landlord (the 'incumbent')?If I have a house that I want to rent out, am I an evil person that needs to be put in my place by the tenants that rent it from me? Is there someone wrong with me wanting to vet the people that will be living in said house (especially since damage done to the house can be hard to recover in some municipalities)?
That is not what i was referring to, I was talking about the laws the city passes to prevent it and protect hotels.
OK, I assume that they would be leant on and "persuaded" to give this thing up, but that just big bully boy tactics. Not a moral or legal thing.
An indictment is not a reliable source of objective fact or unbiased interpretation of fact. It's an accusation, written to make the accused sound as deplorable as possible.
Then they came for the socialists, and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a socialist.
Then they came for the trade unionists, and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a trade unionist.
Then they came for me, and there was no one left to speak for me.
I have no opinion about the allegations against Liberty Reserve. That needs proper judicial resolution, which takes time. I will note, in light of some of the other comments here, that the United States has international treaty agreements with most other countries in the world mutually to regulate money exchange from one country to another. Once in my work as a Chinese-English interpreter (this was back in about 1997), I had occasion to accompany a Chinese official to the offices of FinCEN
so that he could discuss with United States officials how his country (NOT an "ally" of the United States) and ours could cooperate in fulfilling their mutual treaty obligations.
I'm largely with you, Daniel, in desiring government to have narrower rather than broader powers to regulate individual behavior around the world, but I'm not so sure governmental power is too broad or being abused in this case.
This is like saying Henry Ford designed the modern automobile to be used in bank robberies, drunk driving murders, hit-and-run maimings, and kidnapping.
Yes, virtual currency is attractive to criminals. It's also attractive to law-abiding citizens, many of whom do not like to be lumped into one big morass with "organized crime" stuck on top as a label. We're stepping dangerously close to "If criminals like doing it, it must be bad" reasoning.
ADD: I also note this section: "...On Tuesday, in the first use of the 2001 Patriot Act against a virtual currency, the Treasury Department invoked a section of the law to choke off Liberty Reserve from the U.S. financial system..."
Well, there's your terrorism act, used to control crime via virtual currency. We get scared of one thing, pass a law, and then see it used in a completely different context. The current American kerfuffle involving investigating reporters is tied to a WWI-era law that's almost never used. Amazing the tools American prosecutors have available to them. One could say overbearing, even.
ADD2: Nobody is saying they are innocent. The point here is that these guys are being shut down (and they probably need to be shut down) by procedures that have broad application to all kinds of legitimate use as well. These are very broad and powerful tools we've given the state. We should take some time and think about if they need to be more narrowly-focused. The initial Patriot Act had an expiration date. For a reason.