There is a greater risk of people popping up with claims against VP8 or VP9 as they are newer and less prominent. The MPEG-LA's call for a pool of patents has helped draw out those patent owners and many have joined the pool and reached terms with Google (although Nokia and maybe others haven't.
This is common FUD. Whatever was in that "pool" - the end result no one attempted to attack VP8 with patent claims, except for Nokia. The strange counterexample to the claim that "prominence" guarantees safety is Google, who used H.264 against Microsoft themselves. Nothing is protected against sudden patent attacks. But if there are no known patents - then paranoia won't help anything.
Note that I said "greater risk" not that there was no risk for H.264 or that it is a massive showstopper for VP8. I stand by my statement although this really isn't critical EXCEPT for the fact that due to FRAND commitments potential claims are limited (as the Motorola/Google case is showing). If you have made no FRAND commitments you can get injunctions or ask for outrageous (hundreds of millions of dollars or even billions) licensing fees but if FRAND commitments have been made you cannot do this as the courts are educating Google/Motorola.
The obvious baseline for W3C to adopt would in my view be MPEG1 allowing a fallback to a safe free codec and modern non free codecs to be used otherwise.
Even if Nokia lose and no-one else comes forward the Google licence is non-redistributable anyway so for many purposes is no better than the AVC one.
Freedom, zero cost, quality, low legal risk. Choose two.
Freedom, zero cost, quality, low legal risk.
Where did you find freedom and zero cost there? Low legal risk is a myth in the land of patent minefields.
the Google license is non-redistributable anyway
Again wrong. VPx content as well as encoders and decoders are redistributable under the current license which is fully open source compatible.
> Where did you find freedom and zero cost there? Low legal risk is a myth in the land of patent minefields.
I made it up, couldn't narrow it down to three. MPEG1 is low risk, free and Free now. AVC is low risk now it has been a juicy target for long enough to draw out trolls and it is high quality. VP8 is high quality and zero cost.
The license that Google has from the MPEG-LA doesn't seem to allow for those who accept the license to sub license. If this is incorrect please send a reference.
You seem to be of the view that the pool contents are either invalid or non-essential. Until I see a detailed study of them that indicates this with claim by claim explanations I will assume that at least some may be valid. Now Google has taken the license it is highly unlikely they will challenge the pool patents (and they may be contractually obliged not to). This means there is no big player likely to fight the patents and make the status clearly open source compatible.
> The license that Google has from the MPEG-LA doesn't seem to allow for those who accept the license to sub license.
The license is a FUD reduction tool. You can simply ignore it in the context of the open source license of the codec itself - it's not part of that license at all.
> You seem to be of the view that the pool contents are either invalid or non-essential. Until I see a detailed study of them that indicates this with claim by claim explanations I will assume that at least some may be valid. Now Google has taken the license it is highly unlikely they will challenge the pool patents (and they may be contractually obliged not to). This means there is no big player likely to fight the patents and make the status clearly open source compatible.
I'm not sure what you are talking about - patents that MPEG-LA supposedly has against VP8, or the patents that Nokia presented against it?
If the former, those contents can as well be simply non existent and their potential existence used as a tool to spread FUD. Until anything is publicly presented (like Nokia did), there is no reason to pay attention to that "pool". Note that Google didn't license any patents that are known to be affecting VP8. Nothing like that. They just licensed "something", so that MPEG-LA would stop making statements like "what a good codec you have here, a pity if something would happen to it if and when we find some patents against it". I.e. Google bribed them to stop spreading FUD. In no way does it demonstrate that MPEG-LA has any actual patents against VP8.
If the later - the list is published, and now in the process of being reviewed / refuted. Let's see how that works out.
You are also free to use open source AVC implementations and ignore that MPEG-LA license too. Depending on who you are and what you are doing with AVC the probability of action by a patent holder could be very low.
I meant the patents under the MPEG-LA from the eleven companies (some of whom I would take seriously) and including at least two of the biggest Android manufacturers rather than Google's enemies:
CIF Licensing LLC
France Telecom
Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft zur Foerderung der angewandten Forschung e.V.
Fujitsu Limited
Koninklijke Philips Electronics N.V.
LG Electronics Inc.
Mitsubishi Electric Corporation
MPEG LA, LLC
NTT DOCOMO, INC.
Panasonic Corporation
Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
Siemens Corporation
You are right that the patent list does not seem to be published which is unfortunate. If the patents in the AVC pool owned by these companies were checked against VP8 by someone credible and preferably independent it would give quite a good degree of assurance about them.
Do note though that Google claimed to have bought On2's patents and they too only seem to be offered under the same non-FOSS compatible licence as the MPEG-KA ones.
As for the Nokia patents I don't think that they would have been brought to courts if Nokia didn't think victory was a realistic outcome. However the drop out rate for claims is very high in all the patent disputes although it seems very hard to predict at the start what will stand up and what will fall so it is entirely possible that they will fail. From my perspective this seems a bad sign for the consistency and predictability of patent law which needs major reform rather than proof that Nokia is claiming rights that IT doesn't believe it has.
The list of companies doesn't impress me. Many manufacturers are engaged in patent racket. It's Google refusal to play the same game that caused their ire and fear mongering. As I said, until they actually publish what's supposedly exists in that pool - there is no point to pay any attention to their claims.
The patent "racket" is the system enshrined in the current laws which I agree need fixing but our wishes for that to happen don't make it so and the patents won't disappear unless it does or until they expire.
It wouldn't be the first time Microsoft used another company's losing case (SCO) to fight a proxy battle.
Rather than waiting 20 years, we could lobby for legislation that developing, distributing, or running a program on generally used computing hardware does not constitute patent infringement. [1]
[1] http://www.wired.com/opinion/2012/11/richard-stallman-softwa...
Yes it is patented which is a definite disadvantage compared with a theoretical[4] patent free codec but it has some real advantages.
1) The standard is controlled and defined by a collective industry group under the auspices of ISO. [1]
2) Most of the major players in video technology at the time took part in the standardisation so are committed to FRAND patent licensing terms. [2]
3) In almost all cases and commercial business models (that do not involve Free software) the MPEG-LA H.264 patent license is really very reasonable and unlikely to cause problems to an otherwise healthy business. Note that the license Google has to the MPEG-LA pool of patents while free is NOT compatible with Free software.
4) Any companies not in the MPEG-LA pool that popped up now with demands really would trolls in the original sense that they have sat under the bridge for a long time waiting for a juicy opportunity rather than being upfront earlier. I don't think that this would help them in a legal case although there is no guarantee that they don't exist. [3]
5) H.264 is really quite good although the latest codecs are showing what can be done with further development and processing power.
6) H.264 decoding (and often encoding) is cooked into a massive amount of existing and deployed devices in ways that cannot be adapted to VP8/VP9 by a software update.
For now H.264 is the no brainer option for any commercial system although multi codec support may be worthwhile in some cases. If you want patent free I recommend MPEG1 as I believe any patents on it should now be expired or at least expiring very soon if they were granted a long time after filing. I'm glad that Firefox has backed down and will now use the OS codecs to allow playback of H.264.
[1] The OOXML case shows that this isn't foolproof but in my view it is a better option than the standard being controlled by a single company even if the controlling company publishes the source code. This applied to Microsoft when they offered VC-1 as a free alternative to H.264 (there is now an MPEG-LA pool) and to Google now with VP8 and VP9 now. Google is the new Microsoft and has fully learnt the lessons of "Embrace, extend and extinguish".
[2] Not Free software compatible but better than nothing. And even Google's license to the VP8 patents from the MPEG-LA pool does not seem to grant Free software compatible rights.
[3] There is a greater risk of people popping up with claims against VP8 or VP9 as they are newer and less prominent. The MPEG-LA's call for a pool of patents has helped draw out those patent owners and many have joined the pool and reached terms with Google (although Nokia and maybe others haven't.
[4] Realistically for patent free greater than 20 years old is the answer so it probably needs to be MPEG1.