Re:How Patents Are Ruining the Adoption of HTML5 Video
by mbq on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @05:50PM
(#5783074)
Ogg as a fallback for Linux... Actually Theora was seriously planned to be the codec for HTML5 video, but Apple and Nokia spoiled this in 2007 due to some virtual patent problems.
Re:How Patents Are Ruining the Adoption of HTML5 Video
by shmerl on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @09:00PM
(#5783952)
That's known, but Theora never could compete with H.264 in quality. It was proposed simply because it was the best available open coded at that time. When VP8 arrived it replaced Theora for that role.
Re:How Patents Are Ruining the Adoption of HTML5 Video
by mbq on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @09:40AM
(#5786179)
It's not that bad, moreover the game is always about quality/quantity ratio. And if it had become a standard, its development would be heavily pushed forward and vp8 would likely now be really free and called theora 2.0.
Re:How Patents Are Ruining the Adoption of HTML5 Video
by danbmil99 on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @04:29PM
(#5782533)
Latest builds of Chrome and FF play webm/vp8 fine on my Ubuntu machines.
Given that previously Linux users had to manually enable flash, asking them to update to recent browsers is a reasonable request (also good security). Saying you need Ogg/Theora for legacy Linux support is a bit silly -- that's a vanishingly small segment of the target audience, and they tend to be tech savvy anyway.
Re:How Patents Are Ruining the Adoption of HTML5 Video
by anonymous on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @01:52PM
(#5781443)
I wonder why it's not on by default. It can't be illegal to ship a browser that uses gstreamer, right? Users can purchase and install fluendo's codec pack to decode h.264 videos, or use the hw decoders in their graphics cards.
Re:How Patents Are Ruining the Adoption of HTML5 Video
by wmf on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @02:06PM
(#5781549)
The main reason was Mozilla's openness martyrdom, but they've relaxed that position somewhat. There are still problems with pluggable codecs (of while GStreamer is one form): different users will have different codecs installed, leading to poor interoperability and trojan "codec packs" have been a vector for malware.
Re:How Patents Are Ruining the Adoption of HTML5 Video
by shmerl on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @01:53PM
(#5781453)
Mostly for technical reasons. See: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=794282
That's a wrong claim. VP8 support on Linux is commonplace. As well as H.264 support (if we are talking about system frameworks like gstreamer and etc.).
Browsers is another matter, and they ship with their own decoders. Mozilla provides an option to use gstreamer for Firefox, but it's not built by default. Mozilla can't use built in H.264 decoders simply because it will require licensing and will make it non redistributable.
Also, OGG is not a codec, it's a container. The author probably meant Theora.