News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by rickdale on Monday May 27, 2013 @07:21AM (#5774229)
I always feel like no matter how well a journalist covers Afghanistan, its only a small slice of the pie, for everything that is going on over there. And that is not to discredit the journalists, they do a great job, there is just so much going on over there, you gotta pick and choose your stories.

For me, one of the greatest tragedies in Afghanistan as a result from the US war is the drug addict problem over ther. I haven't studied the issue in a couple of years, but I remember looking at pictures and statistics of heroin addicts in Afghanistan. As the war destroyed their country citizens turned to drugs and so did leaders, but the latter did so for money. The citizens literally have nothing better to do. And thats not to say they weren't poppy farmers before the war, they were, the majority were just not heroin abusers.

In 2008 I took a seminar about the Afghanistan War, premised on the question, is Afghanistan a failed state? In a room with 12 reasonably bright American students we all were able to point out terrific errors that were causing some big issues. I remember reading that 70-80 percent of the trained Afghani police force was just signed up to get a paycheck. They never showed up for duty or anything.

I do a lot of thinking about Afghanistan, because the situation is unique, yet historically predictable. In my opinion, its hard for me and Americans maybe all westerners, to understand Afghanistan and the people there; and its just as difficult for the people in Afghanistan to understand our way of life, and how to assimilate to what we were setting up.

At present count, 3 people from my high school class have died fighting in Afghanistan, and 5 counting the year ahead of me (0 of my college mates, point for another story..). And this is what counts for me. I like to think that because the situation is complex and can get confusing, the best way to gain an understanding is to study individual stories, stuff that usually gets hidden behind the larger scene.

From the research I have done, the majority of Afghans want peace to the point where they would accept a Taliban strict rule of law over the continued war. Its confusing, but it just shows the war really needs to end.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by ryanmarsh on Monday May 27, 2013 @10:41AM (#5774772)
tl;dr The ground truth is NOTHING like what you see in the MSM. I fought in Iraq as a paratrooper mostly in Baghdad from '04 to '05. While there I was really surprised by the reporting I saw. We had CNN in our hooch (paid Hadji to hook it up). We had satellite Internet (again paid Hadji for it) and I read the NY Times. The reporting there could not have been further from reality. We used to scratch our heads at the reporting each morning on the day prior in Baghdad. It was like they were reporting from a different planet. You should not be surprised that the ground truth is wildly different from what is being reported. My first briefing when I got on the ground in 2004 was that we were past a simple insurgency and now in a small scale civil war that we were trying to stop from becoming a full scale humanitarian crisis. I recall a lot of reporting and very brainy discussion about the insurgency at that time but I don't recall the civil war entering that discussion until late 2005 when I got back to the states. Keep in mind that in Afghanistan most of reporters don't go out without ISAF patrols because that would not be very safe, it was the same in Iraq. This drastically alters the story you get. On the flip side, I'm pleasantly surprised by the courage displayed by some of the PBS Frontline reporters and the places they've gone. I love Frontline. As they say, America isn't at war America is at the shopping mall. The US Army is at war.
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by graycat on Monday May 27, 2013 @11:44AM (#5775023)
> My first briefing when I got on the ground in 2004 was that we were past a simple insurgency and now in a small scale civil war that we were trying to stop from becoming a full scale humanitarian crisis.

That's what I thought, and I was always in the US and getting only US news. Moreover, earlier still, I believed the remarks reported from Saddam that the US occupation would have one heck of a time keeping the Shiites, Sunnis, and Kurds from having a civil war.

W claimed that, of course, the Iraqis could "govern themselves". Where'd George get that really strong funny stuff he was smoking?

Net, W failed to see what large fractions of common street thugs, one step higher lone criminals, low level gang leaders, various mid level opportunists, government officials, religious leaders, tribal leaders, the Iranians, and international trouble makers saw: W's defeat of Saddam without a serious effort at occupation had left Iraq plowed fertile ground for chaos.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by kinkora on Monday May 27, 2013 @08:38AM (#5774423)
Good story.

I've always thought that the situation in Afghanistan can be pretty much summarised in these pictures:

http://static3.businessinsider.com/image/5112c4a969beddd0720...

p/s: it shows the stark differences in Aghanistan from 1967 to 2007

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by rdl on Monday May 27, 2013 @08:43AM (#5774431)
I thought the Kandahar green belt stuff was "help this third-world country develop with the promise of the green revolution" showplace stuff from the west, not the organic state of Afghanistan overall in the 1960s, though. It was certainly otherwise far better back then, but my perception from people from Kandahar (who admittedly weren't really experts; expats who had left in the 1980s) was that it was sort of like Epcot Center or something which had fallen into disrepair.)
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by znowi on Monday May 27, 2013 @10:58AM (#5774836)
> its hard for me and Americans maybe all westerners, to understand Afghanistan and the people there

It's not hard at all. Country A invades country B. Wreaks havoc and assigns a puppet government. Army is in disarray, civilian life is disrupted. It doesn't take a "reasonably bright American student" to guess the conditions and sentiments of the local populace.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by rdl on Monday May 27, 2013 @07:57AM (#5774310)
How did anyone argue "Afghanistan is not a failed state", other than the "it was never a state, so it didn't fail, it just never won" (although in the monarchy it was OK in certain parts, for about a decade).
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by VLM on Monday May 27, 2013 @08:19AM (#5774373)
May not like hearing it, but the argument is usually a backhanded slap against (radical?) Islam.

Consider if you give a religious exception to "widespread violation of human rights" at least as we'd describe human rights, or consider ethnic cleansing and purifying the faith as a feature not a bug. You pretty quickly start running out of reasons to consider the country a failed state, so I guess a lack of checked checkboxes means it must not be a member of the group.

The backhanded part is assuming Islamic country = Afghanistan, Iraq, Somalia aka failed state. Carefully ignoring Muslim majority, or at least lots of Muslims, such as, Turkey, Egypt, Iran, UAE, France, UK, Indonesia, none of which are paradise on earth but then again not anywhere near societal collapse, at least not right now.

Maybe one way to phrase it is the vast majority of currently failed states are Islamic, but that doesn't necessarily prove anything because the vast majority of Islamic states (and/or states with lots of Muslims) are not currently failed states. Carefully ignoring the previous line is how to get in a backhanded slap against Islam.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by rdl on Monday May 27, 2013 @08:28AM (#5774399)
In the case of Afghanistan, even if you were a Muslim, it would be pretty self-evident that Afghanistan is fucked.

(I certainly don't consider Kuwait, UAE, Qatar Oman, Jordan, Turkey, Indonesia, etc. to be failed; I'd say SA, Malaysia and Bahrain have some serious problems but are otherwise fine, etc. Pakistan is dangerously close to failed, and Sudan has some serious issues; Syria is pretty clearly over the line, along with Somalia and Afghanistan.)

Islam didn't have a whole lot to do with why Yemen is or has been a failed state, despite being Islamic. The rise in Islamic violence there is pretty recent; it was mainly a cold war thing combined with a country where everyone is a drug addict (khat).

Congo - not so Islamic. Or Angola during the Cold War. I'd argue that the cold war was a much bigger factor than Islam; Islam and Islamism only became an issue due to the cold war (where Muslim Brotherhood was somewhat Soviet allied in Egypt, and US/Pakistan/ISI funded the Taliban/Muj/etc. in Afghanistan due to the cold war. Before that, we had "Arab Nationalism" which was also co-opted by socialists/communists (mainly because the initial guys were themselves socialists, so it was pretty natural; same thing happened in India until the 1990s)

"Bad leadership" seems like an important factor in countries where neither the Cold War nor Islam were big factors (Haiti seems pretty close to failed...)

As Foreign Policy measures it, it seems like being in Africa is a bigger predictor than being Islamic, actually, too.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by LekkoscPiwa on Monday May 27, 2013 @08:06AM (#5774336)
Afghanistan was a modern state (and do research instead of simple downvote) as recently as 1960s. They had women studying at Universities, they had modern hospitals, you name it.

War radicalized the society. Put them back in stoneage. They have had wars for the past 30-40 years.

USSR death started with Afghanistan. USA death will start with it too. The place is a graveyard of Empires.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by rdl on Monday May 27, 2013 @08:13AM (#5774356)
I knew it was fine from early 1900s until around 1971-1973. I guess it was ok for 30-40'years before that, not just the 1960s (which is what I thought)
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by LekkoscPiwa on Monday May 27, 2013 @09:13AM (#5774524)
I agree with you. However, the 1960s were the peak. I don't like (ideologically) that guy: Slavoj Zizek. He did however travel to Afghanistan before all the wars started. I believe as a student. He said that at that time, Afganistan was quite often portait by the press as an example of a country in which modernization and social progress that went good. I believe he mentions this in that debate: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QhAMgVFKokk
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by rdl on Monday May 27, 2013 @09:33AM (#5774570)
That seems to be a long discussion about polyamory and how it applies to religion (???)
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by LekkoscPiwa on Monday May 27, 2013 @10:00AM (#5774656)
and bunch of other things. Not worth watching 1 hour worth of video just to see one guy saying something.

Try this: http://forums.pelicanparts.com/off-topic-politics-religion/5...

https://www.google.pl/search?q=afghanistan+in+1970+for+women...

Or just google for "Afghanistan in 1970".

The wars caused regular people to support Islam Radicals as they were the ones defending country from outside agression. Also Iran was a country where girls in 1970s wore mini skirts and had equal rights in access to education. Exactly like in the West. The revolution there changed it all.

The more we try influence them the more it is recognized as a foreign occupational forces killing your compatriots. Obviously during the war/occupation people flock to their natives even when they don't agree with them.

Example: Let's say the US was attacked by China and Ku Klux Klan would be defending the country. Taking care of the weak, running hospitals. Organizing attacks on foreign military forces.

Would you be surprised if they gained more influence? And the more foreign occupation forces would try to destroy them, the more support they would have got. Extremism grows and feeds on war.

Another example (this time a historical one, not a fictional): underground Polish army officers were involved in terrorist attacks on Berlin subway system during the WW2. German could have been calling them 'terrorists' (as they did!) all day and night long. Polish citizenry supported them anyway. That's a war. For a war you want the most crazy, delusional, brutal elements to fight it for you - not a liberal democrat concerned about sexual minority rights. I'm talking about occupation here.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by rdl on Monday May 27, 2013 @10:18AM (#5774709)
Iranian history is even more complex than Afghanistan (since Iran is actually worth fighting over; Afghanistan, not so much). Even though the Shah was a pretty good ally of the US, I'm not sure whether the Qajar dynasty vs. others who came after him were better/worse. The semi-communist guy who Anglo-Iranian oil hated (and the US stupidly followed the UK on) might have been one of their better leaders of the past 200 years.

I agree the people who turn into resistance are often extremists, and if they win, can become more powerful. But there are plenty of cases where resistance fighters came from other organized groups who weren't particularly psycho to begin with; Balkans, Arabs during WW2, etc. Organization and logistics probably trumps insanity in predicting whether a group will be effective, as long as the occupier is brutal enough that everyone hates the occupier. Sure, plenty of the leaders and groups were utterly insane (Arkan's Tigers...), but I don't think it was universal on any side.

(btw, this is kind of an interesting tv show that I'd never heard of before! I'm doing some mindless paperwork right now so it's entertaining listening to a somewhat-psycho marxist making more sense than the other people at the table, oh the irony)

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by LekkoscPiwa on Monday May 27, 2013 @10:55AM (#5774823)
I agree with you. I think that if a nation lacks in organization and logistics (de facto any nation under occupation does) - terrorism makes a lot of sense as tactics. Thinking of it just as of war tactics that happens to work when confronted with organized, stronger enemy. That's how you fight such an enemy. I know, I sound controversial here, I'm not a proponent of terrorism though, just noting a fact.

Where I would be a proponent of terror is here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=orv1kmkiEpk

And I'm not Marxist. I'm a liberal-conservative. Yeah, Zizek is a dangerous guy, lol.

Why we loose with Radical Islam? Because we have no teeth behind our values. It's not like we're going to guillotine muslim radicals taking away women rights. It's not like we're going to guillotine bankers and politicians destroying capitalism in the name of crony capitalism with zombie banks ran on the back of tax payer. We need a liberal revolution, and I hope one will come in my lifetime.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by cafard on Monday May 27, 2013 @09:01AM (#5774491)
Graveyard of Empires? The disasters of WWs I and II surely had more to do with the decline of the British Empire than anything that happened in Afghanistan.
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by kyboren on Monday May 27, 2013 @10:01AM (#5774661)
Have you heard of William MacNaghten? Alexander Burnes? Do you remember the massacre of the British garrison from Kabul, or the awful retribution that followed?

Yes, WWII was the direct precipitating event for the breakup of the British Empire, but the seeds of its destruction were sown long ago in that great Central Asian imperial struggle with Russia.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by LekkoscPiwa on Monday May 27, 2013 @09:07AM (#5774507)
I haven't mentioned anything about UK. I was saying USSR and the USA.
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by darkarmani on Monday May 27, 2013 @11:12AM (#5774898)
I thought it was the Pope or Reagan?
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by panacea on Monday May 27, 2013 @08:06AM (#5774338)
I honestly don't desire to belittle or discount your anecdotes, but equating failed state = drug abusing population seems problematic when you look around in the West.
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by smackay on Monday May 27, 2013 @08:22AM (#5774377)
You have to think of it in terms of the nightmare that is unfolding in Mexico rather than recreational use of drugs by people who are otherwise able to support themselves with jobs.
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by rdl on Monday May 27, 2013 @08:56AM (#5774474)
In both Mexico and Afghanistan, it's not so much local consumption of drugs which is the problem, but production/distribution/etc. of drugs for export or transshipment.

Yemen has a drug use problem (with Khat), leading to a lack of water, etc., but that's nowhere near as serious as narco-insurgency.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by graycat on Monday May 27, 2013 @09:07AM (#5774509)
> From the research I have done, the majority of Afghans want peace to the point where they would accept a Taliban strict rule of law over the continued war. Its confusing, but it just shows the war really needs to end.

As I looked at US efforts at essentially 'nation building', often on the other side of the world, to try to contribute to US national security, I came up with a simple observation:

In a country with a government and economy that function at all, there has to be and is a 'culture' with social structures, education, economic activity, leadership, laws, government, usually religion, etc. While such a culture has to exist, it may be very different from that in the US.

In Afghanistan and much of the Muslim world, the 'culture' is heavily just Islam: Islam controls social structures, e.g., sex, marriage, child rearing, the role of family, etc. Islam also controls most of education, much of the economic activity, essentially all the laws, the police, the justice system, the government, the foreign policy, and, of course, religion. We can toss in architecture, what people eat, and what they wear. Basically from how people dress, eat, work, etc., its all Islam. So, in an Islamic country, take away Islam, and there's no culture at all and, then, just chaos, e.g., criminals, gangs, civil war, etc. Net, in an Islamic country, for a government leader can have an Islamic king (e.g., Kuwait), Islamic strong man dictator (Saddam, Assad), or Islamic cleric (Iran). That's about it.

One can try to set up a Western, secular government in an Islamic country, but the leader will have no cultural foundation to stand on and, thus, will be trying to sell pie in the sky. Meanwhile the clerics will be working 24 x 7 to get their people up on their hind legs against the guy, and too soon he will lose, maybe his head.

For anything like US democracy, laws, police, secular government, freedom of religion, etc., just f'get about it. We need to understand: In the US, our 'culture' of democracy is much more than just our Constitution and elections. Instead, in addition, nearly all of us have 'bought into' a 'social contract' where we believe in, invest in, and trust in our democracy. So for most significant transgressions against the 'culture', the voters get indignant, outraged, incensed, infuriated, and up on their hind legs and vote! E.g., each member of the House has to stand for election each two years, which is darned short, and keeps him on a very short leash, and if he messes up then likely he's out'a there. To borrow from a Bond movie, getting caught in a motel room with a cheerleader does nicely.

Really the Islamic countries are about 500 years behind the history of Western Europe, e.g., when Western Europe was fighting wars of religion and starting to develop respect for humanism, individual freedom, secular government, and democracy. Moving ahead 500 years is not easy. The rivers of Europe ran red with blood for hundreds of years before we got to 'Western Civilization'. Europe has been the most effectively bloody place on the planet until finally it started to learn to live in peace, recently, hopefully.

Net, Afghanistan is going to be an Islamic country, some version of an Islamic country, but still an Islamic country, likely run by a king, strong man, or cleric. Sorry 'bout that. We won't like such a 'culture': Some of the men use boys for sex. They marry off their daughters at age 7 or 13 or some such. They refuse to educate females. They use Islamic laws and justice. Islam runs essentially everything.

That's just the way it is. That's the reality. We need to face the reality. We don't like it. We see it as a 500 year out of date sh!tpit, and we are correct. Right, it sucks. We know that.

Then, facing that reality, we can look for how to get what we need, e.g., US national security, that is, to keep Afghanistan from being the base of operations of another 9/11 attack on the US.

Okay, then, that's what we really need, our real 'bottom line': Keep Afghanistan from being the base of operations of another 9/11 attack on the US. We need little or nothing more than that from Afghanistan. Can we get that? Sure. How? Two steps. Step 1. Put in place a bunch of INTEL. Step 2. Leave. [It took the US 12 years to figure this out?] If our INTEL tells us that they are starting to attack the US again, then level them, appropriate places plus some for good measure, from the air. Done.

What will happen after we leave? Mostly we don't give a sh!t. But I'd put my money on a government run by an Islamic cleric, e.g., the Taliban.

Now, US military, welcome home. Well done.

Yes, we can be sure that the Muslim clerics will get their people up on their hind legs shouting "Death to America". Sounds like a declaration of war to me for which some USAF guy in a container room in Nevada should push a button on a drone control and stop that stuff. But if all they do is shout, then we don't always have to push the button.

England was long smart enough to work effectively in that part of the world, in Egypt, Palestine, Syria, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, Kuwait, Iran, Pakistan, India, Burma, Singapore, etc., without getting all bent out of shape trying to bring English culture to those places.

The US needs to quit being so darned simplistic, wise up, learn from the English 150 years ago, update the lessons a little, use our drones, INTEL, etc., do the smart things, and quit bleeding the US white on absurd foreign adventures from just totally unrealistic, head in the sand, simplistic foreign policy nonsense. We will not get what we have wanted in Afghanistan. Instead we will wise up and get what we can and need or just go broke on nonsense.

What's it going to be US, wise up or go broke?

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by neebz on Monday May 27, 2013 @11:45AM (#5775027)
Have you ever been to an Islamic country ever? You just made up the whole history like a simplistic comic book story.

> In Afghanistan and much of the Muslim world, the 'culture' is heavily just Islam: Islam controls social structures, e.g., sex, marriage, child rearing, the role of family, etc.

I am from Pakistan. Our culture is massive mix of Indian/sub-continental traditions, Islamic values and most recently westerns customs. There is a strong case that our marriage, sex etc. are more inclined towards traditional indian culture than islamic (e.g. second marriages or marrying a divorcee is a taboo in Pakistan while in fact is encouraged in Islam). There is so much diversity in our provinces on how they deal with women (e.g. in Punjab in rural areas, it is very common for women to have jobs, unlike in the Pashtuns) that your claim of sweeping all Islamic countries under one broom is laughable.

> We can toss in architecture, what people eat, and what they wear. Basically from how people dress, eat, work, etc., its all Islam. No it's not. Sorry that's just show your lack of research. Again the 'shalwar kameez' we wear here in Pakistan has more in common with Hindu lineage than Islam with the urban areas are totally jeans/suits. We have huge interest-based banks since forever where banks are a total no-no in Islam.

>Afghanistan is going to be an Islamic country, some version of an Islamic country, but still an Islamic country, likely run by a king, strong man, or cleric

Not sure you can lump up kings with clerics and make an argument out of that. The only thing common between then is opportunist. They wanted to be on the throne and they might've used religion in some cases or maybe sheer power in other. In Pakistan, more than half of our history, we've been ruled by dictators but not once we got an Imam or a cleric.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by graycat on Monday May 27, 2013 @12:35PM (#5775247)
> I am from Pakistan. Our culture is massive mix of Indian/sub-continental traditions, Islamic values and most recently westerns customs

Apparently the main part of Pakistan relevant to Afghanistan is the 'tribal regions' mostly not governed by the rest of Pakistan. There your claims of a "mix" seem to be not correct.

Further, much of the problem the US has had with Pakistan is from the strong role of Islam there and in Afghanistan. For reasons of religion, culture, domestic politics, and foreign policy, Pakistan has been mostly on the side of the Taliban, that is, wants to dominate Afghanistan.

My comments about Islam were focused on Afghanistan. The comments also apply a lot to Iran and Iraq. For Pakistan, sure, it used to be part of India which is wildly mixed from Muslim, Hindu, what it got from the British, and the old cultures from before the British. India is a forbiddingly complicated place, and Pakistan has been influenced by that.

But the main reason for the formation of Pakistan was just Islam -- they wanted an Islamic country. Net, the main culture in Pakistan is just Islam.

Italy is heavily a Roman Catholic country, but the church does not run everything. Turkey is an Islamic country, but the clerics don't run everything. An Islamic country can have a culture more varied than just Islam. No doubt the culture of Pakistan is more varied than that of Afghanistan.

The main interest in this tread is what the heck is the US going to do about Afghanistan and why? The main content of why is just the role of Islam.

The US brought to Afghanistan constitutional government, free elections, roads, schools, hospitals, training and equipment for police and a military, but Afghanistan is about to throw away all of that and return to an 'Islamic state' run by the Taliban. Thus, I and much of the US are losing patience with both Afghanistan and Islam.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by neebz on Monday May 27, 2013 @02:12PM (#5775812)
> Apparently the main part of Pakistan relevant to Afghanistan is the 'tribal regions' mostly not governed by the rest of Pakistan. There your claims of a "mix" seem to be not correct.

They do. The 'tribal regions' are known 'tribal' for a reason. They are dominated by tribes, who have there own traditions & rivalry. They have affiliations with Taliban because of Pashtun traditions. This affiliation goes back even before the Pakistan came into being. Islam is a cultural part of this region but not the sole driving force. They used poppy/heroine for ages but Islam strictly prohibits using drugs. So yet another sample where your nice little narrative doesn't fit.

> Further, much of the problem the US has had with Pakistan is from the strong role of Islam there and in Afghanistan

erm ..US played an important role during the Afghan-Russia war. They actually pumped up the Jihadist sentiment at that time. Religion in the grand scheme has just been a tool to achieve interest.

> For reasons of religion, culture, domestic politics, and foreign policy, Pakistan has been mostly on the side of the Taliban, that is, wants to dominate Afghanistan.

Only foreign policy. Pakistan cannot afford to fight with neighbors on both sides of border. That's the sole reason Pakistan wants to friend whoever comes into power in Afghanistan (apparently the notorious double-game Pak army has been playing with US is because once US goes back they would have to deal with Taliban ..and they want to be in there good books). Pakistan has also been super-friendly with China but no religion, culture, domestic politics play any role in that. It's only foreign policy.

> My comments about Islam were focused on Afghanistan. The comments also apply a lot to Iran and Iraq

You do know Iraq fought war with Saudia Arabia ..the be and end all of all things Islam ? You do know how things were in Iran before the revolution ? If you start looking things from an economics-perspective then everything fits in place. There are some nut-jobs who leave everything to go and fight for the sake of religion but the majority of the population doesn't do that. They just want good food and good living style regardless of whose in power. Iranian revolution can be traced back to that as well.

> But the main reason for the formation of Pakistan was just Islam -- they wanted an Islamic country. Net, the main culture in Pakistan is just Islam.

then how come there hasn't been any Islamic governing system in Pakistan since the creation? There are gazillion open things in this country which are against the very premise of Islam yet no one talks about that. Pakistan wasn't created by an imam or cleric. The most ironic thing (and I would suggest you should go and study that) is that creation of Pakistan was opposed by virtually every single cleric at that time. Founder of Pakistan (Jinnah) lead a very secular life & wasn't a fan-favourite of Islamic imams at that time. Pakistan was created because Muslims were living a second-class life in all of India. Again economic reasons.

> The main interest in this tread is what the heck is the US going to do about Afghanistan and why? The main content of why is just the role of Islam.

That I agree. But that is not something which you can use as a reason to justify how things work in every Muslim country out there. US invaded Afghanistan at a time when they had right-wing extremists in power. So obviously they'll have to deal with problems in the same domain. You don't need to create grand conclusions out of it.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by graycat on Monday May 27, 2013 @09:55PM (#5777574)
I can't compete with you on details of Pakistan!

But, somehow while supposedly trying to help the US bring peace to Afghanistan, Bin Laden lived in a relatively large and nice house for some years about a good golf shot from the Pakistan army college. And no one knew he was there?

And when President Clinton fired cruise missiles at the Bin Laden training camp in Afghanistan, US Secretary of State Albright (also known as Half-bright) informed the Pakistan government since the missiles would have to fly over Pakistan territory. Then somehow Half-bright's information made it to Bin Laden who was well out of the area when the missiles arrived.

Of course Islam is not all there is to it, not in Turkey, Indonesia, Pakistan, or even Afghanistan. And clearly economics is also important.

But my point was about 'culture'. Or just why have US efforts to create democracy in Afghanistan failed? My answer, culture: There's no real basis for democracy in Afghanistan culture. Does this mean that Afghanistan has no culture? No, they do. They have a strong culture, one that runs nearly everything, Islam. Get rid of Islam and they don't have much except maybe a few goats, some poppies, some rusty AK-47s. So, they don't get rid of Islam. Not all of Islam is against democracy, but the culture in Afghanistan is Islam with no foundation for democracy.

This thread (sorry about the times I typed 'tread' instead) has mentioned that in part the Taliban act like the Mafia in Italy and at times parts of the US. That's some of what I thought, and, yes, it's not from Islam. But the main reason for a Mafia is that there is no good alternative system of police and government. With a good system of police, when a Mafia guy comes to a store owner and asks for a monthly payment, the store owner can go to the police who will be waiting when the Mafia guy comes and accepts the money and then ... lock up the Mafia guy for a long time. But this system needs a good culture to support such good police and, thus, good police to protect the citizens. In contrast, all Afghanistan has in culture is just Islam; Islam doesn't provide good support of police that support the citizens; there's no other culture; so the Taliban get to use Mafia tactics. Neither the Taliban nor the villagers believe that a democracy should be better. So, Islam and Mafia tactics are what's there.

It's not that Islam is against good police protection; it's mostly just that Islam doesn't provide good police protection, and in Afghanistan Islam is essentially all the culture. So, no good police protection. And it's not that an Islamic country can't have good police protection; I can believe that some Islamic countries have some very strong police. But in Afghanistan, about all there is is Islam and next to nothing about good police or democracy. And the Islamic clerics? It's not in their interest to see the growth of strong, secular institutions such as good police. So, again, no good police force can grow up.

Or Islamic Sharia law: Try to implement something descended from Napoleonic law or British Common law, etc., and, in a country that has essentially only Islam, many Muslims will keep asking for Sharia law. So, get a 500 year old legal system.

Education? Try to set up a 21st century, or 20th century, education system, and, in a country that has essentially only Islam, a lot of Muslims will insist on Islamic education instead. Halt: Again out of date by 500 years.

Look, if Islam were only religion, then it would be much less of a road block to progress in Afghanistan. Instead, Islam is running nearly everything there and, thus, is able to block nearly any change or progress.

A big point about Islam for people in the US is that Islam is not just religion but is also how to dress, what to eat, how to run a marriage, education, architecture, system of laws, government, etc. So, in the less developed Islamic countries, Islam is a roadblock to change. E.g., in Iraq, there are two sides to Islam, the Shiites and the Sunnis. So, since they have little more important in their lives than just their religion, they fight. They would just rather have a civil war than get on with pumping oil and living a life of milk and honey. They did that already in Europe, been there, done that, got the T-shirt, and had the rivers running red for hundreds of years from religious wars. Finally they learned: Have politics and government separate from and largely independent of religion; have freedom of religion; and don't fight over religion. Done. When the Muslims in, say, Iraq learn that lesson, they will be ahead some hundreds of years.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by neebz on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @01:06AM (#5778189)
> But, somehow while supposedly trying to help the US bring peace to Afghanistan, Bin Laden lived in a relatively large and nice house for some years about a good golf shot from the Pakistan army college. And no one knew he was there?

again, very trivial story. there is an argument to be made that how plausible it is for OBL to live in hiding in Pak but lets for a second we assume that Pakistan were providing a lovely cushy place for him to hide. The reasons are not Islamic, cultural, brotherhood ..it's plain old foreign policy. The war in Afghanistan brings aid and modern technology to Pak Army. And they are suckers for that. Our Army did the same when you guys funded Afghanistan in Russia war (and guess what they build a whole Atomic bomb out of it) and they did the same this time. Nothing to do with your grand illusions of how Islam runs thing here. It's all money. The generals will spend there weekend drinking & dancing (again banned in Islam!) to celebrate there achievements.

---

and as for all your other points which is basically how Islam is hindering progress in Afghanistan: so at least you started with Islamic countries and then narrowed it down to the failed ones and now we are in Afghanistan only. So I'll say that's good progress. You can't compete me on Pakistan on details but you can't do that for Iran, Afghanistan or any other Islamic country. And these are not some hidden research which I did. You only need to visit the country once & meet with common people to understand how your nice little good (democracy) vs evil (religion) doesn't fit. It'll be an eye-opener.

Yes..Islam covers every aspect of life but the number of people who follow Islam like that are less than 0.1% of the world population. And I've given you gazillion examples of that (heck! we have a bigger red district area in Lahore than Amsterdam). Afghanistan was fairly happy with their system a few decades ago. They had universities, tourism, working-women ..all sweet. But then the Russia war happened & it's been downhill since then. Have you ever talked to an Afghani all your life? I can only assume no. Your total knowledge seems to come from watching OBL/Taliban released video speeches.

And I can't even fathom how you think Iraq learned the lessons. The only thing your ill-fated war brought to Iraq is more "love for religion" and more "Death to America". Maybe you have to make these sweet conclusions to make you sleep at night or something but it's hilariously unfounded and naive.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by pooriaazimi on Monday May 27, 2013 @03:11PM (#5776084)
> The comments also apply a lot to Iran and Iraq.

No, it doesn't. I don't disagree with you on the whole (and certainly appreciate that you are even attempting to understand the issue, which is more than almost anyone does), but like neebz I think your narrative is very simplistic and out of touch with reality.

Islam is not as powerful in the "Islamic world" as you portrayed. Taliban is the exception, not the rule.

I currently live in Tehran, and TBH I personally know less than 8 people (less, because it's been a while since I've talked to a few of them) who are supportive of the government, or in general of Islamic rule. And the number of "religious" (as in, religion is more than something theoretical for them - you believe in Quran, and even though you don't follow it's instructions, the mere belief gets you a place in paradise) people I personally know is probably no more than 20 (most of them friends at college).

The reason for Islamic rule (at least in Iran), is not because they have the support of the people, but simply because they have the money and power. You don't sell hundreds of billions of dollars of crude oil every quarter and get rich and powerful, only to allow to be overthrown! You do everything you can to prevent that.

I hate typing on iPad, so, please read the rest of what I wanted to say in this comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4820604

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by graycat on Monday May 27, 2013 @10:26PM (#5777671)
> Islam is not as powerful in the "Islamic world" as you portrayed. Taliban is the exception, not the rule.

Sure. But I was talking mostly about Afghanistan. And the US got 'impatient' with the Shiite/Sunni fighting in Iraq. And the Shiite yelling and screaming, "Death to America" from Iran is difficult to respect.

For the connection between the clerics and the economy in Iran, there was an article in, maybe, 'Forbes' long ago explaining that basically the clerics get a 'cut' of nearly everything in the economy, control who gets to do what, etc.

But, why? That is, why are the Islamic clerics in Iran running the economy with a short leash and running an aggressive military and foreign policy at great cost to their domestic standard of living? Is this just religion? No. But Islam is not just religion and, instead, is often also economic, legal, military, foreign policy, etc. That's not new: The Roman Catholic church was doing that in Europe for hundreds of years. They owned a major fraction of all the farm land in France which has a major fraction of all the good farm land in Western Europe. They built little things like the cathedrals, while the people were living in, what, mud huts? They built the Bishop's Residenz in Würzburg, awash in some of the fanciest art and architecture in all of civilization -- not cheap, and built by citizens in, what, mud huts? The Roman Catholic church was running everything. E.g., to be a king, had to have the Pope tap you on the head or some such. And they were corrupt. So, they had the Protestant Reformation, religious wars, etc. Lots of blood. Finally they learned their lessons about religion. In the US, we borrowed those lessons -- the state will establish no religion; there will be separation of church and state; there will be freedom of religion. Done. Iraq, Iran, and Afghanistan still have to learn these old lessons.

Sorry about the Shah; he was a pawn in the Cold War. The US had just finished WWII and, thus, took the Cold War seriously. We spent a LOT of money, and blood, winning the Cold War.

Iraq, Iran, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, the other Arab oil states, should all do the same thing: Cool down. Relax. Embrace peace. Get the clerics into religion only. No more clerics measuring the lengths of women's skirts or censoring the Internet. Pump oil. Enjoy life. Then work on culture, good government, education, technology, and a strong economy for when the oil runs out. And stop shouting "Death to America". Want nuclear power for electric power, taking the salt out of water and growing vegetables? Fine. Just accept the usual international rules, safeguards, and inspections, and light up your cities and have fountains and big swimming pools of pure water.

All this fighting is over nothing, wasteful, and absurd.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by pooriaazimi on Monday May 27, 2013 @11:31PM (#5777870)
(sorry that this comment is not at all coherent - I have a bad headache right now)

I agree. But the problem is that those who chant "Death to America", like the status quo; they don't want change! If things change (like you said in the second to last paragraph), they'll be out of their jobs and have to do an honest day's work. They don't want that. And do everything they can to prevent that. They "have" to portray US as the "Great Satan", that is behind all their economic, cultural and political mistakes.

It might be strange and unfathomable to you and me, but some people prefer to be King in a wasteland, than to be an ordinary citizen in a country with much greater standard of living. They'd rather be a powerful Mullah in Taliban, than to live normally in a western country. Many of these clerics have spent years studying in European countries, but after finishing college they've left the west and now are living in a shack somewhere in Ghandahar and are the local commander of Taliban. Why? I don't know.

Most of these people won't "cool down, relax or embrace peace", because they are enjoying their shitty lives. And that's the problem, because they have the power to make life miserable for others too. They'd sooner bomb their people (Saddam, Ghadafi, Assad) and ruin their own country, than to "let it go".

There are exceptions like Mubarak or Bin Ali (or Iran's Shah) that fought furiously, but in the end decided not to completely ruin their countries and fled. But not all dictators are like that; some are like Assad.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by pekk on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @01:23AM (#5778240)
I hope you are very careful, your commentary is really interesting but I worry for you writing things like what you said about Shah and Assad from there.
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by lobster_johnson on Monday May 27, 2013 @01:03PM (#5775388)
Turkey is a secular state. While the population is muslim, the state has historically resisted attempts at islamification. That resistance is being eroded, however.

Off-topic: You seem to be using the word "net" a lot in a way that seems odd to me. Net as in "the net effect of which is"?

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by graycat on Monday May 27, 2013 @08:38PM (#5777354)
"Net" is partly from accounting where we calculate, say, earnings, and have already subtracted off expenses, etc.

More generally "net" means a summary or a very simple statement of the core point.

In writing to be understood, often it is good be clear, and even too simple, about the main 'points'. Otherwise it is too easy that no 'points' at all get across.

Your comment and at least two 'siblings' are far more thoughtful than mine was so that my oversimplifying with "net" is not appropriate.

Back here in the US, after 9/11 and now 12 years in Afghanistan, we need to make some difficult decisions: We tried, hard but in total ('net'!) not hard enough, to make Afghanistan a "shining city on a hill" but apparently have failed and maybe even 'net' have done more harm than good.

Bin laden is gone. The Taliban government that let Bin Laden use their country as a base to attack the US is not gone but is out of power. There are stories that some even in the Taliban now understand that it was a big mistake to let Bin Laden use Afghanistan as a base to attack the US.

The US has tried 'nation building' in several countries of the world. We were largely successful in Germany and Japan. With US military protection, Taiwan and South Korea have done well. The US has tried hard to have peace with both Russia and China and not have them become another 'Axis' like Germany and Japan in the 1940s. Still, in Viet Nam, Cambodia, Iraq, and Afghanistan, the results of US efforts been from frustrating and/or poor (Iraq) down to worse.

Viet Nam is the grand tragedy: I have a nice 600 dot per inch black and white printer from Brother, made in Viet Nam. Terrific for Viet Nam. The US couldn't be happier. The Brother printer is much better than the HP printer I bought in 1994. That Brother and Viet Nam are at least in part beating HP in the printer business is mostly fine in the US (except for HP stockholders!). As far as I can tell, what Viet Nam is now is just fine with the US. The big, huge point for the US is that Viet Nam is not part of some Axis of Moscow, Peking, and Hanoi that seemed to be a threat starting just after WWII where the US had just defeated the Axis and didn't like things that looked like an Axis. The WWII Axis also hurt Viet Nam -- Japan occupied Viet Nam.

But, the way Viet Nam is today, it is clearly no threat to its neighbors or the US, and that's really all the US wanted. The US didn't want a colony, and for the rubber or lumber, wanted to pay fair prices for it.

The tragedy is that Viet Nam and US relations as they are today could have been just the same in the early 1970s, the 1960s, ..., back to just after WWII (to heck with the French) just by both sides just deciding to and shaking hands on it.

In summary ('net'), the US has tried, sometimes at great expense in US blood and treasure, often with much more expense in blood in the other country, sometimes been successful, and sometimes not. When we have failed, we didn't really know why.

For why the US was successful in Germany and Japan, both countries had very strong, highly disciplined cultures, suffered just devastating, horrible, defeats, with homeless people wandering cold and hungry in the streets with rotting bodies under piles of rubble, and then used their discipline to say "never again", mean it, implement it, do a lot of really hard work, and rebuild themselves.

So, 'culture' played a part. So, why not success in Afghanistan? My view: Culture. The culture was different; either the US didn't understand it or it was insufficient. What was that culture? In a word, Islam; it runs nearly everything. The US tried to build a 'secular' (independent of religion) democracy, and the Taliban have Islam on their side. The US has B-52 bombers from 40,000 feet, GPS location, A-10 airplanes that reduce tanks to piles of scrap iron in seconds, supersonic F-16 airplanes that can reduce a tank to scattered scrap iron in even less time, schools, hospitals, etc. and lose, and the Taliban have sticks, stones, some RPGs, and rusty AK-47s and win. To me, the main difference is that the Taliban have the 'culture', in this case, Islam, on their side.

Whatever, likely the US will be leaving Afghanistan, fairly soon.

For the US, it's much more difficult to attack us now. In particular, it's difficult even to have nail clippers on a US commercial airplane. And I can believe that in many Islamic countries, anyone shouting "Jihad! Death to ..." will quickly get a 'corrective lesson' they won't forget, maybe even can't forget.

For Turkey, if they become more fundamentally Islamic, then they will find that the US, NATO, the EU, and maybe even Russia will become much less friendly.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by ucee054 on Monday May 27, 2013 @08:48PM (#5777393)
The comments also apply a lot to Iran and Iraq

If you think Salafist Afghanistan, Kohmeinist Iran and Baathist Iraq had anything in common then you know jack shit.

That's like comparing Nazi Germany, Soviet Russia and the US colonies in Cotton Mather's time, sticking them all into one big pot because they are all "Christian". Idiocy.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by graycat on Monday May 27, 2013 @10:47PM (#5777738)
You miss the point: It's not that all the versions of Islam and Islamic governments are alike. Instead, it's that in the more backward Islamic countries, Islam is essentially all the culture there is. And Islam is not just a religion but is also into law, government, education, etc. So, in such a country, Islam is about all the culture there is and can block, actively or just passively by default, essentially all progress.

As you point out, there are still some differences. But what is in common is that Islam, in whatever flavors, is so strong, and not just a religion, and essentially all the culture there is, is able to block progress.

Look, to be more clear, the problem is not just Islam. Instead, the Roman Catholics ran everything in Western Europe for hundreds of years, were corrupt, blocked progress, and finally Europe got out of it, after religious wars, etc.

The point is not that Islam is a bad religion, even if it is. Instead the point is that to run a good society, need a good culture, and that culture needs to come from much more than just some religious clerics. A religious state, Roman Catholic, Islamic, or anything else, just will not be a successful state. In the countries where Islam is the only culture, Islam needs to shrink back to being just a religion, hopefully one of several, and let the culture have other inputs besides just religion. Got it now?

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by ucee054 on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @11:10AM (#5780465)
Got it now?

Don't patronize me. You wrote a screed justifying bombing the hell out of civilians because you didn't like their speech. Somewhere in your moral bankruptcy, you wrote

So, in an Islamic country, take away Islam, and there's no culture at all and, then, just chaos

This was your characterization of Iran and Iraq, which showed that you don't know jack. It also won't work for Turkey or Malaysia.

By the way, "nation building" failed in Germany as well, largely because Americans are hypocrites who SAY "nation building" and DO war profiteering, corruption and vindictiveness. The result was Adolf Hitler.

So the US had to fight another World War with Germany, and after getting their asses kicked so badly by the Axis, and coming close to losing in several ways, the US decided in 1945 to do actual nation building in half good faith, hence the Marshall Plan. This time round, it succeeded in Germany and Japan.

Unfortunately, the US forgot this lesson by 9/11, so when it came to Iraq and Afghanistan, they went back to "nation building" by Blackwater XE and Halliburton, with predictable results.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by bokonist on Monday May 27, 2013 @01:01PM (#5775380)
"Really the Islamic countries are about 500 years behind the history of Western Europe... Moving ahead 500 years is not easy.Net, Afghanistan is going to be an Islamic country, some version of an Islamic country, but still an Islamic country, likely run by a king, strong man, or cleric. Sorry 'bout that. We won't like such a 'culture': Some of the men use boys for sex."

Taliban-style regressive Islam is not 500 years old in Afghanistan, it is only a few decades old. Check out these pictures from Afghanistan in the 1960's: http://blogs.denverpost.com/captured/2013/01/28/podlich-afgh...

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by graycat on Monday May 27, 2013 @11:05PM (#5777795)
Yes, for a while, parts of Afghanistan started to look modern.

But the point is, to have a good country, need a good culture. But about all Afghanistan has is Islamic culture, and it is more than just a religion -- it is also about food, clothing, education, laws, government, etc. Just can't have a good culture, good enough for a good country, from just a religious culture. E.g., people in Afghanistan do not have enough information to have any good reason to believe in democracy so don't. So, the Taliban with Islam and Mafia techniques can run the place better than the elected government the US helped set up.

Right, the Taliban are not 500 years old, but Islam is. If Islam were just a religion, then the 500 years might not be so bad. But with Islamic culture, also get Islamic laws, education, and government, and those are 500 years out of date and bad.

Talk to a guy 500 years ago about US democracy in the 21st century, and he will think you've been smoking funny stuff. Well, that's about what the US faces in Afghanistan.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by infinitone on Monday May 27, 2013 @09:48AM (#5774618)
> For anything like US democracy, laws, police, secular government, freedom of religion, etc., just f'get about it.

Clearly you haven't read much history about Islam and can only see the world from what the US media feeds you. Somehow you've been led to think that US 'democracy' is the epitome of a civil world and if a nation is unlike it- then it is some dystopian society.

Islam had all of those things during its founding and up until the Mongols came- during its reign the most controversial land were once governed by peace and had all Christians/Jews/Muslims living side by side. To not cut too much from your time watching Fox News, here's a primer on history; http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TpcbfxtdoI8

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by graycat on Monday May 27, 2013 @11:27AM (#5774960)
> Clearly you haven't read much history about Islam and can only see the world from what the US media feeds you.

It's not about me. It's about current US foreign policy with respect to the current Afghanistan and some other Islamic countries. The movie 'Lawrence of Arabia' claimed that there was lighting on the streets in Damascus 900 years ago or some such. Fine. Terrific. But that doesn't say much about the Islamic countries today.

If you see something wrong with what is in the US media about current Islamic countries, especially Iraq, Iran, Afghanistan, and Pakistan, then be clear where they are going wrong.

> Somehow you've been led to think that US 'democracy' is the epitome of a civil world and if a nation is unlike it- then it is some dystopian society.

What I wrote clearly claims that the US has "totally unrealistic, head in the sand, simplistic foreign policy nonsense", thus, meaning that I don't claim that the US is your "epitome of a civil world". But considering Libya, Egypt, Yemen, Somalia, Iraq, Iran, Afghanistan, and Pakistan, I'd pick the US. Maybe there's hope for Lebanon returning to be the Paris of the Mideast. And maybe Jordan and Kuwait are doing well.

I suspect that the Saudis are making a strong and sincere effort to move forward some centuries quickly, e.g., before their oil runs out. But they have a long way to go and are moving slowly, as likely they should.

Since you are interested in history, here's one from history for you: Religion running everything and religious governments don't work very well. Europe figured this out after some hundreds of years of their rivers running red from religious wars.

The lesson is still true, and the Islamic countries need to figure this out. But a big, huge problem in many Islamic countries is that Islam is the only 'culture' they have so that without Islam they are left with no culture at all and quite literally don't know what clothes to put on or what to eat for dinner. So, they can't just throw out Islamic culture; instead they have to replace it with something better, slowly.

For Singapore, Taiwan, Japan, and South Korea, clearly they do some things well, but they are all Asian, and I would never be able to figure out Asian culture.

Sometimes I wonder considering Canada, Switzerland, Holland, Denmark, Sweden, Norway, Finland, Scotland and the US, maybe I wouldn't still pick the US. Maybe. But I've been in the US so long I likely wouldn't fit in at any of those other countries. I suspect that, still, net, net, the US is the best place. For France, Italy, and Austria, maybe someday I will go on a food tour and pig out in Paris, Marseilles, the Piedmont, and Vienna!

> To not cut too much from your time watching Fox News

I cut out TV. For Fox, I got tired of O'Reilly and couldn't stand Chris Wallace. O'Reilly was too often wrong, and Wallace was just so obnoxious he wasn't even wrong. Then my cable company offered me TV, phone, and Internet for less than just phone and Internet, so I accepted. The set-top box has been sitting here for several months, and I use it for a clock. So far I have yet to attach a TV to it. And I have no other source of TV. I haven't watched any TV, or Fox News, in months. On the Internet, I don't much like the Fox Web site. Your assumption that I watch Fox News is just flatly wrong.

> here's a primer on history

And I wrote on current events. I made it really simple: We can't fix the culture of Afghanistan. So, for US national security, step 1, put INTEL in place. Step 2, leave. If our INTEL tells us that they are about to attack us again, then level them. Done. History doesn't have much to do with it.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by Symmetry on Monday May 27, 2013 @10:37AM (#5774759)
The relation between Islam and society is actually a lot more complicated than that. Go to Pakistan and ask 10 Imams about honor killings[1]. Eight will hem and haw, one will say that it's against the Koran and needs to be stopped, and one will say it might be against the Koran but it's so important it needs to continue.

I do find the rules Muhammad laid down to have a lot of problems, but they were a big improvement over the existing traditions in the area and would be a big improvement over what people actually do in Afghanistan.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by draugadrotten on Monday May 27, 2013 @11:24AM (#5774952)
>Go to Pakistan and ask 10 Imams about honor killings[1]. Eight will hem and haw, one will say that it's against the Koran and needs to be stopped, and one will say it might be against the Koran but it's so important it needs to continue.

Go to the USA and ask 10 pastors about drone strikes. Eight will hem and haw, one will say that it's against the Bible and needs to be stopped, and one will say it might be against the Bible but it's so important it needs to continue.

"Those who say religion has nothing to do with politics do not know what religion is." Mahatma Gandhi

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by Symmetry on Monday May 27, 2013 @11:57AM (#5775078)
Oh certainly they would, though I suspect the ratios are different. Mohammad was running a theocracy within his lifetime, so all the compromises and practicalities that were needed to actually govern. There's still a large amount of tradition that has to be applied, but you can talk about the Islamic way to govern much, much more concretely than the Christian way. Which if you believe in moral progress is a bit of a problem with Islam, but not one I'm going to dwell on when talking about societies that would be better off following the Koran more closely.

And incidentally, your point is somewhat opaque but I believe you're taking that Gandhi quote to mean the opposite of what he meant. That is, it isn't that politics does influence religion but that politics ought to be influence by religion.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by dctoedt on Monday May 27, 2013 @12:53PM (#5775333)
> Step 1. Put in place a bunch of INTEL.

This sounds suspiciously like Step 2 of the South Park underpants-gnome meme; it detracts from other good points you make.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by graycat on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @12:03AM (#5777975)
I kept it simple. A longer description is that with modern technology we don't really have to occupy, run, or have a big presence in the place to know what's going on. And when we do see something that is a threat to the US, we can stop it without 100,000 troops in the country. For the show you mentioned, never saw any such thing!
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by dctoedt on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @07:27AM (#5779309)
You're pretty optimistic about those two things. The history of the past 10 years, and for that matter of the past 50 years, suggests that both are decidedly non-trivial challenges, with or without "modern technology."
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by wnight on Monday May 27, 2013 @11:35AM (#5774985)
> Then, facing that reality, we can look for how to get what we need, e.g., US national security, that is, to keep Afghanistan from being the base of operations of another 9/11 attack on the US.

This is just vapid bullshit. 9/11 was guys with knives. They had very little specialized training and needed less. You can't spot that from the air with drones, and it didn't need fields of poppies to fund.

There's one simple reason the USA is in the middle east - oil. Making sure it keeps flowing.

> Yes, we can be sure that the Muslim clerics will get their people up on their hind legs shouting "Death to America". Sounds like a declaration of war to me for which some USAF guy in a container room in Nevada should push a button on a drone control and stop that stuff. But if all they do is shout, then we don't always have to push the button.

So does some war-hawk talking about how we should push a button and end the outrage that we created with yet another bomb.

Maybe we should trade, the militant cleric for you, as some sort of reverse prisoner-of-war deal, to help keep the peace.

> The US needs to quit being so darned simplistic, wise up, [...], use our drones, INTEL, etc., do the smart things,

Or, you know, you could try for a foreign policy that didn't involve holding a gun to everyone's head.

Especially since you got too big for anyone to fight, and started picking on smaller enemies with less resources - meaning that everything is going to turn into guerrilla strikes against civilians, on both sides.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by graycat on Monday May 27, 2013 @12:40PM (#5775271)
> You can't spot that from the air with drones

The INTEL is not limited to, or even primarily from, just drones. Heavily the INTEL will have to be 'human INTEL'. Drones that hover for many hours can also be part of INTEL, but mostly the drones would be for attacks on targets identified by INTEL mostly not from drones.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by wnight on Monday May 27, 2013 @09:37PM (#5777529)
No, I meant you can't spot small knives from the air so you have no way of really knowing who you're killing - unlike bombing a missile convoy or a tank, obvious weapons. Your INTEL, that from the ground, is often - maybe usually - wrong, and without a visible clear and present danger you shouldn't be killing people.

But way to go in responding to the tiniest part of the post and ignoring the rest.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by graycat on Monday May 27, 2013 @11:14PM (#5777817)
> No, I meant you can't spot small knives from the air so you have no way of really knowing who you're killing

No, you still know whom you are killing, because of the human INTEL and not because they are carrying knives.

Another point, on your side, is that once the Jihaders know that the US is watching with INTEL, etc., then they will be much more secretive and not have open air training camps and, thus, be more difficult to detect, target, etc. Then the US has three fall back positions: First, we are much harder to attack now than on 9/11. Second, the attacks we are now most concerned about are not just two wacko Jihaders in Boston but a nuke in a boat in Boston harbor. Third, generally our INTEL around the world is much better now than in 9/11 -- anyone wanting to slip a nuke into a boat in Boston harbor will have a much tougher time getting from start to finish for that project than in 9/11. From banking, finance, electronic communications, satellites, HUMINT, etc., the US has a much closer eye on Jihaders now than in 9/11.

> There's one simple reason the USA is in the middle east - oil. Making sure it keeps flowing.

Likely so. Some in Israel hope not. Actually, some in the Arab oil states should like the US 'police' activities in their area.

But oil is not why the US is in Afghanistan. W wasn't much on the Afghan effort, but Obama wanted to say that the country that attacked us was Afghanistan and not Iraq so wanted to claim that W was wrong going to Iraq. Once Obama was in office, he tried a 'surge' in Afghanistan that didn't much work and now is about just to pull out. To me, Obama was just playing US politics and has had no interest in either Iraq or Afghanistan.

> So does some war-hawk talking about how we should push a button and end the outrage that we created with yet another bomb.

> Maybe we should trade, the militant cleric for you, as some sort of reverse prisoner-of-war deal, to help keep the peace.

War is hell. I know that and don't like it.

But we are in a war in Afghanistan. Then, did I mention, war is hell? So, part of how we do that war is push buttons on the controls of drones. That's part of why war is hell. But, Afghanistan was the base of the 9/11 attack on the US that killed 3000 innocent US civilians. That was war and hell. So, to defend ourselves, we went into Afghanistan and eventually got Bin Laden. Then we tried to set up a modern government there to replace the Taliban that let Ben Laden set up a base from which he attacked us. To defeat the Taliban, we use HUMINT and INTEL, heavily where the Taliban leadership is hiding in the Pakistan tribal regions, to identify Taliban leadership. Then we track them with drones. When we have a clear shot at such a bad guy, a USAF guy in a box in Nevada pushes a button. It's hell. Sometimes women and children get killed, like they do in nearly all wars. Did I mention, war is hell? I don't like it. And I didn't like 9/11 either.

> Or, you know, you could try for a foreign policy that didn't involve holding a gun to everyone's head.

That's not nearly all there is to US foreign policy. I don't much like US foreign policy, tries to do too much, is too blunt sometimes, to gentle and even naive other times, and usually too simplistic. Still, a gun to the head is not nearly all of US foreign policy. In Afghanistan, we could have just leveled the place, all from the air, in weeks, the whole place, dogs, cats, rabbits, goats, sheep, men, women, and children. Easily. Instead, we tried hard to give them a constitution, a freely elected government, a freely elected parliament, roads, schools, hospitals, trained and equipped their police and military, tried to protect their villages, etc. But it didn't much take root. Essentially no one in Afghanistan was prepared to sign on and support the government we were trying to help them have. So the Taliban was able to run a powerful shadow government, use Mafia techniques to keep the villages 'in line', extract cash to pay for their war, etc. But our efforts were far from just holding a gun to heads.

> started picking on smaller enemies with less resources

My view is that the US has been too active around the world. But the US is not nearly responsible for the rise of radical Islam, and radical Islam is not aimed nearly at only the US. In particular, radical Islam against the US is not seriously from the US "picking on" anyone.

Really, radical Islam is based on a simple, old dynamic: Some people want more power. So, in heavily Islamic countries with a lot of oil money sloshing around, people who wanted more power, e.g., Bin Laden and various Islamic clerics, saw a way to pursue power: Use Islam to get some young people up on their hind legs and use oil money to pursue projects. Boom. 9/11.

There's a lot of pushing and shoving, heavily enabled by oil money: So, Saddam wanted to push against Iran. And Iran was eager to push back. So the US helped Saddam. Then Saddam wanted to push against Kuwait and then Saudi Arabia, and the US pushed back. Now Iran wants connect with Syria, influence Lebanon, and push against Israel. In Egypt, the Islamists didn't like the secular dictator and got rid of him, and now are making an even worse mess out of Egypt. Similarly in Libya. Similarly in Syria. And Iran .... So, there's lots of pushing and shoving, again, enabled by oil money. And it helps that the culture is so heavily dominated by Islam's 500 year old traditions that there is so little more modern culture. But no way is much of that pushing and shoving due to anything the US did or did wrong.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by wnight on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @11:37AM (#5780626)
> But, Afghanistan was the base of the 9/11 attack on the US that killed 3000 innocent US civilians.

No, it bloody was not. Many of those people hadn't even been in Afghanistan. The ones who were, and who "received training" had mostly received that in the context of fighting Russia. The myth of the 9/11 training camp in Afghanistan is entirely made up. Terrorist camps themselves are a myth. Militias train in the hills with weapons, terrorists don't execute those attacks and don't need/get that training.

Further, you've killed over 200 people, almost every one civilian, for every person killed in the 9/11 attacks. In retribution, against people who weren't involved.

> No, you still know whom you are killing, because of the human INTEL and not because they are carrying knives.

The same HUMINT you pick and choose to justify invading Iraq? The same HUMINT that says "bomb that wedding"?

Because your intel is notoriously bad, especially in that area of the world - even now, and there's such a conflict of interest at all levels.

No, it's just straight-up murder when you drone-bomb someone without on-screen visible reasons (driving a tank) because you have such a low standard of proof - it wouldn't qualify to get a warrant to search the person back home.

But even if your intel was perfect, your leaders ignore anything that doesn't let them proceed with the already-planned mobilization. Iraq wasn't a mistake, Iraq was one of the largest cases of mass murder on the planet - second only barely to monsters from our past. And it was planned before 9/11, and before the cooked-up WMD scare, etc.

> Really, radical Islam is based on a simple, old dynamic: Some people want more power.

No, really? Because that's only exactly like every other group on the planet.

> In Egypt, the Islamists didn't like the secular dictator [that we installed] and got rid of him

Funny that. And funny how you make a big deal about secular when it's the fact that he had people abducted for secrets trials and executions, and that the USA backed him, than his religious status, that bothered the Egyptians.

Oh, and that he was a dictator, and felt he had the right to rule for life.

But yeah, just radical Islamists...

> There's a lot of pushing and shoving, heavily enabled by oil money:

Yes. Texas oil money. And other.

> But no way is much of that pushing and shoving due to anything the US did or did wrong.

You're probably wrong, but it's a tellingly pathetic defense for a pathetic position regardless.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by guard-of-terra on Monday May 27, 2013 @08:15AM (#5774362)
There is this recurring rumour that USA helps to deliver heroin from Afghanistan (and whereever) to Europe via their military bases. Particularly in Albania.

I don't know where it is coming from, but little doubt that USA intervention in Afghanistan leads to an increase of Heroin production there which then gets smuggled out.

Taliban needs to wage war and guns don't buy themselves.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by ardit33 on Monday May 27, 2013 @12:27PM (#5775212)
If you believe that I have a bridge to sell to you.
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by sultezdukes on Monday May 27, 2013 @09:01AM (#5774492)
From the research I have done, the majority of Afghans want peace to the point where they would accept a Taliban strict rule of law over the continued war. Its confusing, but it just shows the war really needs to end.

And so would have the majority of Americans back in 2001, but they wouldn't give up Bin Laden, so they paid the price.

Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary by drumdance on Monday May 27, 2013 @11:28PM (#5777854)
And so did we.