News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: leaving a company in silicon valley.

Hey HN, i 'd appreciate some advice.

Right out of college, I was offered a software job at a certain silicon valley company. I was wowed by the salary, perks, and benefits so i eagerly accepted. I've been working here for under a year now, when I was approached by recruiters at another silicon valley company. I'm fairly content working where I currently am, and my coworkers are great people. But I've always wanted to work at the second company and I know they'll offer more compensation to boot.

The problem is, I don't want to leave the first company because I feel obligated to finish my current projects. But i wonder: Is there ever a good time to leave a company? I feel conflicted as this is the first fulltime job I've had out of college...

( 10 comments | 16 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: leaving a company in silicon valley. by reikonomusha on Sunday May 26, 2013 @10:27AM (#5771151)
I agree with what everyone here said, but I also must give a counter-point.

Being at a company for less than a year (or even less than two years) can ultimately cause you issues. When I thought I had a job secured, and was at it for half a year, I was "let go". Now, to my resume, I had to add "Company X — 0.5 years".

My track record thus far had been between 0.5 and 1.5 years at companies, either as a contractor or full-time employee. When it came time to interview at places, I actually had interviewers flat-out say "you are a risk to us" because I didn't keep a position at any company for 3 or more years, and their rationale is that I wouldn't hold a position with them much longer than anywhere else.

I know for at least one position, where I went through the grueling interview process and did well, I was rejected, solely based off of this fact.

So before you start hopping companies, keep in mind what it will look like on your resume and how a future employer might interpret it, especially if things don't happen to work out at the company you might get an offer from.

Lastly, I might note and you might already know this, that just because a recruiter contacts you doesn't mean a company is very keen to hire you from the get-go. They are looking for "talent", and thought you were worthy of a try. I've had both recruiters and VCs approach me as technical recruiters, and most of their efforts ended up being fruitless in actually landing some offers (95% of the time it was because I was just not a good fit for the position—my interests and experiences did not match up—and the other 5% was because I didn't meet some set of qualifications, such as a particular degree, prior experience, etc.).

Re:Ask HN: leaving a company in silicon valley. by nopassrecover on Sunday May 26, 2013 @10:58AM (#5771238)
Is this cultural to the US? I've never known it to be an issue here in Australia, and it's always quite a surprise to see someone with a longer than 2 year stint in the first 5-7 years of experience.
Re:Ask HN: leaving a company in silicon valley. by tptacek on Sunday May 26, 2013 @10:08AM (#5771100)
It's your current employer's job to retain you. It is not your job to be loyal to them.
Re:Ask HN: leaving a company in silicon valley. by BrentRitterbeck on Sunday May 26, 2013 @01:19PM (#5771679)
These words are so true. Employment is a mutually beneficial economic relationship. Employers want you to believe they hold all of the power; however, this is very far from reality in early stage companies.

Employers gotta pay to play. Sometimes pay is much more than cash dispersed twice a month.

Re:Ask HN: leaving a company in silicon valley. by nopassrecover on Sunday May 26, 2013 @07:58AM (#5770875)
I'd say it's unreasonable (though understandable) to feel any guilt/obligation beyond your contracted/legally required notice projects. Look at the other side - it would be considered unethical for an investor-backed company to keep staff on out of obligation rather than business sense.

As you're interested in working at the other company it probably makes sense to do so - otherwise you may end up resenting your current job for the "what could have been" opportunity. That your obligation to finish your projects is your main doubt reinforces this.

Make sure you have a firm offer from the new company first (you may want to hold off on accepting this offer until you've talked with your current company though), and then have the talk with your current company.

You obviously have no hard feelings towards your current company and enjoyed the opportunity working with them so it's quite likely you'll stay good contacts for down the track. Particularly so if you're able to work something reasonable out for a handover strategy that works for both you and the two companies.

Good luck!

Re:Ask HN: leaving a company in silicon valley. by josh_fyi on Sunday May 26, 2013 @07:56AM (#5770871)
It's totally OK to leave. There is no need to "finish" complete projects which can take years.

Just take care to finish off the current phase of each project -- you'll have to decide in context what that means -- and hand off to colleages.

Good relationships and open communications are the key.

Re:Ask HN: leaving a company in silicon valley. by makerops on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:23PM (#5788029)
I was recently in a similar situation, although not in SV; you are feeling a lot of unnecessary guilt(?), from a logical standpoint you probably realize it is not justified, but that does not mean you aren't experiencing the emotions. You just have to suck it up, and approach it like a chess game, plan your strategy, and ignore the emotional aspect, not to say you can actually flip a switch and not feel them, but do your best to just ignore them, and only let your brain do the work. To help with this, employers don't necessarily need you as much as you probably assume they do. They go through this a lot more than you, so it's not a big deal. If you are really afraid of burning bridges, give 4-6 weeks notice (that's what I did), and reaffirm, that you will help in any way you can (sitting in on interviews, helping the new hire train if they find one quickly enough, teaching current employees some stuff that will ease the transition irt what you were working on).
Re:Ask HN: leaving a company in silicon valley. by BrentRitterbeck on Sunday May 26, 2013 @12:05PM (#5771427)
It sounds like there are two things at play here: (1) You really want to work at this new offer, and (2) the new offer would net you more money.

With respect to (1), your work is going to be the best when you enjoy what you do. You state that you are content where you are now. Does your current job get you out of bed in the morning? Do you wake up wanting to go to work? Would the second job get you out of bed in the morning? Work on the thing you are most passionate about.

With respect to (2), employment is a two-way street. You have every right to cut off your employer as your employer has the right to cut off you. I've been through two rounds of cutbacks. I got hit once. I don't believe in company loyalty at all. You have to think of your career as a business. If all else is equal (in this case it might not be), and the pay is better, you should go for the higher pay. Don't fall into the trap of letting your employer "own" you.

Re:Ask HN: leaving a company in silicon valley. by furqanrydhan on Sunday May 26, 2013 @06:12PM (#5772620)
Honestly I'd leave the moment I feel like I'm wasting my time. If you're not learning anything or there's no real room for growth (learning potential), then i'd leave. At this stage where you are it's more important to learn as much as possible from every job situation than pure salary. The compensation being higher is an added benefit but I would definitely focus on a job that challenges you (both your skills and your person).
Re:Ask HN: leaving a company in silicon valley. by bsaul on Sunday May 26, 2013 @11:35AM (#5771339)
Do you feel like you could talk about that to your current employer ? "I wan't to leave, so let's plan something to make it painless for both of us" It's better than just tell them "i'm leaving in two weeks, that was great", and you still have the option to do it that way if things go wrong with the first way.

Note : i've only worked in the valley for a few months and it was a long time ago, so take my advice with caution.