Re:The cult of design dictatorship (2012)
by joe_the_user on Saturday May 25, 2013 @02:47PM
(#5768302)
I would argue that if the designer is doing their job properly and working with and for users, then they will be usually right, and if you don't like it, you're wrong
Uh this is working really well...
Let's see, Unity, Gnome 3, Windows 8... there is a pattern where static design has prevailed over the coherent, overall functional design of products. This is especially painful in the desktop PC market because people use them to do thing, even ordinary people have a use for a keyboard OMG.
The thing about overall functional design is that here you might talk to the engineers a bit. You might windup with a slightly less slick product but one that does what the users want it to - assuming you have users who to do more.
Uh this is working really well...
Let's see, Unity, Gnome 3, Windows 8... there is a pattern where static design has prevailed over the coherent, overall functional design of products. This is especially painful in the desktop PC market because people use them to do thing, even ordinary people have a use for a keyboard OMG.
The thing about overall functional design is that here you might talk to the engineers a bit. You might windup with a slightly less slick product but one that does what the users want it to - assuming you have users who to do more.