News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The cult of design dictatorship (2012) by georgespencer on Saturday May 25, 2013 @10:54AM (#5767424)
So wide of the mark that I almost feel faint. Selected highlights:

> This cult is insidious. Its two main tenant are: 1. The designer is always right. 2. If you don’t like what the designer is doing, you’re wrong, and you should go somewhere else. Doesn’t sound very friendly, does it?

1. Couple of fallacies here: you've set up a scenario in which your conclusion is supported (gosh, that doesn't sound friendly! This guy's a genius!), but it's also ignoratio elenchi: it doesn't fucking matter whether it's friendly or not, because who gives a shit whether the philosophy by which you design a product is friendly or not? It's like asking whether the philosophy is crunchy or gooey.

2. I would argue that if the designer is doing their job properly and working with and for users, then they will be usually right, and if you don't like it, you're wrong, and you should go somewhere else (because you're probably a neckbearded engineer trying to design something with zero user empathy).

> Steve Jobs made a zillion bucks cramming his design decisions down peoples’ throats.

1. In the same way as any designer, living or dead, who has shipped something to consumers, was "cramming [their] design decisions down peoples' throats."

2. In addition to the hugely biased language used, it's a gross oversimplification of design at Apple. A good example of Steve Jobs designing something is the iDVD anecdote. The iDVD team spend weeks working on a user interface that they think works. Jobs comes into the meeting, stops them halfway through, ignores their complicated workflows, and draws a simple rectangle which has a single "BURN" button on it. His great skill wasn't design, but editing and empathy.

> and now one of its founders spends his days custom-building and racing F1 cars.

Just another casual misrepresentation. DHH has not retired and is still working hard at 37signals.

> They did all this by being design dictators.

Yes. Forget the brilliant engineering, marketing, thought leadership, branding, etc. It was this cult thing you've conjured out of nowhere.

> Steve Jobs had a vision, and if you didn’t like his vision, you could go home.

Yes. But a vision is nothing to do with design. Example: Steve Jobs had the vision for MobileMe/iCloud. The vision was a cloud-based software product that allowed you to synchronise your devices and keep data across all of them. The design is terrible. Design being architecture and the implementation. Vision != design.

And what do you mean by "go home"? Isn't the same true of any product? If you don't like Android you can "go home". If you don't like Ferrari you can "go home". With "go home" you're implying that the consumer loses out. In reality because there IS ONLY ONE WAY A PRODUCT CAN POSSIBLY WORK, you're criticising them for not disrupting the space time continuum in order to offer two different products so you can not like Steve Jobs' vision and still like Steve Jobs' vision. Fuck me.

> 37 Signals made its products like it wanted to, and if you didn’t like it, you could suck it.

WHAT THE FUCK ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT? I'm giving up on the rest.

Re:The cult of design dictatorship (2012) by acabal on Saturday May 25, 2013 @11:19AM (#5767494)
> The iDVD team spend weeks working on a user interface that they think works. Jobs comes into the meeting, stops them halfway through, ignores their complicated workflows, and draws a simple rectangle which has a single "BURN" button on it. His great skill wasn't design, but editing and empathy.

That's not editing, that's literally throwing everything away and forcing his vision on them. Precisely what I'm talking about. And "empathy" is not a word I'd use to describe Steve Jobs, who by all accounts was a terrible jerk.

> Design being architecture and the implementation. Vision != design.

Maybe a better title for this post would have been, "The cult of product leader dictatorship." When I wrote design, I didn't mean industrial design or UI design, but product design and leadership. My fault for being unclear.

> WHAT THE FUCK ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT?

On reading this post again 6 months after I wrote it, those are indeed strong words that don't really reflect 37 Signal's attitude. My words, not theirs.

Re:The cult of design dictatorship (2012) by georgespencer on Saturday May 25, 2013 @12:16PM (#5767657)
> That's not editing, that's literally throwing everything away

Throwing stuff away is editing. Sigh.

> and forcing his vision on them. Precisely what I'm talking about.

1. His vision was "a simple experience for the user". iDVD didn't end up with a simple rectangle and a single button marked "Burn". He refocused his teams around simplicity and ease of use.

2. I note that you've avoided responding to the other parts of my response in which I inquire as to whether you believe all designers in history are "forcing" their "vision" on others.

> And "empathy" is not a word I'd use to describe Steve Jobs, who by all accounts was a terrible jerk.

Product design is all about empathy with users. Steve Jobs was blessed with that in abundance. If you attribute Apple's success to his vision and design, then you have to acknowledge that users love their hardware and software. Jobs was great at cutting through bullshit and getting himself, his team, his engineers and designers -- who are all highly technical 'power users' -- to be humble and remove themselves from the equation and build something for mass consumption.

Re:The cult of design dictatorship (2012) by joe_the_user on Saturday May 25, 2013 @02:47PM (#5768302)
I would argue that if the designer is doing their job properly and working with and for users, then they will be usually right, and if you don't like it, you're wrong

Uh this is working really well...

Let's see, Unity, Gnome 3, Windows 8... there is a pattern where static design has prevailed over the coherent, overall functional design of products. This is especially painful in the desktop PC market because people use them to do thing, even ordinary people have a use for a keyboard OMG.

The thing about overall functional design is that here you might talk to the engineers a bit. You might windup with a slightly less slick product but one that does what the users want it to - assuming you have users who to do more.

Re:The cult of design dictatorship (2012) by keithpeter on Saturday May 25, 2013 @03:49PM (#5768588)
"I would argue that if the designer is doing their job properly and working with and for users, then they will be usually right, and if you don't like it, you're wrong, and you should go somewhere else..."

Canonical claim that they user test the Unity interface. The test tasks appear to be geared to 'end users', although there is a nod to 'power users'[1]. This focus on testing and iteration would seem to be at variance with the idea of a 'design dictator'. Does anyone have hard evidence of user testing of the Gnome 3 desktop?

[1] http://design.canonical.com/topic/user-experience/ [list of blog posts showing range of activity]

Re:The cult of design dictatorship (2012) by coldtea on Saturday May 25, 2013 @03:52PM (#5768594)
So wide of the mark that I almost feel faint. Selected highlights: > This cult is insidious. Its two main tenant are: 1. The designer is always right. 2. If you don’t like what the designer is doing, you’re wrong, and you should go somewhere else. Doesn’t sound very friendly, does it? >1. Couple of fallacies here: you've set up a scenario in which your conclusion is supported (gosh, that doesn't sound friendly! This guy's a genius!), but it's also ignoratio elenchi: it doesn't fucking matter whether it's friendly or not, because who gives a shit whether the philosophy by which you design a product is friendly or not? It's like asking whether the philosophy is crunchy or gooey.

So wide off the mark, that you hit a guy on a wheelchair 2 blocks away.

It DOES fucking matter if "the philosophy by which you design a product is friendly or not" when you're trying to build that product in a community (as is the case with Gnome 3). He specifically mentions Gnome 3 as his example, and in the dynamics of Open Source communities friendly DOES matter. A lot.

Perhaps you could spend "fainting" (sic) and more time in reading and understanding where TFA comes from.

>2. I would argue that if the designer is doing their job properly and working with and for users, then they will be usually right, and if you don't like it, you're wrong, and you should go somewhere else (because you're probably a neckbearded engineer trying to design something with zero user empathy).

And I'd argue that he describes cases where the designers are NOT doing their job properly.

It's not like most designers working in web/software startups are trained professionals, profficient in the history of design, psychological and cognitive issues, HCI principles and user testing methodologies. A lot are just glorified graphic designers, if that. Especially the ones TFA article describes, and which we've all met, are the "I know better" BS types.

Also your whole argument is based on the premise of: "if the designer is doing their job properly and working with and for users". Well, TFA describes a case where the users are not happy with the designers work -- a case where a project (namely Gnome 3) lost momentum and users.

>Just another casual misrepresentation. DHH has not retired and is still working hard at 37signals.

Just another pedantic correction of a comment made in jest that was not supposed to be taken literally. Not to mention he doesn't say he's retired at all.

>>37 Signals made its products like it wanted to, and if you didn’t like it, you could suck it. >WHAT THE FUCK ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT? I'm giving up on the rest.

He talks of the same "FUCK" (sic) that 37 Signals themselves admit (and are proud of). That they make opinionated products, and that if somebody isn't pleased with them, so be it.

Re:The cult of design dictatorship (2012) by georgespencer on Saturday May 25, 2013 @04:37PM (#5768733)
> It DOES fucking matter if "the philosophy by which you design a product is friendly or not" when you're trying to build that product in a community (as is the case with Gnome 3). He specifically mentions Gnome 3 as his example, and in the dynamics of Open Source communities friendly DOES matter. A lot.

Ah the whine of the open source developer who wonders why the average joe finds OSS unusable and impregnable. It doesn't matter if there's a great product at the end of it. If the product is suboptimal then we can all moan about the reasons why.

Also worth pointing out that you're misrepresenting his article. He says:

> It’s a problem that doesn’t just apply to Gnome 3—though Gnome 3 certainly suffers from it. It’s the problem of the Cult of Design Dictatorship.

So either you don't understand his article, or he's applying a generalisation drawn from Gnome3 and then deliberately applying it to the wider world. Which?

> Perhaps you could spend "fainting" (sic)

I'm obliged to point out, with a sense of delicious irony, that you are using sic incorrectly ;)

> and more time in reading and understanding where TFA comes from.

I read it and understood it. It's horseshit.

> It's not like most designers working in web/software startups are trained professionals,

What? Yes, they are.

> profficient in the history of design, psychological and cognitive issues, HCI principles and user testing methodologies. A lot are just glorified graphic designers, if that.

A lot, or most?

> Especially the ones TFA article describes, and which we've all met, are the "I know better" BS types.

I guess there's an inherent risk with drawing _massive, sweeping generalisations_ from "I've met some of these".

> Also your whole argument is based on the premise of: "if the designer is doing their job properly and working with and for users".

Actually my argument is better summarised as:

1. If a designer is doing their job properly, then the characteristics described in the original article all hold true, but the outcome is successful so nobody cares. 2. The point laboured in the article is, essentially, that design is not a democracy and you should "go home" if you don't like a product. I counter that this is a platitude: it could be true of any product ever made.

> Just another pedantic correction of a comment made in jest that was not supposed to be taken literally. Not to mention he doesn't say he's retired at all.

"spends his days". It's an unfair characterisation made in support of a tawdry argument which boils down to a bunch of plattitudes

> He talks of the same "FUCK" (sic) that 37 Signals themselves admit (and are proud of). That they make opinionated products, and that if somebody isn't pleased with them, so be it.

My point was: But so what? Every single piece of software is made with opinion behind it. If you don't like it you can choose another piece of software. That's true of everything from bottled water to delivery pizza. Who gives a shit? It's not worth pointing out.

Re:The cult of design dictatorship (2012) by coldtea on Sunday May 26, 2013 @01:41PM (#5771768)
>Ah the whine of the open source developer who wonders why the average joe finds OSS unusable and impregnable.

No, the whine of the open source developer who knows why the average joe finds the OSS project he talks about unusable and impregnable: the BS decisions of "designer dictators" that alienate the users.

>So either you don't understand his article, or he's applying a generalisation drawn from Gnome3 and then deliberately applying it to the wider world. Which?

Or, you don't understand the obvious: that things that hold for Gnome 3 can also hold for a wider world -- and that some of them (like a friendly decision process) can be especially important for OSS projects.

Reading comprehension problems?

> Perhaps you could spend "fainting" (sic) >I'm obliged to point out, with a sense of delicious irony, that you are using sic incorrectly ;)

Wrong again. I only forgot the words "less time" between spend and fainting. As for "sic" I used it as it is meant to be used. It has no hard dependency on the tense or form of the word used -- ("feel faint" vs "fainting"). It just means that those were your words (even if adjusted to fit the quotation's syntax).

>>It's not like most designers working in web/software startups are trained professionals, >What? Yes, they are.

Oh, I'm afraid they are not. You can count the number of them that have a university degree in HCI in one hand.

>I guess there's an inherent risk with drawing _massive, sweeping generalisations_ from "I've met some of these"

Yes, it's called deductive reasoning. You should try it. It's not like there's an infinite number of startups either -- so it can also be exhaustive or near exhaustive sampling.

>1. If a designer is doing their job properly, then the characteristics described in the original article all hold true, but the outcome is successful so nobody cares. 2. The point laboured in the article is, essentially, that design is not a democracy and you should "go home" if you don't like a product. I counter that this is a platitude: it could be true of any product ever made.

OK, so your argument is wrong. (1) is a statistical noise (a few highly talented designer arseholes) so for all practical cases the bad end result the article laments holds true.

>My point was: But so what? Every single piece of software is made with opinion behind it.

Which is a useless platitude in itself. The important thing is the degree of opinion in each software. Others are "taking or leave it and fuck you", and others listen to their team/community/users.

>That's true of everything from bottled water to delivery pizza.

Not really. There are "designer" pizza places that only sell you a specific kind and fuck off if you don't like it. And there are places that let you design your own pizza, sandwich, coffee, whatever. And places in between.