News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The cult of design dictatorship (2012) by coldtea on Saturday May 25, 2013 @10:04AM (#5767302)
>The problem is not the cult of design dictatorship, the problem is bad design and bad designers

Which is precisely what the "cult of design dictatorship" describes.

Your correction amounts to saying "the problem is not crime, it's criminals" -- it's obvious and it's already conveyed in the original phrasing.

>That doesn't mean that being a designer or a dictator is a bad thing inherently

There's two ways to see this.

The pedantic ("is it true 100% percent and for all persons?") which I find useless, and the pragmatic ("is it true for most people that try to play Jobs/37 Signals that they are not fit for the role?").

The second, I believe holds. And that's why the idea of "being a dictator designer" is an inherently bad thing. Because it gives the majority of people the wrong idea about what they should do.

I don't care if the same thing works for a tiny minority. We should not perpetuate memes that only work for a tiny minority.

If that minority has the talent and stubbornness of Jobs/DHH, they will do it by themselves anyway.

The memes ("be a dictator and force your opinion to your team/users") only serve the mediocre, those that do harm.

Re:The cult of design dictatorship (2012) by knowtheory on Saturday May 25, 2013 @10:44AM (#5767403)
> Your correction amounts to saying "the problem is not crime, it's criminals" -- it's obvious and it's already conveyed in the original phrasing.

No, that is distinctly not what I am saying. My assertion is that centralized authority is important, and perhaps even necessary in creative endeavors.

Furthermore complaints about "bad" designers tend to actually amount to "i disagree with your design vision/priorities/choices, therefore you are bad". But disagreeing with someone's design choices does not mean that they are being a bad project leader.

Edit: having read over my original post, it's a bit muddled so i can see where you're coming from. If you read some of the other sibling posts, you'll get a clearer sense of what i mean.

Re:The cult of design dictatorship (2012) by coldtea on Saturday May 25, 2013 @03:32PM (#5768529)
>No, that is distinctly not what I am saying. My assertion is that centralized authority is important, and perhaps even necessary in creative endeavors.

To that, I agree.

I don't have a problem with centralize authority (one guy being in charge etc, like Linus or Guido or Jobs).

I have a problem when the person being in charge does it with some hazy "You'll listen to me because because I know good design" thing -- Jobs, DHH etc proved their worth in practice, they didn't merely claim they have the knowledge.

Whereas today you see people convinced they are the next Jobs/DHH that are just shallow imitators with no talent, and they try to force this at their teams / companies / communities.