No, that is distinctly not what I am saying. My assertion is that centralized authority is important, and perhaps even necessary in creative endeavors.
Furthermore complaints about "bad" designers tend to actually amount to "i disagree with your design vision/priorities/choices, therefore you are bad". But disagreeing with someone's design choices does not mean that they are being a bad project leader.
Edit: having read over my original post, it's a bit muddled so i can see where you're coming from. If you read some of the other sibling posts, you'll get a clearer sense of what i mean.
To that, I agree.
I don't have a problem with centralize authority (one guy being in charge etc, like Linus or Guido or Jobs).
I have a problem when the person being in charge does it with some hazy "You'll listen to me because because I know good design" thing -- Jobs, DHH etc proved their worth in practice, they didn't merely claim they have the knowledge.
Whereas today you see people convinced they are the next Jobs/DHH that are just shallow imitators with no talent, and they try to force this at their teams / companies / communities.
Which is precisely what the "cult of design dictatorship" describes.
Your correction amounts to saying "the problem is not crime, it's criminals" -- it's obvious and it's already conveyed in the original phrasing.
>That doesn't mean that being a designer or a dictator is a bad thing inherently
There's two ways to see this.
The pedantic ("is it true 100% percent and for all persons?") which I find useless, and the pragmatic ("is it true for most people that try to play Jobs/37 Signals that they are not fit for the role?").
The second, I believe holds. And that's why the idea of "being a dictator designer" is an inherently bad thing. Because it gives the majority of people the wrong idea about what they should do.
I don't care if the same thing works for a tiny minority. We should not perpetuate memes that only work for a tiny minority.
If that minority has the talent and stubbornness of Jobs/DHH, they will do it by themselves anyway.
The memes ("be a dictator and force your opinion to your team/users") only serve the mediocre, those that do harm.