Re:Wisp: a homoiconic JS dialect with Clojure syntax, s-expr...
by asynchrony on Friday May 24, 2013 @03:39AM
(#5761648)
Javascript strings are immutable and literals are almost certainly preallocated and stored in a table of constants.
Why should using a string keys cause heap allocations?
Re:Wisp: a homoiconic JS dialect with Clojure syntax, s-expr...
by arohner on Saturday May 25, 2013 @03:45PM
(#5768567)
If you have a VM where strings are immutable and interned, you're right. Java doesn't guarantee that strings are interned (though you can ask the VM to intern it), so Clojure treats them differently.
Also, Java declared java.lang.String as final, so Strings can't be extended to implement clojure interfaces to get nice behavior, like IFn and IKeywordLookup.
That's basically what keywords do -- they are human-readable and compile down (prob. using some hash) into some integer, and the integer is stored globally only once. The biggest savings in memory comes when using maps, and that's how & why keywords get their name.