News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Government Wants A Backdoor Into Your Online Communic... by wmf on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:03AM (#5755289)
Every Web 2.0 service has been "backdoored" (i.e. storing data in the clear on the servers) all along and very few people have complained. Perhaps inventing a scary term for an existing practice will catalyze some kind of change, but I doubt it.
Re:The Government Wants A Backdoor Into Your Online Communic... by schoen on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:15AM (#5755469)
"Backdoor" is the term that we used in the 1990s in connection with proposed anti-encryption measures, and particularly systems like Clipper where encryption was present but had been modified to allow government access ("key escrow" and "key recovery"). In this prototypical case, a potentially otherwise secure design was modified specifically to allow the government to break it. There are still engineering efforts today to do analogous things, including work at ETSI with regard to GSM voice encryption.

As a coauthor of the original post, I think the term is still reasonable and useful.

I agree that the applicability of "backdoor" to the cases you mention is less clear, and sometimes absent. Often, the main reasons that users don't get to control their own crypto keys may have to do with a service provider's business model and engineering decisions. If facilitating surveillance wasn't one of the main design goals, I can see where "backdoor" feels much less appropriate. (I think I'd argue that it's still an appropriate term if the architectural decisions about encryption are directly influenced by pressure from the government. Legislation to ban certain designs for communications systems should put us squarely in that category.)

I'd also like to find ways to encourage users to value end-to-end encryption, but I don't think that was meant to be the point of using the term "backdoor". We are actually talking about legislation here, supposedly meant to change how services are engineered, likely including services and software that are already in use.