News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Poll HN: IDE (eclipse) or plain editor (vim, emacs) ?

I recently got into a discussion about whether using an IDE really speeds up development time. If you were confronted with a large project and barring organizational constraints, do you believe using an IDE (Visual Studio, Eclipse) will make you significantly more productive than a good editor (vim, emacs) ? I separated the options out to be language specific, so select your language of expertise.
( 9 comments | 3 points | on HN )

Poll

Java - IDEs rock! Eclipse forever... 8 votes
Java - Editors are the best! Long Live vim! 7 votes
C++ - IDEs are my best friend! 1 vote
C++ - Editors do everything I need, forget your IDE! 8 votes
C - IDEs ! insert clever comment... 2 votes
C - editors ! but IDEs may make my code readable? 7 votes
Ruby - IDEs ! I am really out of jokes... 2 votes
Rudy - editors ! 5 votes
Re:Poll HN: IDE (eclipse) or plain editor (vim, emacs) ? by lastkarrde on Wednesday April 22, 2009 @08:40PM (#574870)
Netbeans 6.5 for large PHP projects, vim for quick fixes and Gedit + plugins for small/medium projects.
Re:Poll HN: IDE (eclipse) or plain editor (vim, emacs) ? by hs on Wednesday April 22, 2009 @07:54PM (#574809)
i don't use those languages and i use vim

i still believe touch typing (10 fingers + cartoon characters) is often taken for granted

how many of your bugs stem from typo?

Re:Poll HN: IDE (eclipse) or plain editor (vim, emacs) ? by asimjalis on Wednesday April 22, 2009 @07:18PM (#574750)
I'm also curious about Python, Objective C and C#.
Re:Poll HN: IDE (eclipse) or plain editor (vim, emacs) ? by Zev on Wednesday April 22, 2009 @09:47PM (#574925)
I generally use Xcode + IB if I'm doing anything complex with ObjC. Though, If I'm just doing a one-off command line app with ObjC alone for whatever reason or need to make a quick edit to a file, I'll use TextMate instead.
Re:Poll HN: IDE (eclipse) or plain editor (vim, emacs) ? by doubleyooexwhy on Wednesday April 22, 2009 @07:27PM (#574768)
No. All I need for C is my emacs, compiler, and terminal, and I'm good to go.
Re:Poll HN: IDE (eclipse) or plain editor (vim, emacs) ? by SwellJoe on Wednesday April 22, 2009 @08:32PM (#574860)
I dunno who Rudy is, but I use an editor (vim) for all languages.
Re:Poll HN: IDE (eclipse) or plain editor (vim, emacs) ? by keefe on Wednesday April 22, 2009 @09:38PM (#574917)
damnit...
Re:Poll HN: IDE (eclipse) or plain editor (vim, emacs) ? by kqr2 on Wednesday April 22, 2009 @07:51PM (#574802)
Also, curious about people who do Flex development.
Re:Poll HN: IDE (eclipse) or plain editor (vim, emacs) ? by keefe on Wednesday April 22, 2009 @09:39PM (#574918)
I do flex development as well and I think flexbuilder is the only real choice