News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by ajross on Thursday May 16, 2013 @11:34AM (#5719147)
Arrgh. Title is total link bait. There is no news about SMTP here. The linked blog post is whining about XMPP, which is not being disabled. Apparently the author is a user of "XMPP Federation" (the ability to link XMPP servers together a-la IRC), which is also not being disabled. But apparently it might be someday, as the new Hangouts stuff won't support it.

So how did we get form "can't talk to your Hangout via an XMPP client" to "Google will disable SMTP"? Really folks, this site used to be better about this stuff...

Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by Dylan16807 on Thursday May 16, 2013 @12:01PM (#5719303)
1. Looking at the other threads I can't quite get a straight answer on XMPP, but it seems to be entirely disabled for the "new communications product called Hangouts" (new??), but this is not just about federation.

2. claudius is very clearly explaining why google SHOULD disable SMTP. Nobody has seriously suggested they would; you might need to recalibrate your satire detector. Also claudius gave several reasons that apply equally to XMPP and SMTP to be extra helpful. :)

Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by andrewguenther on Thursday May 16, 2013 @12:31PM (#5719482)
It is not available in Hangouts, but it will continue to be supported "for the foreseeable future" in GTalk.
Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by tankenmate on Thursday May 16, 2013 @02:08PM (#5720028)
Except that GTalk is now being deprecated on Android and being replaced with the new version of Hangouts...
Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by fdr_cs on Thursday May 16, 2013 @01:04PM (#5719654)
Just like reader, right ?
Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by philwelch on Thursday May 16, 2013 @12:32PM (#5719492)
Between Google Reader and XMPP federation, it's clear that Google is turning against open standards.
Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by ajross on Thursday May 16, 2013 @03:26PM (#5720584)
Given that Google was, essentially, the only meaningful provider of either a public federated XMPP service or a RSS feed reader[1], that seems like a pretty weak argument. If there's no community, was it ever really open?

[1] Calling Google's 100% proprietary (albeit publicly documented) reader protocol an "open standard" is a bit of a stretch, FWIW. Google certainly isn't refusing to support RSS on its blog offerings.

Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by wpietri on Thursday May 16, 2013 @04:28PM (#5720950)
Google Reader killed the RSS reader market by offering a solid product for free. You can't use the lack of other options as proof of anything except the depth of Google's pockets.
Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by ajross on Thursday May 16, 2013 @05:10PM (#5721168)
What does "killing the RSS reader market" (a point with which I agree, by the way) have to do with "turning against open standards"?

If anything, your logic would argue that the harm to open standards happened when Reader was introduced, not when it was killed, no?

Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by wpietri on Thursday May 16, 2013 @07:26PM (#5721867)
I'm not the original poster, so I can't say what he might mean by that.

But in my view, Reader's arc is a sign of their growing indifference to open standards and a love of walled gardens. Well, their walled garden.

My impression is that Reader was launched back in the days when they were just doing things for the fun of it. If a 20% time project does well, then you push it out. And then they cared about open standards, which is why you can OPML-export your reader subscriptions.

But even at the time they didn't think much about crushing the nascent RSS-reader market. The programmers wanted to build things, so they did. And they liked them to be open, so that's how they ended up.

In the last few years, though, they've shifted. Google Plus was a sign that the power shifted from the nerds to the suits. The suits see what Facebook has and want the same. In that period, they just neglected Reader to death. I doubt it was intentional, but they it suited their walled garden urges just fine.

Now they've killed it, because it doesn't even do that anymore. As many people have noted, RSS has lost a lot of ground to proprietary sharing. Will it make it back? Would it have lost it anyhow? Hard to say. But a big part of why it's hard to say is Google's dominance.

So trying to answer your last question as framed, I guess I'd say that the harm to open standards happened at launch and up until when they killed it. The announcement kicked off a bunch of innovation and interest in newsreaders, and I'm looking forward to seeing how that plays out.

Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by philwelch on Thursday May 16, 2013 @04:35PM (#5720982)
There are lots of RSS desktop clients. It's unfortunate that web apps are appearing more vulnerable to Google's monopolistic practices than desktop apps were to Microsoft's.
Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by loup-vaillant on Thursday May 16, 2013 @08:08PM (#5722022)
Microsoft's products cost money (minus piracy), and fought Free Software, which is also Gratis most of the time.

Google is already Gratis (the ads don't count as a price in most people's minds).

Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by philwelch on Friday May 17, 2013 @03:49AM (#5723174)
I was referring more to IE, which was bundled with the OS to circumvent Netscape's business model.
Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by loup-vaillant on Friday May 17, 2013 @04:38AM (#5723278)
Ah. Maybe it was because IE sucked for a long time, compared to Firefox?
Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by philwelch on Friday May 17, 2013 @04:44AM (#5723293)
Gmail sucks too now (to give an example) but it's much harder to provide a viable alternative if you're an open source project or a startup. There will never be a Firefox of web mail, much less a Firefox of search engines.
Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by duaneb on Thursday May 16, 2013 @12:31PM (#5719481)
I don't think they would kill SMTP, but I also didn't think they would kill CalDav.
Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by fdr_cs on Thursday May 16, 2013 @01:05PM (#5719660)
I'm starting to think that they don't kill it, just because they can't . But if they had the chance ... :/
Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by duaneb on Thursday May 16, 2013 @01:21PM (#5719730)
Well TBH I hate SMTP and would love to see it replaced.... however, the features I want (native user-to-user encryption preventing Google from reading my mail) Google would not want to add, and unless Google makes it an open standard it's a waste of time.
Re:What's next Google? Dropping SMTP support? by saraid216 on Thursday May 16, 2013 @02:30PM (#5720203)
> So how did we get form "can't talk to your Hangout via an XMPP client" to "Google will disable SMTP"? Really folks, this site used to be better about this stuff...

Religion is inevitable. http://www.shirky.com/writings/group_enemy.html