News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Canadian anti-piracy outfit pirates photos for its website by dspillett on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @10:45AM (#5712311)
> What are the anti-piracy people supposed to do?

In this specific circumstance: make exactly the same amends they would expect anyone else to make if they had found someone else inadvertently distributing unlicensed media, which would probably at least be:

* Immediate removal of the content until such time license to use it is arranged

* Payment in full at the author's chosen rate for licensing the content for the period they were using it

* Perhaps including a significant multiplier if the content creators chose to license per user not per server/service

* Definitely including opportunity costs (such as the interest the content creators could have earned had that money been in their accounts from the point it should have been, or interest they have paid out because the money wasn't)

* Willingly open their doors (or not moan when a law enforcer kicks their doors open) for a third party auditor to verify the state of other media they are using

If they are unable to pay immediately, a payment plan (with appropriate interest arrangement, increasing the debt by at least enough to recompense the creators for the continued inconvenience of not having the money and the continued risk of the debt never being paid if the group folds) should be arranged.

> I sympathize if they had nothing to do this and were let down by designers / rogue image reseller.

They would not accept the 3rd party responsibility argument if they were going after someone, so they should not be able to use it either. They should pay any costs directly. If they wish to hold one of their suppliers responsible then they can take separate action to be reimbursed for those funds.

Our sympathy should extend just as far as their's would, which is basically the "setting up a repayment plan instead of demanding all the money this instant or sending them to do prison time" thing.

That feels fair to me. If the content creators in question want to be more generous in their interpretation of the situation then that would be fine too of course, as long as the group doesn't expect them to be more generous.

Re:Canadian anti-piracy outfit pirates photos for its website by diminoten on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @11:06AM (#5712464)
If you disagree with what this anti-piracy group is doing, how is it fair to apply the standards they support? Isn't it necessarily, then, unfair to apply their standards to anyone, if you disagree with those standards?

It seems like you'd be agreeing with them if you asked them to apply their own standards to themselves. You either think they're right or they're wrong, and if you think they're wrong, some poetic justice shouldn't be enough to break your own moral code. That seems more indefensible than holding an incorrect set of views - to attempt to knowingly apply views you believe are wrong to someone because it satisfies a primal urge for vengeance.

Re:Canadian anti-piracy outfit pirates photos for its website by yew on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @12:35PM (#5713108)
If you disagree with what this anti-piracy group is doing, how is it fair to apply the standards they support?

I prefer to ask you, how isn't it fair? You are free to believe that 'You either think they're right or they're wrong'. I am equally free to believe that things are more complicated.

In this case I'll go by my own standard (which I apply not only here and now but whenever I have cause to consider such things in my interactions with others) - that of pragmatically holding others to their own principles even when I disagree with them.

If this group embarks on a journey of introspection and decides to profess a different set of principles, I'll gladly alter my opinion to suite. Until then they'll simply have to live with me being disappointed in them on the Internet. Or something.

Re:Canadian anti-piracy outfit pirates photos for its website by Natsu on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @11:30AM (#5712616)
He's pointing out that they're not adhering to their own moral code, rather than trying to hold them to his. That said, they might be able to assert an innocent infringement defense:

http://itlaw.wikia.com/wiki/Innocent_infringement

Standard disclaimers about getting a lawyer if you need legal advice apply, as always.

Re:Canadian anti-piracy outfit pirates photos for its website by diminoten on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @11:59AM (#5712832)
I'm saying they should be applauded for not adhering to their own moral code by those who disagree with said code.
Re:Canadian anti-piracy outfit pirates photos for its website by dspillett on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @12:10PM (#5712920)
Not if they then continue to apply that code to other people after not adhering to it themselves. Experience suggests that this is most likely what they will do.

If this is taken as a voyage of personal discovery and they change their ways, then we can applaud their critical thinking ans self inspection. Otherwise we can justifiably cry hypercrit (for all the difference it will make...).

Re:Canadian anti-piracy outfit pirates photos for its website by dspillett on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @12:43PM (#5713149)
(replying to my own comment instead of diminoten's reply as HN seems to have a nesting limit)

> Either their moral code is something you agree with, or it's something you don't. Who they apply it to is completely irrelevant.

I didn't say they had to apply their own code to themselves to not be completely hypercrits - the other option (as I have already explicitly stated) is to modify their practises to account for their new found enlightenment.

Re:Canadian anti-piracy outfit pirates photos for its website by diminoten on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @02:17PM (#5713752)
There is nothing meaningful in calling a person hypocritical. It has literally no impact on the validity of their claims.
Re:Canadian anti-piracy outfit pirates photos for its website by dspillett on Thursday May 16, 2013 @05:33AM (#5717654)
Their current claims, no. But it calls into question the validity of their previous actions which they are now contradicting.

I'm not commenting on which of the two situations is right (perhaps neither is), if railing against the "one rule for you, one rule for us" thing.

Re:Canadian anti-piracy outfit pirates photos for its website by diminoten on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @12:32PM (#5713096)
Either their moral code is something you agree with, or it's something you don't. Who they apply it to is completely irrelevant.

Furthermore, you can "cry" whatever you like. Personally, I find calling someone hypocritical to be utterly banal and entirely pointless. It means nothing for their argument. Man is flawed independent of his convictions.

Re:Canadian anti-piracy outfit pirates photos for its website by Natsu on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @11:45PM (#5716785)
> Either their moral code is something you agree with, or it's something you don't. Who they apply it to is completely irrelevant.

I do not agree. Showing that they hold themselves to a double standard undermines their credibility when they're trying to claim the moral high ground on an issue like this.

If, however, they own up and admit that they screwed up, I will give them due credit for that. I believe I've already mentioned the concept of innocent infringement which may be relevant here.

Re:Canadian anti-piracy outfit pirates photos for its website by biot on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @03:02PM (#5714028)
There is a certain amount of schadenfreude involved in seeing someone hoisted by their own petard. This is true whether or not you agree with the reasons for said hoisting.
Re:Canadian anti-piracy outfit pirates photos for its website by dougk16 on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @05:25PM (#5715056)
Interesting point from more of a logical perspective...I upvoted you for sparking discussion, although I think there's a flaw there. Namely, I think your argument would only hold water (logically) if the anti-piracy group intentionally violated their own standards, which I don't believe they did. It was accidental violation, which just goes to support the anti-anti-piracy view, that pinning down "ownership" in the era of digital content can be so difficult that even anti-piracy groups mess it up.
Re:Canadian anti-piracy outfit pirates photos for its website by dspillett on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @12:13PM (#5712956)
If they disagree with what they do, when it could be applied to themselves, how is their position fair at all either?

I made no statement as to whether I agree with what they expect of others - I simply suggested they should do what they would expect others to do, lest they be classified hypercrits.

Re:Canadian anti-piracy outfit pirates photos for its website by guizzy on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @11:36AM (#5712671)
He's simply highlighting their hypocrisy.