Interesting point from more of a logical perspective...I upvoted you for sparking discussion, although I think there's a flaw there. Namely, I think your argument would only hold water (logically) if the anti-piracy group intentionally violated their own standards, which I don't believe they did. It was accidental violation, which just goes to support the anti-anti-piracy view, that pinning down "ownership" in the era of digital content can be so difficult that even anti-piracy groups mess it up.