News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:France weighs 'culture tax' by varjag on Tuesday May 14, 2013 @08:38AM (#5704444)
> A country can create the freaking money.

A country can print money, but it can't create value to back them at will: the national workforce at their productivity rate create only so much added value at any time.

Yes if a government wants to live beyond its means, it can either print more money, with inflation following shortly; or borrow money, and hope the future generations sort out the downpayments somehow. If a country has enough assets and reputation on the market it can borrow for decades, but eventually the risk of piling up the debt becomes unacceptable to usual investors, and it's payback time.

Re:France weighs 'culture tax' by loup-vaillant on Tuesday May 14, 2013 @02:30PM (#5706941)
Create vs print: I was indeed talking about printing money (which doesn't necessarily mean actually printing notes).

If I recall correctly, inflation is hardly a bad thing. Okay, super-inflation is a bad thing, but I'm talking 5-15% a year. As if controlling inflation would ultimately cause unemployment. As long as we keep it smooth, and the salaries rise along with the prices, then it's only a tax on savings. Plus, inflation seems to be heavily and negatively correlated with unemployment (I'm not sold on that idea, but as far as I know, it seems plausible).

I also agree that there is such a thing as living above one means, even if it's a whole country. I disagree however that printing money (with the intention of destroying most of it later) instead of borrowing it at a significant interest rate would necessarily cause inflation. Or are you implying that your government is by nature unreasonable, and will systematically abuse its power to print?

Possibly. But then, if I can't trust my government with that, I can't trust it with anything (starting with taxes). If it's a problem with this particular government, we have elections. If it's a problem with any possibly elected government, then maybe it's time to change the governance itself.

Re:France weighs 'culture tax' by varjag on Sunday May 19, 2013 @05:18AM (#5732343)
> Or are you implying that your government is by nature unreasonable, and will systematically abuse its power to print?

No, and indeed the governments use printing press as a last resort. However when it becomes necessary to inflate in a last ditch attempt of saving economy, we're not speaking of 5-15%.

Greece without external bailout, were it not in Eurozone, would've taken perhaps 500-1000% annual, with most loss concentrated within few initial months. People's savings would've been wiped and confidence in the currency lost for at least a decade. Likewise for Iceland, Cyprus and other borrowing bubble zones.

Re:France weighs 'culture tax' by derleth on Tuesday May 14, 2013 @05:27PM (#5708338)
> inflation is hardly a bad thing

The idea that inflation is always and forever a bad thing, PERIOD, is religious dogma for some people; they will not be budged, nor swayed, nor convinced to look at any evidence that inflation is part of a healthy, growing economy.