News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Flying Car Crashes In British Columbia by mikeash on Sunday May 12, 2013 @09:21PM (#5696687)
There are two completely unrelated kinds of flying car.

First is the Jetsons version of the flying car. This is the aviating equivalent of the personal automobile. You get in, you fly it to work from your driveway, land it on the roof of your office building, and walk in.

Second is what this was: a machine that's both a road car and an airplane.

The first one is at least conceptually very neat. If it worked, it could completely eliminate traffic jams, eliminate pedestrian-vehicle accidents, and vastly improve the efficiency of local transport. There's been little attempt to build such a thing. It basically demands VTOL operation, which vastly restricts its range and increases its cost and noise. The Moller Skycar is the only real-world attempt at this one that I can think of, and it didn't get very far.

The second one is completely pointless. The "flying car" as it actually (barely) exists, as in this example, is just a car that is also an airplane. You drive it to an airport, reconfigure it to be an airplane, fly it to another airport, land, reconfigure it to be a car, and drive off.

The problem is that design tradeoffs mean that such a "flying car" is both a bad car and a bad airplane. They have inherently different needs for things like wheels, engines, drivetrains, etc. Putting both into the same machine means it's not going to do either one well.

For every "flying car" out there, you can take the same money and buy a better car, a better airplane, a second better car to keep at your most frequently used destination airport, and have enough money left over to rent cars at other airports for years and years. This is unlikely ever to change.

The Jetsons idea is interesting, but roughly nobody is working on anything at all applicable to it.

Re:Flying Car Crashes In British Columbia by derekp7 on Sunday May 12, 2013 @09:53PM (#5696784)
I think the closest we'll get to a personal flying vehicle would be something similar to a powered hang glider / ultralight. The way I envision it would be retractable wings using carbon fiber for the skeletal structure, and an electric motor somewhat like in a Dyson vacuum cleaner for power (along with a fuel cell so it can run off hydrocarbons, as that has a better power to weight ratio then batteries). If the mass of the entire device is less than the mass of the person it is carrying then I would think damage (to third parties / structures) would be limited.
Re:Flying Car Crashes In British Columbia by Wingman4l7 on Sunday May 12, 2013 @10:21PM (#5696848)
The most workable concept at the moment is basically a powered parachute/paraglider trike beefed up to be like a dune buggy. I always felt this was cheating though, because when I hear "airplane" I think of a fixed wing design.

EDIT: ... which is exactly the design that crashed. AFAIK these don't require a pilot's license, but that doesn't mean they're easy to fly.

Re:Flying Car Crashes In British Columbia by mikeash on Sunday May 12, 2013 @10:40PM (#5696898)
It does seem less awful than other concepts, but still... why? It's a worse dune buggy and a worse airplane than you could build if you took the same resources and built the two separately.

As for being hard to fly, I believe the rationale behind not requiring licenses is simply that you're unlikely to kill anyone else when you crash, so do what you will. At least in the US, licensing requirements for different kinds of aviation scale fairly directly with the number of innocent civilians you can take out if you screw up too badly. Not 100% the case, but a decent approximation.

Re:Flying Car Crashes In British Columbia by Wingman4l7 on Sunday May 12, 2013 @11:20PM (#5697021)
Oh, I'm not disagreeing with you, just commenting on flying car design.

AFAIK licensing requirements scale with aircraft size and complexity -- which does correlate nicely with its danger to bystanders.

Re:Flying Car Crashes In British Columbia by mikeash on Monday May 13, 2013 @10:13AM (#5698737)
Yep, I was just elaborating a bit.

You're right that licensing requirements go up with size and complexity, but it's a bit beyond that as well. For example, carrying people in exchange for money has stricter licensing than carrying people for fun, because the idea is that 1) you'll do it more often and 2) people paying you for services are less aware of the risk they're taking.