News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by Adam503 on Saturday April 18, 2009 @04:47PM (#568723)
Bruce Sterling "Poor folk love their cellphones."

"Poor folk" don't have cellphones. They can't afford them.

Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by olefoo on Saturday April 18, 2009 @05:11PM (#568737)
There is a $20 Billion (with a B) a year market in prepaid cell phone services that says you are wrong.

And as is often the case, providing convenient retail solutions for small purchasers can be more profitable than demanding long term contracts.

As with many things, when it comes to mobile services the poor pay more and get less.

Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by Adam503 on Saturday April 18, 2009 @05:42PM (#568776)
Those are lower middle class people buying those services. The poor would be choosing between their cellphones and shelter. Am not saying there are no people that choose to be homelessness and keep their cellphone, but there aren't very many.
Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by mbrubeck on Saturday April 18, 2009 @10:37PM (#569021)
It's not at all unusual to see homeless people with mobile phones. Some homeless shelters even provide them to clients, to help them with job hunting. And it's not like anyone is "choosing to be homeless" by spending $5/month on a prepaid cell phone.
Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by jibiki on Saturday April 18, 2009 @06:29PM (#568819)
No true Scotsman would own a cellphone!

In all seriousness, "poor" to me does not mean homeless. In fact, there are many people above the poverty line who I consider poor (the so-called "working poor".) Obviously this is different for you, and it's silly to have an argument over semantics.

Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by Adam503 on Saturday April 18, 2009 @07:14PM (#568861)
There's official US. Gov't standards for these types of things, you know.

I use the same terminology and standards the US. Gov't does. http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/poverty/threshld/thresh07.htm...

If someone insists on trying to communicate applying their own individual definition to terms of common usage that are different than those others in a region uses, they themselves are the ones that will have difficulty communicating their ideas.

If the discussion is about poverty and the poor, and the discussion is in the US, the US Gov't standard would be the reasonable standard for terminology to be derived.

So a single person with no dependents is considered poor in the US if they make less than $10,590 or roughly 10/11 K a year. I responded to Sterling's statement that said poor people love cellphone because people that make less than 10/11K a year don't have cell phone because they can't afford them.

Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by olefoo on Saturday April 18, 2009 @10:56PM (#569037)
If you go through tracfone.com you can get into a phone and have very minimal service for less than $100 a year. That's slightly less than 1% of gross income, which is probably low for what people in that situation spend on communication.

Now you or I would find the service cripplingly limited. But for someone who really needs it. It's there.

Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by varjag on Saturday April 18, 2009 @08:48PM (#568943)
It is quite obvious from the article that "poor" was used there in sense of "not rich". Like, when one says "I'm a poor student" he doesn't necessarily mean he lives in cardboard box and hunts for his lunch in city park.
Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by omouse on Saturday April 18, 2009 @11:16PM (#569055)
"I'm a poor student" he doesn't necessarily mean he lives in cardboard box and hunts for his lunch in city park.

Well if you're a sociology student or something... :P

Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by rarestnews on Saturday April 18, 2009 @06:41PM (#568835)
My friend told me the other day he was in a bus, and there he saw a very poor immigrant who was talking on his cell whole trip. I thought this was weird and unusual, but he told me he saw similar thing lots of times. Many of my friends who earn little, spend ALL of their money on unnecessary purchases, like newest cellphones, newest clothing, etc, they're deep in debt and continue spending this way.
Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by Adam503 on Saturday April 18, 2009 @08:32PM (#568931)
There's some really incredible things people say "a friend of theirs saw." Here's a regularly updated page with 25 of those things people swear their friends were eyewitness to...

http://www.snopes.com/info/top25uls.asp

Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by rarestnews on Sunday April 19, 2009 @08:36AM (#569357)
Kudos for bringing it up. Now we have a conspiracy to find the elusive poor guy with a cellphone. Maybe next decade we'll develop a cryptomobilanthropology hunting for the unbelieveable miracle of elusive poor guy talking on a cell phone hiding in foggy woods and out-of-focus areas.

Kudos, Adam503, keep up the good work debunking the greatest mysteries of our time!

Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by pavel_lishin on Saturday April 18, 2009 @10:38PM (#569024)
Ain't that the American dream?
Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by maigret on Sunday April 19, 2009 @03:30AM (#569218)
Sure they do afford. Most people in Africa have a cell phone. They just don't have computers.
Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by Agathos on Sunday April 19, 2009 @09:32AM (#569387)
I don't know about "most." But yeah, the story of the poor African who uses a microloan to buy a cellphone that he/she rents to the rest of the village has been told so many times, it's a cliche.

Also there's the one about the fishers and farmers who check on market prices before making the long trek to sell their goods.

Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by pfedor on Saturday April 18, 2009 @05:34PM (#568768)
In downtown Palo Alto you can see people sitting on the sidewalk with cardboards which say they lost their jobs and don't have money for food, talking on their iPhones.
Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by Adam503 on Saturday April 18, 2009 @05:43PM (#568777)
You think there's poor people in Pala Alto, CA, huh?

Wikipedia has per capita income in Palo Alto, CA as $56,257.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_locations_by_per_cap...

Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by joechung on Saturday April 18, 2009 @06:32PM (#568824)
Given the number of people whose income is over $56K, that implies that there are just as many, if not more, people whose income is below that.
Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by Adam503 on Saturday April 18, 2009 @07:24PM (#568870)
The US standard for poverty is roughly $10,500 a year. Palo Alto's median income more than 5 times the US poverty standard.

Go find me a place IN Palo Alto someone whose income is $10,500 a year can pay what the US Fed. Gov't standard for what it considers reasonable rent... 30% of one's income to live IN Palo Alto.

Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by MaysonL on Monday April 20, 2009 @11:07PM (#571843)
They can if they get a loan from Grameen. And lots of them have. And paid the loans off, using the phones.
Re:Bruce Sterling: Poor folk love their cellphones by donaq on Sunday April 19, 2009 @02:18AM (#569161)
I think you're missing the point, which is more about misery loving company than about cellphones.