-former HPH participant (not at U Maryland)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wright_brothers
"On September 20, 1904, Wilbur flew the first complete circle in history by a manned heavier-than-air powered machine, covering 4,080 feet (1,244 m) in about a minute and a half."
If you are trying to win a challenge, it makes sense to optimize your solution for it. And fundamentally, it's just never going to be possible to make a human powered helicopter that is compact and can run for a whole. Hovering just requires too many RPM.
Someone should start another prize for 3 minutes.
Apparently a lot of the aircrafts flying capability has to do with its proximity to the ground. I'm sure part (if not all) of the reason why the rotars almost touch the ground.
It seems that you're certainly right, they're not creating a fully functioning flying machine, they're building a challenge winner, and that's what they set out to do.
In both cases, the people who set up the competition where perfectly aware of what they would get. Also, they were smart enough to make their challenge hard, but not impossible (some would argue Sikorsky set the target too high, as it took 30+ years to see a worthy challenger, but it is impossible to foresee how hard a problem is, and Gossamer Albatross had flown the channel in 1980. Also, Hilbert surely set some harder problems)
Seems like this isn't a helicopter, more a human-powered-helicopter-challenge-winning-machine.
I mean, if it can't fly for more than 90 seconds it might technically pass the requirements but is it in the spirit of the prize?