That's still moderation - the article didn't say that the moderation was from admins or reddit staff. Also, there are reddit-wide rules[0] that apply regardless of sub.
Also, r/atheism isn't a hate group. There's plenty of asshats and the occasional hateful post, but it's not a hate group in general. Take a look at the sub[1] on any given day, and most of it isn't hateful
http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/1e0vcv/if_there_is_...
A few comments down (above the fold on even a tiny monitor) we have this exchange:
Poster talking about his Holocaust-surviving grandfather (32 upvotes):
"My grandfather became a believer, but he didn't go all orthodox. He just believed. His reasoning was that if it weren't for god - he would have died many times during the war."
The reply, with 100 upvotes:
"Explanations like that are precisely what makes me hate religion. When people tell themselves these things, they betray an inner conviction that they are somehow better and more special than the countless men women and children who died at the hands of the Nazis. Makes me sick when people say things like that."
Link to comment: http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/1e0vcv/if_there_is_...
If you take faith because God kept you alive during the war as a foundation, a few conclusions can be drawn.
1) God did not want you to die in the war. Why else would surviving be proof of God?
2) God either wanted other people to die in the war, or having no preference either way for them at that point, let them die in the war.
3) God therefore has a preference for you over those that died, even if it's only to fulfill a future purpose.
I personally prefer not to make assumptions about what someone was thinking (but what they could have been thinking is another matter), but doing so at this level seems more a matter of poor assumptions and rigor to me than hate. In any case, a simple explanation of what is wrong with their reasoning along with the accusation of hate is warranted.
Keep in mind, the poster may truthfully be offended by these types of remarks, just as you ostensibly are by their response.
If you castigate them for their actions without even attempting to understand their reasoning, that makes you guilty of exactly the same thing you accuse them of in this instance.
I also think it's in very bad taste to speculate on why someone chose specific coping mechanisms to live with themselves after being one of the few to survive a horrific ordeal.
My primary complaint is not that someone said something like this, but that it was acceptable enough to everyone else in the community that it ended up one of the very first posts in the discussion.
Unfortunately, I don't have time to respond more fully; I didn't realize this would be so controversial.
There are insensitive and caustic comments everywhere - but when they are promoted through upvotes they discourage participation from affected individuals, breeding an environment where people only feel welcome if they subscribe to the dominant opinions. This results in a hollow echo chamber, which is not a satisfactory equilibrium for any forum trying to encourage healthy discussion.
1. Pre-internet definition of forum.
I guess that was just a long-winded way of saying "it's complicated".
The other thing I'll add is this: I do visit /r/atheism, albeit infrequently. And you're probably right that it's not a particularly nice place to visit for people who are actively religious. That doesn't bother me only because I go in with the assumption that they aren't going to be there, aren't interested in being there, and that the few who do come in and stick around are the kind of people who can look past the stylistic stuff and still engage in a conversation which is - hopefully - enlightening for both sides.
I guess that was a long-winded way of saying "it's all about expectations".
Nonetheless, I can understand why you might shy away from /r/atheism. That place has it's own character and it's not for everybody. But what forum is?
If you want the quality content, try this : http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/search?q=flair%3Aquality&...
Just because there's an implicit agreement that subreddit moderators need to obey reddit's rules doesn't mean they have to. If someone does something like posting someone's personal information, the little report button on their post goes to the moderators, who the site admins have trust to actually delete infringing posts. If someone posts something bad and the moderator is half assed or doesn't care, there's no way to get that post removed unless one of the admins stumble upon it or if you were to send the admins a message (I dunno if this would even be reliable).
Mods put in a lot of work, without which reddit would be worse off.
I say all this as a guy who doesn't even visit the site anymore. Haven't logged in in months.
As a kind of olive branch though, let's just say "hate groups like r/mensrights".
Reddit is not a person. What are you trying to say? That all of reddit's 400 million users have the same thoughts and attitude?
The author is trying to say that 400 million people is such a large sample of humanity that classing them as "redditors" instead of just "humans" doesn't add anything.
Let's cut this crap right here. No one is saying they all have the same thoughts and attitudes. However, the entire site is built around users voting on what they like, and what they like is incredibly consistent to the point of clever users[0] gaining massive karma by using a bot to repost the top comments of old threads.
So no, reddit is not a person. It is, however, a collection of people who— for the most part, most of the time— are consistent in what they upvote.
[0]: http://www.reddit.com/r/SubredditDrama/comments/vefen/recap_...
It was discovered that Trapped_in_Reddit was using
Karmadecay to search for old content as it was reposted
to Reddit. TiR would then copy the top comment of the old
thread, and re-use it in the new repost thread, as his
own comment - guaranteeing many upvotes for the re-used
comment.People have been looking at pictures of cats with sayings on them since the 1970's[1]
[1]: https://tytempletonart.files.wordpress.com/2012/04/hang-in-t...
Humans, acting as a group, are very predictable and easily manipulated. There are many smaller communities on reddit where you find a bigger difference from the mean.
I dont really understand this section. Is the author trying to defend reddit's holier art thou attitude towards the world and their tendency to stick their nose in matters they shouldnt in the name of internet justice?
>And Reddit actually has much better checks and balances in place -- thanks to a combination of the upvote system and moderator intervention.
This is just plain false. Subreddits are not moderated by reddit employees, only by the people who founded the subreddit and whoever they choose to moderate the subreddit with them. This is why hate groups like /r/atheism and fox-news-tier biased news subreddits like /r/poltics can exist. Hell, the only visible admin-intervention I've ever heard of on reddit was when they took down the child porn reddits, and even that required -two- pieces by major news outlets on how reddit was hosting child porn.
The upvote/downvote system is literally only useful for propagating viral/interesting content. Far too many people are relying on reddit as a news source nowadays, and thanks to the upvote/downvote system, all it takes is 51% disapproval for an article to virtually disappear. Since everyone uses the downvote button to say "i dont like this content" rather than "this content isnt good/isnt relevant", you get lots of wonderful skews. This is why /r/poltics has such a intense liberal bias - all it takes is a 51% of the users to disapprove of an article that supports republicans in order for the submission to disappear from view of everyone else. Imagine how horrible the news would be if an entire political viewpoint is censored just because the majority believes differently. That's news on reddit.