So you're saying reddit has consistency in what it upvotes? That doesn't refute my point; it actually helps to refute yours.
I'm saying if you created a website called humannews and the entire population of the whole world contributed to it they would consistently upvote the same stuff and it would look almost exactly like reddit.
Humans, acting as a group, are very predictable and easily manipulated. There are many smaller communities on reddit where you find a bigger difference from the mean.
People have been looking at pictures of cats with sayings on them since the 1970's[1]
[1]: https://tytempletonart.files.wordpress.com/2012/04/hang-in-t...