News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. citizens ditch passports in record numbers due to hi... by dragonwriter on Thursday May 09, 2013 @10:29AM (#5680594)
A few nitpicks:

> If you accept current economic theory, a flat tax actually hurts poor people more because it's regressive.

A flat tax is not "regressive" by either of the usual definitions (by the standard definition, a "regressive" tax takes a either a higher total percentage or a higher marginal percentage at lower incomes.)

It still hurts poor people compared to a progressive tax system, because it isn't progressive, so the burden on the poor, at any given total revenue level, is greater than in a progressive system.

> It's regressive because each percentage point of tax means more to the poor person than it does to the rich. 15% of 1M is a lot of money compared to 15% of 30K, but the 30K earner feels that a lot more.

While this decreasing-marginal-utility based argument for why flat taxes are bad for poor people is both consistent in outline with the current theory and well supported by empirical research on the marginal utility of income, calling this "regressive" is inconsistent with the usual definition of "regressive" when it comes to taxation.

Re:U.S. citizens ditch passports in record numbers due to hi... by gnoway on Thursday May 09, 2013 @12:14PM (#5681179)
I agree. Prefacing with 'current economic theory' was a poor choice on my part.

A few of my friends are heavily left-leaning, and anytime the topic of flat taxation or 'the fair tax' comes up they start foaming at the mouth about how it's regressive. The two concepts are paired in my mind.

Re:U.S. citizens ditch passports in record numbers due to hi... by dllthomas on Saturday May 11, 2013 @06:28PM (#5692341)
Flat in dollars is regressive in welfare. It does pay to be clear about which you're speaking of, though.