From http://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm?bay=content.view&#... we learn that:
- Total giving to charitable organizations was $298.42 billion in 2011 (about 2% of GDP). This is an increase of 4% from 2010.
- Giving by individuals (which includes bequests and family foundations) is critically important as it represents nearly 9 out of every 10 dollars donated.
- 32% of all donations, or $95.88 billion, went to religious organizations (down 1.7%). Much of these contributions can be attributed to people giving to their local place of worship. The next largest sector was education with $38.87 billion (up 4%).
- Donations were up to health charities (2.7%), to public benefit charities (4%), to arts, culture, humanities charities (4.1%), to International charities (7.6%), to human services charities (2.5%), to environmental and animal charities (4.6%).
For comparisons to Europe, check out: http://www.american.com/archive/2008/march-april-magazine-co...
- Per capita, Americans give 3.5x than the French, 7x Germans, 14x Italians.
- Americans are 15% more likely to volunteer than the Dutch, 21% more than the Swiss, 32% more likely than the Germans.
The pattern holds true across many demographics (education, age, income).
Second, while many of the donations were to religious organizations, many food banks, shelters, etc are run by the same institutions. Assuming those categories are mutually exclusive is risky at best.
My observations are that Americans definitely look out for themselves. People tend to give (as you stated) in ways that directly or indirectly benefit themselves.
These are broad generalizations but having lived here for 30 years I'd not consider our society to be generous by any stretch of the imagination.
Now, in the techy world I work in, I can find a wealth of self centered pretentious types who are more concerned about how their seen that what they see.
No charity has, or ever will, end major problems like hunger or poverty.
Make a Wish Foundation crows about spending 76% of funds on programs. If the SSA were as efficient as Make a Wish Foundation, it would have an overhead of an additional $185 billion a year (i.e. approximately equal to all federal payroll expenditures).
The government probably has a worse QALY because it runs Medicare, but that's not the government's fault -- anyone who runs the medical care program for old people is going to have horrible numbers there.
(You are more likely to die if you are on Medicare than if you are uninsured. This isn't because Medicare is killing you, it's because old people are on Medicare.)
In addition, we'd have to examine marginal-QALY versus average-QALY. Depending on the question one or the other could be more important.
Americans freak out whenever anyone tries to do QALY measurements, so we don't know just how good (or bad) our various programs are, public or private.
"Medicaid" is the program you're looking for, not Medicare. Anyway, Americans did willing give money to "help the poor" get medical treatment. There were various organizations that operated charity hospitals (Shriners and the Catholic Church come to mind) where you paid what you could pay, and Americans donated generously to keep those hospitals running. It was normal for doctors to put in some amount of unpaid time in charity clinics because that was considered the right thing to do.
But the government crowded all that out, and since it's been a few generations people don't remember.
>I would imagine that the US is also among the greediest countries in the world.
This isn't even close to being right.
I would imagine that the US is also among the greediest countries in the world.
Odd how it can work out that way with percentages.
[edit: grammar]