News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by chimeracoder on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @05:25PM (#5670911)
A similar HN post, which may be of interest: "What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2012?" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4802849

I find this overextension of copyright laws maddeningly frustrating. My previous comment (unfortunately) still stands:

Also still under copyright:

"I Have a Dream" until 2038[1]. This is particularly frustrating because the copyright holders include the estate of the person who delivered the speech, but not the estate of the two other people who wrote it (and likely most of it) - not to mention the fact that, by any web-era definition, it was a public performance and also a 'general publication'.

"Happy Birthday" (certainly in the EU until 2016, and potentially in the US too until 2030, though this is disputed[2]).

There is also one movie - whose name escapes me now - which entered the public domain and was then put back under copyright protection subsequently.

In the case of "I Have a Dream", think of the societal cost of raising two generations of students without a complete copy of the speech in their textbooks (as is generally the case).

Alternatively, think of how a 2012 version of "I Have a Dream" would happen today. If hundreds of cell phone recordings of the speech were distributed halfway around the world within mere minutes after the speech, of what relevance would copyright protection be?

[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Have_a_Dream#Copyright_disput....

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Happy_Birthday_to_You

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by Guvante on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @05:44PM (#5671034)
[It's a Wonderful Life](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Its_a_Wonderful_Life)

I have heard on several occasions that the reason it is currently so popular is because it went into the Public Domain and was shown on many channels due to this.

Whether that is actually the case no one knows for sure.

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by wisty on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @06:25PM (#5671227)
It's also just a fantastic movie. It's kind of like "A Christmas Carol", but instead of Ebenezer Scrooge being saved, it's the guy who's standing up to him. It's warm, it's funny, and it asks a lot of big questions. And it doesn't appeal to a single viewer. And it's not too heavy, either - Citizen Kane might be better, but it's not really a film you can get a 6 year old to watch.

There's very few movies which are so critically acclaimed (top 100), which can appeal to adults and kids alike. It's subject is both completely commonplace, and the most important thing there is.

Also, how many good Christmas movies are there? It's got to be in the top 5 Christmas films, at least.

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by pfarrell on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @08:28PM (#5671774)
OT but i can't help commenting. Watching IAWLife is something I look forward to every Christmas. It's a rare Holiday movie that doesn't mention Santa or Religion (at least not directly). As I've gotten older, though, I have to say its a pretty dark movie. Only the final few scenes pull you back from the slow decent of man driven to suicide over money and regret over life's missed opportunities. The scene with the disgraced pharmacist (Mr. Gower!) haunts me; considering those moments in my own life that could have destroyed the "future" I know.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by r0s on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @08:55PM (#5671855)
I honestly didn't appreciate "A Christmas Carol" until I was thirty.

The spirit of Christmas Present is Dionysus, and I think this is the Santa archetype either in prototype or metaphor. Portrayal of wealth is great social commentary. The entire play is almost entirely devoid of Christianity, the only mention of God in the whole play, is interesting. Time travel? The future represented as death? Awesome.

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by lmm on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @06:35PM (#5671309)
And yet it was unsuccessful on initial release, both critically and commercially.

(And while the same can be said of several films now considered classics, such films were generally unconventional (at least for their time) in a way that It's a Wonderful Life really isn't)

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by throwaway1980 on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @09:45PM (#5672013)
In my experience,

"A man who hates his life to the point of suicide is shown by a guardian angel how much the other people around him depend on him. As a result of seeing what the world would be like without him, he changes his mind about the suicide and ends up embracing the life he has, recognizing the simple yet wonderful things about it for what they are."

is not a conventional Hollywood story. Do you have any other examples? I'm mostly interested not because I want to prove you wrong, but because I actually want to be wrong and I want to watch these movies if they exist. Groundhog Day is the only other one that comes to mind.

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by vacri on Thursday May 09, 2013 @12:35AM (#5678848)
There are plenty of non-conventional Hollywood stories in movies, you just need to look beyond the usual big studio crops.

I'm also not sure that what you describe is a non-conventional Hollywood story: "Person has hard life (or a good life that hits a serious problem), is about to give up, finds something to have faith in, warm fuzzy ending" is a pretty generic tale.

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by throwaway1980 on Thursday May 09, 2013 @06:57AM (#5679724)
Your synopsis is more general than what I'm thinking of, so of course it's going to catch more things. It's really the specific story of: 1) protagonist's life sucks; 2) protagonist gains deeper understanding about how life works; 3) protagonist sees the same life he was living before in a new light. I guess A Christmas Carol is about like that.

I've seen quite a bit of film, but honestly, if it's really that generic, what are some other examples?

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by omegaham on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @10:27PM (#5672160)
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by throwaway1980 on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @10:40PM (#5672190)
Hey cool, thanks! Incidentally I think the time loop mechanic from Groundhog Day is also from a TZ episode.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by itsadok on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @06:54AM (#5673472)
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by throwaway1980 on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @04:07PM (#5676537)
Thanks to you too!
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by advice4u on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @08:54PM (#5671849)
Which only makes it more remarkable that its popularity continues to grow. That fact suggests there is a special timelessness to the film, since as you say most classics are either prototypical, unconventional, or artistically innovative (like, as was mentioned, Citizen Kane).

The closest analogy I can think of while remaining in the realm of the arts is Vermeer, who was a fairly typical Dutch genre painter unrecognized in his time and ignored for two centuries. Nowadays he is popular and beloved, but unlike Rembrandt who is held as a great master or van Gogh who is held as a quixotic genius, Vermeer himself is taken as wholly mundane; his works simply have some "je ne sais quoi" that resonates with the average person.

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by dmckeon on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @07:26PM (#5671544)
It appears that the copyright on the film was not renewed, leaving it in public domain, but the copyright on the story that the film was based on was renewed, which became a pivotal point after 1993, when that copyright holder was able to negotiate for licensing for more limited showings. This is covered in the URL you provide, and the details are corroborated by several other sources. It is complicated.

One of the effects of the film's popularity in the 1980s is on the popular perception of runs on banks and of bankers - I wonder how much American views of the recent financial crisis are colored by the grim visage of Mr. Potter?

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by Guvante on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @12:13PM (#5712957)
I understand the situation but wanted to be brief. The important point that there was a time when the movie was in public domain and was shown quite a bit. Given the costs of licensing, assuming that is coincidence is suspect.

Since number of views affect popularity, it is possible that a classic is a classic because it became public domain. By extension, would more public domain improve things for everyone?

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by krenoten on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @09:40AM (#5674044)
Fans of the cult movie "The Room" may be interested in knowing that Tommy Wiseau spent a substantial amount of the total budget on securing rights to sing "Happy Birthday".
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by hammock on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @10:02PM (#5672074)
The shorter the copyright, the less incentive there is to create something timeless and lasting (if copyright terms provide incentive to invest in creative work). If spoils are only provided for life+70 years, then an artist may have little incentive to create something that could be enjoyed for a period longer than that.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by ckannan90 on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @10:07PM (#5672094)
That's such a strange thing to say. When artists create their work, do they rank them by the estimated number of years of their legacy, and discard the ones that fall outside of the copyrightable timeframe? I mean, are you implying there are artists out there who aren't creating works because they feel that this one is definitely a "life+75" piece of work, and so what's the point if all I get is life+70?
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by hammock on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @11:43AM (#5674857)
Imagine a copyright that lasts only one day. Would you ever write something to appeal to an international audience? There wouldn't be time enough to translate it.

Imagine someone lives beneath a volcano and knows that at some point an eruption will destroy his house such that he no longer extracts economic benefit from it. Do you think that the way he builds his house (e.g. using straw, or stone) will differ based on whether the eruptions come every 10 years or every 100?

If artists are motivated by the economic incentive afforded by copyright, then the level of that motivation is variable based on the length of copyright.

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by SEMW on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @01:20PM (#5675499)
> If artists are motivated by the economic incentive afforded by copyright, then the level of that motivation is variable based on the length of copyright.

While that's undeniably true, I think the objection is to your leap from observing that motivation significantly increases with term length at term = 1 day, to concluding it's still significantly increasing at term = life+70yrs.

Economic incentive can be measured and modelled, and while there isn't that much research into this, there is some. One Cambridge study (Pollock [2007]) found that the optimum length of copyright term is ~14 years (any longer and the economic benefits of works going into the public domain outweigh further increases in incentive to produce). Now, yes, economics models should be taken with a large grain of salt (especially ones when it's unfeasible to test their predictions). But it's a start, and certainly there don't seem to be any econ studies supporting a length anywhere near life+70 or longer.

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by nano111 on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @11:52AM (#5674911)
Are you saying that home builders and engineers should get paid royalties for as long as the house stands?
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by eru on Sunday May 19, 2013 @12:31AM (#5731793)
No, that's the wrong analogy. Hammock's comment applied to housebuilding would be that new houses would fetch lower prices (and thus there would be less incentive to build them), if after a few years your house would cease to be your property and become a publicly owned good.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by lifthrasiir on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @10:17PM (#5672124)
Please let me know an example of works created by a future incentive. As far as I know, in many cases, timeless and lasting works are created either for a current incentive or for something completely independent to monetary incentives.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by malnourish on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @10:05PM (#5672087)
No incentive? What about the incentive of enduring name recognition, creating timeless works, and creating art? There is incentive that transcends monetary gain and for many artists that is what they're after. I am not saying they shouldn't be compensated for their work, if they desire compensation.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by e12e on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @10:26PM (#5672156)
This clearly explains why DaVinci didn't leave us with anything timeless and lasting. Thank you.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by cgag on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @02:30AM (#5672852)
Do people just downvote sarcasm or are people just not recognizing it? Thought this was hilarious.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by tomp on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @04:14AM (#5673105)
When first reading, I didn't see it as sarcasm, just as an unsubstantiated claim. Rereading it, I'm still not so sure...
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by RyanMcGreal on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @08:35AM (#5673756)
Poe's law. There is no parody so outrageous that someone couldn't make the same argument either sincerely or as a troll.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by pfedor on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @04:07PM (#5676536)
The corollary of course being that when you're so far gone that you can't even imagine anyone honestly thinking differently than you--that you're unwilling to even consider arguments in favor of other opinions--that you see what you believe as obvious and everyone as insane--then of course you will respond to any honest attempt at discussion the way you just did.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by RyanMcGreal on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @11:10PM (#5678572)
Of course it's possible that the original comment is sincere, but given how objectively nonsensical it is - and the same user's follow-up comment [1] is even more hyperbolic - it is far more likely that the comment is either a) a troll, b) some kind of performance art or c) so hopelessly dogmatic that it might as well be a troll.

And for what it's worth, I consider myself reasonably capable of considering arguments in favour of opinions that differ from my own. On many occasions I have changed my mind about an issue based precisely on arguments that persuasively challenged my assumptions or beliefs. I just have an expectation that those arguments should not be ridiculous.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5674857

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by Contero on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @05:20PM (#5677041)
He gave a sincere followup. It wasn't sarcasm.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by noptic on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @02:57AM (#5672923)
I see what you did there
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by camus on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @11:29PM (#5672322)
I guess hammock was being sarcastic ...
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by kbenson on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @01:01AM (#5672589)
Poe's law strikes again.

I can only interpret it as sincere, or very deadpan.

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by skore on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @03:22AM (#5672966)
It's a thing around here: There is no deadpan option available on Hacker News. There are only jokes that sometimes work.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by theorique on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @07:29AM (#5673547)
We need a deadpan tag.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by skore on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @08:45AM (#5673800)
I actually pondered making that into an AskHN discussion after writing my reply - proposing to add "sarcasm" and "joke" tags more readily, but it occurred to me that this is precisely how it should be and how people like it.

It's a kind of hypersensitivity that acts as quality control. Instead of firing off sarcasm quickly without too much thought and cheaply pointing it out with a "sarcasm" badge, you only get to make jokes or be sarcastic if it is very, very well thought through.

I actually got away with (meaning - positive karma) a joke the other day, although I later pointed it out in a reply to somebody who didn't realize it. Still - felt like an accomplishment and I suppose that's how it should be.