> But I think Paul might be surprised at how many people today would choose the '73 Caddy over the '73 911.
If that were true then why would cadillac let that model/style die out unlike porsche with the 911?
I'd wager to guess that most would chose the Porsche. I know I did. You can see mine, which happens to be a 1973 911E as Paul chose for his article, here: http://www.octanenation.com/custom/1973-porsche-911/254/
OctaneNation is my startup.
Further evidence that the 911 is desirable: http://www.hagerty.com/valuationtools/HVT/VehicleSearch/Repo... Mine sold for around $10.5k in 1973, and Haggerty says the average value now is $54k. Using an inflation calculator says $10.5k is equivalent to $53k today... Interesting.
The same Hagerty valuation tool shows the Cadillac is worth around $8k.
Considering the Porsche 911 is still made today and looks just as good today as it did 40 years ago, I think it qualifies as "timeless."
Compare a black 911 Carrera:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/2/24/91...
And today:
https://www.autoweek.com/storyimage/CW/20110125/CARNEWS/1101...
Re:Design
by kenjackson on Sunday May 05, 2013 @09:12PM
(#5660461)
I'm unclear as to what your point is in response to mine? I thought both are timeless designs, for different reasons. Your response doesn't seem to dispute this at all...
I think if you're in a certain population you'll see the Porsche as better designed, but you likely would have thought the same thing in 1973. But I think Paul might be surprised at how many people today would choose the '73 Caddy over the '73 911.