News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Manchester City Council by jerguismi on Thursday May 02, 2013 @07:24AM (#5643674)
No. Goverment web sites should be minimal design & content - black text on white background, no extra graphics. I don't want to pay taxes so that these latte-sipping designers can create cool projects.
Re:Manchester City Council by robfitz on Thursday May 02, 2013 @07:34AM (#5643718)
You are conflating minimal and cheap. A good minimal design takes the same sort of person (who may or may not enjoy milky coffee) as a good design of any other aesthetic.
Re:Manchester City Council by RivieraKid on Thursday May 02, 2013 @08:10AM (#5643905)
You make an assumption that super simple website is the optimal balance between quality and price. I think that it's wrong. First, minimalistic websites with good UX are not significantly cheaper. And second, if the webstite has a lot of visitors, it makes sense to pay lot of money for even small improvements of the UX.
Re:Manchester City Council by EliRivers on Thursday May 02, 2013 @07:48AM (#5643770)
I pay taxes and I want government sites that are easy to navigate and efficiently designed. Black text on white background does not meet my requirements. This design - which I bet puts over 50% of user requirements in those eight simple pictures at the top - meets my requirements.

A page full of black text on a white background? Sounds like you're on some kind of ideological trip.

Re:Manchester City Council by yen223 on Thursday May 02, 2013 @07:47AM (#5643768)
You want government websites to look like a domain-squatter's page: https://www.gov.uk/ ?
Re:Manchester City Council by RivieraKid on Thursday May 02, 2013 @08:17AM (#5643936)
This is the most good-looking gov. web I've seen.
Re:Manchester City Council by JoeKM on Thursday May 02, 2013 @01:09PM (#5645814)
Yes please. That is the most beautiful government website I've ever seen. Simple. Readily informative.

Not only is the landing page excellent, but most websites can't figure out layout beyond the landing page. Check out an article page:

https://www.gov.uk/being-taken-to-employment-tribunal-by-emp...

Simply elegant.

Edit - The landing page could look less like a sea of links if they put a simple 16x16 glyph icon next to each link that represents it.

Re:Manchester City Council by stmchn on Thursday May 02, 2013 @07:55AM (#5643809)
Have you seen the state of some government websites today? Sure they're "minimal" (often not, sometimes they're just plain ugly) but almost always difficult to navigate. You underestimate how difficult it is to organize information-dense government websites. I think people will ultimately get more value out of a well designed site.
Re:Manchester City Council by blowski on Thursday May 02, 2013 @07:31AM (#5643702)
Why should public services be ugly?
Re:Manchester City Council by laumars on Thursday May 02, 2013 @07:54AM (#5643803)
Why do people insist that services which exist purely for quick searching of information have to be design-orientated and pretty?

I hear the same arguments about developer sites (eg PHP manual) but frankly I prefer layouts with an emphasis on conveying content rather than watering down that content behind a wall of epic sized fonts, fading effects and huge scrollable areas.

There's a time and place for each design choice, but government sites aren't there to look pretty, they're there for reference. And while it's entirely possible to have a such a layout that isn't ugly, in this instance I think the site has gone the other way (form over function) - so I'd sooner see be faced with an ugly site.

NB this is coming from a dyslexic who equally hates being presented with walls of text.

Re:Manchester City Council by king_jester on Thursday May 02, 2013 @10:08AM (#5644518)
> Why do people insist that services which exist purely for quick searching of information have to be design-orientated and pretty?

Many of the design principles that improve the aesthetics of a site do have a direct correlation in making those sites easier to navigate and use, esp. for folks who already have a hard time navigating web pages or understanding what information is good/bad/desired. This goes for quality and design of icon sets, font selection, color palette, hinting effects for interactive page elements link links, navigation hierarchy, and more.

> There's a time and place for each design choice, but government sites aren't there to look pretty, they're there for reference. And while it's entirely possible to have a such a layout that isn't ugly, in this instance I think the site has gone the other way (form over function) - so I'd sooner see be faced with an ugly site.

It is true some sites go overboard with visual emphasis will not fully considering user experience. That is true for aesthetically pleasing and unpleasing sites. Government sites are no different from any other kind of site - if aesthetic improvements make the UX better, they are appropriate, perhaps even more so for a site that is supposed to be totally accessible to all people affected by government.

Re:Manchester City Council by laumars on Thursday May 02, 2013 @01:00PM (#5645750)
> Government sites are no different from any other kind of site

I beg to differ. I think government sites (as well as other reference material like programming manuals) are about getting visitors to their requested information as quickly and painlessly as possible. The user experience isn't from browsing the site, it's purely on whether the visitor found the piece of information or not. Where as recreational sites are about keeping visitors on the page for longer. ie encouraging them to browse around on related pages and re-visit the site again - preferably frequently. For that to work, having a prettier site is of more importance (note that I'm not saying more important than usability, just that aesthetics is of more importance on those types of sites than on reference sites).

It's like sports cars vs delivery trucks. The former needs to be prettier as it's a luxury item and few people would buy an ugly luxury item. So sometimes you'll see the design dictated a little by aesthetics (eg the way the doors open). The latter is bought to serve a specific purpose, so if it's not functional then people wouldn't buy it. This means that delivery trucks generally aren't as aesthetically pleasing but they don't need to be.

To expand on my example, when you described how form and function work beautifully together is a little like Eddie Stobart trucks, they've laid the function down first and then worked out how to make it feel a great deal more special by emphasising the functional attributes of the truck. And as much as I agree with you that examples like that in web design is fantastic, it's a very hard thing to judge. Sadly most people don't pull it off.

Re:Manchester City Council by RivieraKid on Thursday May 02, 2013 @08:15AM (#5643926)
Because it improves people's lifes. The main purpose of governent is to improve people's lifes.

But minimal websites doesn't have to be ugly of course.

Re:Manchester City Council by laumars on Thursday May 02, 2013 @09:26AM (#5644290)
You'd have to be pretty shallow to think that aesthetics are the be-all and end-all of improving peoples lives (and particularly in the case of government websites where they're just a tool; people just use them as a means to an end).

Usability should be the most important factor of a government website. If it can be pretty and usable, then that's a bonus.

Re:Manchester City Council by DanBC on Thursday May 02, 2013 @09:58AM (#5644469)
"Design" means two things.

To people like me and you it means "stupid things that prevent me from doing what I want. Things that are only there because someone thinks they look nice"

To good designers it means "very carefully made choices that make information easier to find; that make websites easier to use; and that have the added benefit of making things less ugly."

I say that a book is often a great example of minimal design. Designers point out that books have hundreds of years of cumulative design - the fonts have been iterated; the layout and the margins and the indents and everything has all had decades of iteration.

I get the feeling that you and parent both agree and are now talking past each other.

Re:Manchester City Council by laumars on Thursday May 02, 2013 @12:40PM (#5645613)
This was why I switched to using the terms "aesthetics" and "usability" to make the distinction between the different interpretations of "design" (In fact in the very post you replied to, I hadn't used the term "design" once).

Since The other guy counter-argued using those same terms so I can only assume that our opinions differ.

Re:Manchester City Council by RivieraKid on Thursday May 02, 2013 @10:12AM (#5644548)
I didn't say that, but pretty is better than ugly in almost every situation, that was the point. Good-looking and usable is better than ugly and usable.

Websites should maximize user experience, i.e. how pleasantly the user feels. Aesthetics and usability contribute to that.

Re:Manchester City Council by laumars on Thursday May 02, 2013 @12:37PM (#5645587)
Recreational sites with reference tools. If we were talking about sites like Twitter, then aesthetics are obviously very important. However for productivity tools such as government websites, then usability is far more important as you're not after casual surfers and trying to generate more traffic from them, you're literally just trying to get people to the information they want in the most direct and painless way possible.
Re:Manchester City Council by switch007 on Thursday May 02, 2013 @07:32AM (#5643708)
They should be if it's cheaper (while still meeting the goals etc).
Re:Manchester City Council by nwh on Thursday May 02, 2013 @07:35AM (#5643724)
What correlation is there between expensive design and good design?

I've seen projects that haven't cost more than a few hundred dollars and still look absolutely stunning. I've also seen projects developed this year that look like they have been dragged from the 90s, yet cost millions in today's money.

Re:Manchester City Council by blowski on Thursday May 02, 2013 @08:04AM (#5643868)
A lot of the time the design probably was sketched out in the 90s, and it's taken until this year to reach the development phase.
Re:Manchester City Council by blowski on Thursday May 02, 2013 @08:02AM (#5643852)
Making the website more appealing for non-geeks results in more non-geeks using the website. The website is a more cost-efficient way of servicing non-geek citizens.

So spending money on good design can definitely be worth it. Assuming every penny spent on aesthetics is a penny wasted is a developer fallacy.

Re:Manchester City Council by rhygar on Thursday May 02, 2013 @06:05PM (#5647480)
Says the guy who thought "cooking recipes as Gantt charts" was a good idea: http://kangasbros.fi/visual-cookbook/
Re:Manchester City Council by bwang8 on Thursday May 02, 2013 @01:59PM (#5646165)
The cost of designing a page such as this over a minimalist website is so negligible in terms of the amount the government spend and take everyday, that it is simply not necessary to nitpick. This could be just thought of as an experiment in governmental website design. I think sometimes the "people" act like the worst managers that they micro-manages and want to squeeze every penny, while missing the big picture.
Re:Manchester City Council by scott_riley on Thursday May 02, 2013 @07:34AM (#5643719)
I drink espressos.
Re:Manchester City Council by josefresco on Thursday May 02, 2013 @09:57AM (#5644465)
Fun fact: The primary ingredient of a latte is: espresso.
Re:Manchester City Council by PhilipA on Thursday May 02, 2013 @07:53AM (#5643798)
Never underestimate the competition between municipalities, which are also fought on the web.
Re:Manchester City Council by bengillies on Thursday May 02, 2013 @08:24AM (#5643966)
What does paying taxes and drinking lattes have to do with building a website? Yes you pay taxes to the government, and yes they're in the process of updating their websites (and largely doing a fantastic job of it), but your taxes don't enter into it. The government allocates a certain amount of money towards the process, and that money gets spent on building new websites. That's it. You don't pay for it directly. Please don't pretend that you are.
Re:Manchester City Council by DanBC on Thursday May 02, 2013 @07:57AM (#5643821)
Plain text is not accessible. Plain text fails to help people with motor control problems; with cognitive problems; etc.
Re:Manchester City Council by mattacular on Thursday May 02, 2013 @10:11AM (#5644537)
Yeah, this is definitely the one waste of tax dollars that you should be outraged about.