News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by flatline on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @08:20PM (#5635734)
Of course, there is the risk that everyone thinks McDonalds is a swell idea, and then no one will ever do anything nicer for lunch ever again. Not to stretch the analogy too far, but I have had this happen both literally and figuratively.
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by alxp on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @09:18PM (#5635917)
There's a fable warning about the problem of throwing out a suggestion because you think one needs to be made, and then everyone going along with it because it's what they think the group wants, when no individual actually wants to do that thing. It's called the Abilene Paradox: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abilene_paradox
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by incompatible on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @12:04AM (#5636382)
Wikipedia is actually a great example of how getting something started can eventually lead to something much better. Here's the first version of that article: http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Abilene_paradox...

That's what Wikipedia was like after it was created: random people writing a few words about some subject they thought they knew something about. It didn't seem like it would amount to much, at the time.

Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by pekk on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @09:10AM (#5637634)
Maybe it hasn't amounted to as much as you think.

In addition to a great deal of general information substantially duplicating what you already could have found on the internet (much of Wikipedia is actually scraped/aggregated from elsewhere, which is the real use of crowdsourcing here), it's also jammed full of trivialities and utterly biased, misleading, politicized articles guarded jealously by special interest groups. All those interest groups together form one giant defensive cabal which rejects criticism of Wikipedia and is constantly begging for money to sustain itself. Because it's democratic, you see, and not dominated by those egghead academic experts (but rather by Wikipedia experts, who established their tenure by making an account and writing rarely-verified information to Wikipedia in a way that complied with the politics of Wikipedia incumbents).

Wikipedia could have put effort into seriously verifying incoming information, but that would have made it an elitist affair like academia. Or it could have seriously taken everything democratically, which would have made it a total populist mess. Instead it created its own insular oligarchy to tell everyone what is true or not. And the appointments of this oligarchy are utterly opaque, but they definitely aren't based on any combination of merit and democracy.

Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by splawn on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @10:53AM (#5638286)
I disagree with your assessment that Wikipedia doesn't add value. It acts as an awesome aggregator and is usually a good place to start when learning about any topic. Im not going to play "name that fallacy", but your points against it seem weak to me. Of course its info is scraped and aggregated from other sources. Thats how information works. Thats normal even in academia. Im sure that on pages that don't have many watchers, a bad edit could go unnoticed for a long time, but this shouldn't be an issue for you, since you follow up on sources and practice critical thinking no matter what source you use .
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by samegreatsleeve on Thursday May 02, 2013 @03:45AM (#5643152)
So wikipedia is a low quality content farm that shows up for every google search and prevents actual expert pages from being seen--taking revenue and visibility from experts--while providing lower quality content.

And that's a good thing to you.

An unreliable encyclopedia is the most useless thing in the world. An unreliable encyclopedia with the most powerful SEO in history...is a grave threat to human knowledge.

Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by splawn on Thursday May 02, 2013 @09:50AM (#5644424)
This is an interesting take on it. What are some examples of experts that are being silenced?

Usually when people criticize SEO, its over the methods used to get irrelevant links on pages, putting junk in your serps. Afaik wikipedia does well because people link to its content, not because of spam tactics.

Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by samegreatsleeve on Thursday May 02, 2013 @02:58PM (#5646468)
The experts aren't bing silenced, they just show up on the second page of google so get no hits.

The first page will often have literally 5+ links to wikipedia, and those articles will cite the never-visited reliable page but get a lot of the details wrong.

You're absolutely right that it's a cultural issue more so than a tech issue. Wikipedia marketing has managed to convince people that an amateur content farm should be the first stop for information. But why should your first stop be amateurs who often get it wrong?

Ask any academic how good wikipedia is for their specialty. It always ranges from "ok" to "terrible". And why would we expect anything else? How can amateurs be expected to understand, interpret, and report on reams of subtle developments in any area?

The best wikipedia articles are the ones that tend most toward plagiarism--literally just copying the words and concepts of an academic while barely rephrasing them to avoid copyright infringement. It's not worthwhile.

Meanwhile, every important article on wikipedia has a high quality, professionally written counterpart on Encyclopedia Britannica. What's the point of wikipedia?

For an easy example just search any topic in philosophy. Wikipedia comes up first. Read that, then read Stanford Encyclopedia, then read Encyclopedia Britannica.

Why is wikipedia the top hit? Because their SEO/marketing is overwhelming. It's definitely not due to quality! In contrast, the other two options being beat out by Wikipedia SEO are written by notable experts. The quality difference is enormous. EB and SEP can actually be relied on. On wikipedia you never know what important subtlety they got wrong.

Wikipedia is the eHow or expertsexchange of information. It's a drag on human knowledge. It needs to die.

Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by incompatible on Thursday May 02, 2013 @09:41PM (#5648361)
I can't reproduce your results: I find typical searches give 1 or 2 links to Wikipedia on the first page. And if you add "-wikipedia" you can get rid of the lot.

I do realise Wikipedia is far from perfect. So many articles don't cite their sources, for example, or cite some personal website that doesn't cite any sources at all.

Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by samegreatsleeve on Friday May 03, 2013 @12:34AM (#5648830)
Understand that it isn't MY problem. I find it easy to avoid wikipedia because I know how to do things like -wikipedia.

But I'm not the vulnerable population. Most people don't know to do that, and just think wiki info is fine when it's not.

The results that give 5+ wikipedias on one search are usually long tailed.

Here's one search I just made up:

logic axioms encyclopedia

First 4 hits are wikipedia, all 4 of them are shit. If you just add -wikipedia the results are infinitely better. Therefore, wikipedia is a low quality content farm shitting up the Internet.

It also doesn't help that google, apple products and other services now directly prioritize wikipedia.

Example:

continental philosophy definition

Google first gives a big bold wikipedia box, presenting wikipedia info as if it is the fucking gospel.

Then the next hit is wikipedia.

Then the rest are a mix of reliable sites that wikipedia stole its content from, and wikipedia subsidiaries (Jimmy Wales affiliated) like Citizendium.

How is this considered ok? It's an intellectual travesty and a giant threat to public education. How many people will click the first link, or the giant google endorsed wikipedia box, and ignore all the reliable experts below it?

Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by splawn on Friday May 03, 2013 @09:51AM (#5650068)
I just did your "logic axioms encyclopedia" search, it supports what you say about google giving preference to wikipedia. However, if you compare wikipedia's page to britannica's i think it undermines your argument against wikipedia's inferiority. Wikipedia not only has more information, but it also lists all of the contributors and has a complete list of citations. Britannica's banner ad plastered page featured only 3 paragraphs, no citations for deeper reading and no list of contributors to help you evaluate the content. I know this is just a sample size of one, but I think it shows that your opinion is extreme. As I said before, it doesn't matter where you get your info, you have to practice critical thinking and demand sources. I totally see where you are coming from, but i am not convinced that it is as bad as you are making it out to be. Imo, its the lack of education on how to evaluate information (this includes the ability to determine the "authority" of its sources) that is an intellectual travesty and a giant threat.
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by samegreatsleeve on Friday May 03, 2013 @03:27PM (#5652126)
Britannica costs $5 a month. Their articles are excellent.

A free source written by top philosphers is Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosphy. That should be the first hit.

If Wikipedia wants to be a link farm with citations and links to every source on some topic, that might be an OK service. That's not what they are. They claim to be an encyclopedia. They get it 80% right, but 20% wrong is unacceptable for the world's go-to source for information. Especially when the better alternatives are just as accessible; they only lack SEO.

Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by gertef on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @04:58PM (#5640746)
[Citation needed.]
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by ffn on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @08:40PM (#5635794)
As the guys who usual says "that's a swell idea", or "yeah, I'm down for some McNuggets" to really gross food decisions (masochism, I don't know), I personally love it when other folks throw out these "sequestration" choices because it's usually the only way to get everyone to go to McDonalds.
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by ripter on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @11:37AM (#5638575)
And that's how I discovered the McRib
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by mbetter on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @12:14AM (#5636413)
I actually could go for some McNuggets right now.
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by rmrfrmrf on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @12:59AM (#5636543)
Yeah it's a bad sign when all this post did was make me hungry.
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by hwang0214 on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @01:58AM (#5636679)
haha amen.
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by kvcrawford on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @03:53AM (#5636952)
Ramen?
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by mikec3k on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @02:57PM (#5640058)
Real ramen has nothing in common with those packaged noodles. A big bowl of ramen soup with lots of meat, seafood & a hardboiled egg is heaven.
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by rmrfrmrf on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @03:31PM (#5640255)
See, what you do is buy the ramen packets, a bag of frozen shrimp, and a dozen eggs. Bring the water to a boil, let the ramen rehydrate, then crack an egg right into the pot. Add some frozen shrimp and let it sit for a minute, then break the yolk and stir. Cook until the yolk solidifies and serve.

Duh.

Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by run4yourlives on Thursday May 02, 2013 @04:31PM (#5647028)
It's probably a lot cheaper and easier to go and buy Chinese noodles if that is the end result.
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by ctdonath on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @02:39PM (#5639932)
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by modarts on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @09:06PM (#5635883)
Exactly. I can't even begin to tell you how many times something that was supposed to be "just be a prototype" made it to production this same way.
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by weinzierl on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @04:26AM (#5637006)
You bet. I'm working on an application that is a prototype and a legacy application simultaneously.
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by aurelianito on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @05:08PM (#5640800)
Me too.
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by ripter on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @11:38AM (#5638582)
I've wondered if there is any production software that wasn't "just a prototype"
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by rmc on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @10:08AM (#5637962)
There's nothing more permanent than a temporary solution.
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by vagarwa on Thursday May 02, 2013 @01:02PM (#5645762)
So much wisdom packed into so few words!
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by mseebach on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @12:30AM (#5636466)
If everybody (but you, presumably) is happy with McDonald's then the onus is on you to change their minds. The trick only works when there is a consensus to strive higher. If you fail to do that, then, eventually, you will have to say "screw you guys, I'll go to the ramen-place alone then".
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by aflinik on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @04:53AM (#5637070)
If you had a better idea you should have started with it in the first place.

It should work equally well as a creativity trigger, and if nobody comes up with something different you still end up with a choice that's not so bad.

Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by jonb on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @02:54PM (#5640043)
Indeed. Steve Jobs apparently said "The name of the company is Apple unless you can think of something better by tomorrow." And they couldn't.
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by vacri on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @08:30PM (#5635763)
If it backfires, then all you need to do is next time say "let's do something different".
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by flatline on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @08:37PM (#5635783)
Once a precedent has been established, it can be hard to change people's minds, especially if it was fast/easy/convenient the first time around. It really depends on the group.
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by designflip on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @08:20AM (#5637462)
I think it works well in the writer's case. He knows his audience and has probably worked with them long enough to know where they like to go to eat. He's not taking the risk of McDonald's every day. There wasn't a chance that would happen anyway because even if one or two person wanted to go to McDonalds two days in a row, the group would win out and override it.
Re:The McDonald's Theory of Bad Ideas by run4yourlives on Thursday May 02, 2013 @04:30PM (#5647019)
If everyone thinks McDonald's is a swell idea, it probably is.

This means that either A) Lunch isn't as important as everyone seems to make it out to be , or B) McDonald's is "good enough" or C) some combination of factors including A and B that suggest worrying about where you are eating for lunch isn't worth any of your time today.