News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Appeal to Google: Make ".io" a gccTLD by mattmanser on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @09:07AM (#5631895)
It turns out that we've got massive domain squatting, America somehow snagged .com instead of .us, England decided to use .co.uk for no apparent reason, there's seemingly some sort of massive corruption going on in ICANN 'selling' tlds, etc., etc.

i.e. the whole thing turned into a complete and utter farce long ago.

In the end it's not a perfect world and it's a hack because the very tld domain system itself was woefully broken even in conception.

Re:An Appeal to Google: Make ".io" a gccTLD by RobAley on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @09:16AM (#5631951)
> England decided to use .co.uk for no apparent reason

Eh? The UK (not "England") use .uk. This is then subdivided into .co.uk, .ac.uk, .org.uk, .gov.uk and many more depending on the type of organisation, as ccTLDs were initially envisioned, i.e. type.country

Re:An Appeal to Google: Make ".io" a gccTLD by mattmanser on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @11:37AM (#5632770)
Why wan't it .co.us then? Or .com.uk? At best it's meaningless, at worse the US was the very first domain squatter sitting on all the tlds.

What actually happened is a massive waste of money paying for stupid extra domain names to stop someone else impersonating you. It's just historical.

And now they claim their increasingly worrying and opaque laws apply to any website that uses it, which is even worse for us all.

That the UK decided to then follow the naming convention (or any other country that did) is a waste of letters.

Total farce.

(I did actually mean UK, I'm English and it was a slip)

Re:An Appeal to Google: Make ".io" a gccTLD by walshemj on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @12:09PM (#5633025)
Because county tlds organization is devolved to that country duh they each do their own thing.
Re:An Appeal to Google: Make ".io" a gccTLD by justincormack on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @01:09PM (#5633439)
.co.x vs .com.x is arbitrary. But .uk should be .gb technically.
Re:An Appeal to Google: Make ".io" a gccTLD by blowski on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @01:30PM (#5633630)
Actually, .gb exists as well, but the subdomain is dra.hmg.gb.

.uk was created before the standard was agreed, and the UK was allowed to keep using it.

Re:An Appeal to Google: Make ".io" a gccTLD by thomasahle on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @09:18AM (#5631965)
England has chosen to split up their tld into .ac.uk, .co.uk, .gov.uk etc.: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.uk

Because the Americans owned ICANN, they got away with first-level domains for everything, .com, .gov, ... Other countries had to either put everything under one domain, or split it up like the brits.

Re:An Appeal to Google: Make ".io" a gccTLD by kijeda on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @11:21AM (#5632663)
That is some terrible revisionist history.

.com, .net, .gov etc. were the first TLDs created in the early 1980s (when the DNS was invented, before ICANN existed). Only later in the mid 1980s were country codes added to the repertoire, and each country was given one based on the ISO 3166 standard — including the US (.us).

The only domains with geographic prohibitions were .gov and .mil, being run by the US Government. People of all countries have always been able to register domains in .com, .net etc., not just Americans.

Re:An Appeal to Google: Make ".io" a gccTLD by takluyver on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @01:05PM (#5633415)
Anyone can register a .com, .net, .org address, but the registries are subject to US law. So, for instance, US courts can order a .com domain taken down, even if it points to servers in another country.
Re:An Appeal to Google: Make ".io" a gccTLD by dalore on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @09:45AM (#5632134)
United Kingdom, not England.
Re:An Appeal to Google: Make ".io" a gccTLD by eloisant on Tuesday April 30, 2013 @09:11AM (#5631920)
What's wrong with .co.uk? It's the same in Japan: .co.jp, .ac.jp, .or.jp... And I think it's good.