Re:Ask HN: What would your reaction be? (final year undergra...
by STajbakhsh on Monday April 29, 2013 @07:34PM
(#5629555)
Those are interesting points and luckily I am aware of them. I quite like the angle at which you're looking at this; it made me think again.
Re:Ask HN: What would your reaction be? (final year undergra...
by mike_mikeson on Monday April 29, 2013 @08:10PM
(#5629684)
We should be very very thankful for these questions. They differentiate the people that have really read around and understand what it is that we're doing in CS, and those that have just been to the lectures.
I would relish this essay question - I would have written about the history of Unix, the evolution towards Plan 9 and why it failed. These are important issues in CS, and if you are ignorant of them you are likely to repeat them. Your professor is testing that you have understood these lessons from history.
I think you need to retract your implication that it's somehow an inherently bad or embarrassing choice for a question.
All you have left is that you are fundamentally opposed to any philosophical, historical or human factor thinking in CS, and I don't think that's a supportable position.