News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

mike_mikeson

Re:Plain English Explanation of Big-O on Wednesday May 01, 2013 @02:18AM (#5636735)
There's a whole lot of ignorance going on in there.
Option is a monad. All monads are functors. The key characteristic of a functor is that you can map over it. So why does it surprise you to be using map with Option?

The Scala docs (http://www.scala-lang.org/api/current/index.html#scala.Optio...) tell you this in the second paragraph.

To be honest, and I'm being a bit snarky here I know, I think you're just fairly ignorant of basic functional programming techniques. That's not a crime, but don't mouth off about functional programming if you know so little about it.

We should be very very thankful for these questions. They differentiate the people that have really read around and understand what it is that we're doing in CS, and those that have just been to the lectures.
But people make technical design decisions in operating systems based on trying to make the operating system as conceptually simple as possible, which is what he means by beautiful, which I hope you would know from reading the literature.

I would relish this essay question - I would have written about the history of Unix, the evolution towards Plan 9 and why it failed. These are important issues in CS, and if you are ignorant of them you are likely to repeat them. Your professor is testing that you have understood these lessons from history.

I think you need to retract your implication that it's somehow an inherently bad or embarrassing choice for a question.

All you have left is that you are fundamentally opposed to any philosophical, historical or human factor thinking in CS, and I don't think that's a supportable position.

I don't get what your objection is?

It's obviously a mini-essay question, a chance to show your opinions and reason about ideas. Seems good to me.

Do you not like it because it's not a yes-no question? Welcome to reality, where not all questions have simple answers, even in CS. That's probably why it's a top-tier university!

Whatever you do don't look at this exam paper from Cambridge - it will blow your mind http://www.phil.cam.ac.uk/u_grads/Tripos/Ethics/Past_Exams/1.... Example question "What makes death bad?"