News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by hkmurakami on Monday April 29, 2013 @05:56PM (#5629103)
I'm no expert in design, but when trends change so consistently, I have to wonder whether this is like automobile design or fashion where UI design kind of just "rotates" and churns indefinitely rather than head towards "the true answer"

I have no idea and no opinion on which is better etc, just genuinely curious.

Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by morsch on Monday April 29, 2013 @06:19PM (#5629232)
Fashion and automobile design are quite mature fields, though, compared to human machine interfaces. This is reflected in the fact that most changes in digital interfaces include shifts in terms of functionality. These kinds of changes are very rare in fashion: pants (either BE or AE) all work mostly the same -- and so do cars. The choices made seem to affect mostly aesthetics as opposed to functions.

I guess it's possible that at some point the major interface methods will be standardized to such a degree that future changes will be aesthetic, to avoid putting off people, if nothing else. For instance, there was considerable resistance to MS changing the functional interface of Office not too long ago. But even mature consumer interfaces such as windowing systems continue to introduce additional functionality, although I guess some might characterize those changes as mere window dressing (heh), as well.

Some computer interfaces do head towards what some conceive to be the true answer, with a slow stream of incremental improvements, e.g. the Unix shell. But that's a professional interface subject to other kinds of pressures than consumer technology.

IANAD.

Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by brudgers on Monday April 29, 2013 @06:28PM (#5629276)
Automotive design has changed radically around function - safety and aerodynamics being the most obvious visible changes which could be trivialized as styling.
Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by morsch on Monday April 29, 2013 @06:41PM (#5629333)
Ok, obviously you're right about that, but I was thinking just in terms of the human-machine interface. Even then, automotive engineering is much less "stale" than fashion, and any new technology may push towards more radical change.
Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by brudgers on Monday April 29, 2013 @08:26PM (#5629746)
Touch screen navigation, voice control, DVD players, third row seating, dynamic stability control, launch mode, dial-in suspension...etc.
Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by MatthewPhillips on Monday April 29, 2013 @06:32PM (#5629304)
Does automobile design really churn? I know occasionally companies try to revive classic styles (the PT Cruiser or Ford Thunderbird) but those don't seem to catch on and spread into a general fad. What you think of as the 50s style, or the 80s jagged style haven't been revived and I very much doubt they ever will.
Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by Domenic_S on Monday April 29, 2013 @06:49PM (#5629372)
> 80s jagged style

Hard creases are very in right now, as are sweeping contours (90s) -- today's style looks like 80s + 90s + modern facelifting.

Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by scott_meade on Monday April 29, 2013 @06:03PM (#5629142)
Yes, that's how it works and is why the TechCrunch article calls flat design a "fad".
Re:Apple’s Jony Ive said to be bringing flat design to iOS 7 by angersock on Monday April 29, 2013 @06:31PM (#5629296)
It's strange, because it seems to be a regression to Visual Basic and Hypercard aesthetics in some ways. Embossed buttons? Pshaw!