I wouldn't put up a huge stink if the law was "you must pass the bar exam".
However, the law is "you must attend 3 years of law school".
> These laws do not exist solely to frustrate you
Agreed. They exist to decrease the supply of lawyers, thus increasing the price that lawyers can demand.
Frustrating me is just a side effect.
I sympathize with your frustration, but the reason for the prerequisites could just as easily be that they don't believe they can create a test which properly encompasses everything a lawyer should know.
Also, at least in San Francisco, the job market seems to be saturated with lawyers, even before the economy went south.
Actually, there are still a few states where you can join the bar after clerking for a number of years and passing the bar exam.
See, for example: http://www.wsba.org/lawyers/licensing/faq-rule6.htm
This untrue, throughout history companies get laws to make upstarts more difficult. There is no reason you need to go to law school or even pass the bar, if the buyers don't think it is a good tool they won't use it.
In fact things can work the other way, you are protected the few who may be swindled (they're clearly visible), but ignore all those who are harmed by the lack of new products. It's very hard to look at the other side of the equation, but it is normally quite significant.
Unless a company already has lawyers on staff, they have no way of determining whether a legal expert system is a good product or not. For that reason, it cannot be a substitute for a living, breathing lawyer. It could certainly be a tool for lawyers, and streamline the hell out of most legal processes, but to treat it as something more is to give up on any lowest common denominator for legal advice. And while this would certainly harm lawyers, it would also harm a great many other people.
The recent mandates on testing toys for lead, has pretty much outlawed small toy producers. You can't prepare food at your house and legally sell it (even if you say this was cooked at my house). The FDA debacle with juice pasteurization vs more modern UV processes.
> And while this would certainly harm lawyers, it would also harm a great many other people.
Once again you make a statement that claim to be true with no real backing. Say 1 person is harmed by this newer cheaper law advice, and 10,000 are saved due to the reallocation of resources to medicine -- this is of course a hypothetical example, but it has just as much grounding as yours.
Not: we need the government to be our nanny. That results in all kinds of really bad side effects, including those illustrated by the person who started this thread.
Thanks Mark
In most of these cases, it's not the government protecting existing companies, it's the government protecting the naive population. You won't fire someone after six months of unpaid labor, but someone else will. Your expert system might create air-tight contracts, but someone else will cut corners.
These laws do not exist solely to frustrate you. Part of being in a uniformly free society is ensuring that naive people are not at the mercy of the better informed or less scrupulous. Things can't work any other way.