Is this true? Is it really such an open-and-shut case?
In some senses it is obviously true: There were a lot fewer people, a lot fewer filing cabinets and a lot fewer regulations. A lot of the tools needed for our big modern system -- hygiene, communications, literacy -- just weren't there yet. There were essentially no worker protections in the early stages of the Industrial Revolution; there were few environmental regulations. And travel and communications were harder, which made it easier to evade certain regulations -- they say that, as late as the 20th century, movie companies relocated to Hollywood in large part because it was the US city farthest from Thomas Edison's patent lawyers.
But government-sanctioned monopolies are not a new invention. (That's what the British East India Company was all about.) Enormous tariffs levied on mass-produced goods are not a new invention. Taxes are not a new invention. Gangs of Luddites (not metaphorical Luddites -- the real thing) who break your equipment and sabotage your business model are not a new invention.
Wine monopolies? Here's a book that deals, in part, with how the English ban on French wine imports boosted the English brewing industry in the 17th century:
http://www.amazon.com/War-Wine-Taxes-Political-Anglo-French/...
And here's a Wikipedia article on mercantilism, the dominant theory of international trade for over 250 years, starting in 1500:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercantilism
Mercantilism was all about big-government management of the economy through tariffs and subsidies. But, of course, that was arguably a big improvement over the medieval model: Small-government "management" of the "economy" by private armies who threatened to burn your crops and besiege your house unless you paid tribute.
Given this, the idea that there could be less (or about the same) regulatory interference of business today is, frankly, ludicrous. For one thing, simply reducing business budgets (taxes) at the rate the government does is an onerous burden all by itself. Arguments can certainly be made that it's a net gain for society, but please do not be disingenuous in stipulating the facts.
That depends crucially on which business you're talking about. Exceptions abound. Consider that example of the mail-order wine business. Do you know how hard it was to start such a business in the days before FDR? There was a lot of "regulatory interference", personified by guys like "Eliot Ness". You couldn't start a wine business in the USA, full stop -- unless you kept it underground. That era also had a devastating effect on our brewing industry that took a generation to recover from.
One could also ask some of the people who run porn sites about the complex history of "regulatory interference" in their business.
And, as we now know all too well, there have been times when regulation of the financial industry was much more strict than it is today. That's not a simple history, either: Corporations and stock exchanges have existed since the 17th century, but their degree of regulation has changed in complicated ways over time.
And a relentless focus on taxes obscures other forms of interference that were more important at certain times, for certain industries. However onerous it is to start a telecom-based company today, it was probably harder back in those days before FDR, when AT&T held a government-sanctioned monopoly over all of US telephony:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ma_Bell
In 1934, the government set AT&T up as a regulated monopoly under the jurisdiction of the Federal Communications Commission, in the Communications Act of 1934... by 1940 the Bell System effectively owned most telephone service in the United States, from local and long-distance service to the telephones themselves. This allowed Bell to prohibit their customers from connecting phones not made or sold by Bell to the system without paying fees. For example, if a customer desired a type of phone not leased by the local Bell monopoly, he or she had to purchase the phone at cost, give it to the phone company, then pay a 're-wiring' charge and a monthly lease fee in order to use it.
That the Internet managed to come into existence at all is the result of a complex interplay of antitrust law, the rise of government-funded research under guys like Vannevar Bush, and the Cold War (DARPA, which funded the Internet, was born in the days after Sputnik).
Today, our cable and phone companies also wield virtual monopolies with the help of the FCC. The situation is pretty bad in the USA. But I'm not sure it's significantly worse than it was back in 1940.
Prohibition was passed in 1919 (under Wilson) and "repealed" in 1934. (The repeal amendment federalized some restrictions that hadn't existed before 1919.)
No, but a reasonable percentage of those convinced that "it's all the government's fault" are going to continue to see it that way no matter what (and get offended when that gets pointed out, apparently). Just like other people think that more government/laws/rules is always the answer. For that matter, I'm pretty convinced of my "radically moderate" views which are somewhere around The Economist's.
Which is why these sorts of discussions rarely go anywhere, even over a beer, to say nothing of short, sharp answers on internet forums.
Of course you are. If you thought they were wrong, you wouldn't hold them as your views, would you?
I was thinking about this, and part of the problem is that these threads often feel like someone selling me something, rather than trying to figure out how things really work. They'd be much more interesting if people "let down their guard" a bit, upped the reasoning, and lowered the propagandizing. I guess it may not feel like propaganda to those involved, but I really like reading comments like mechanical_fish's, which cast a wide eye on things, considering all points of view, rather than people pulling out all the stops to fit the facts to their point of view.
Don't surrender your reason to social contructivism.
In most of these cases, it's not the government protecting existing companies, it's the government protecting the naive population. You won't fire someone after six months of unpaid labor, but someone else will. Your expert system might create air-tight contracts, but someone else will cut corners.
These laws do not exist solely to frustrate you. Part of being in a uniformly free society is ensuring that naive people are not at the mercy of the better informed or less scrupulous. Things can't work any other way.
I wouldn't put up a huge stink if the law was "you must pass the bar exam".
However, the law is "you must attend 3 years of law school".
> These laws do not exist solely to frustrate you
Agreed. They exist to decrease the supply of lawyers, thus increasing the price that lawyers can demand.
Frustrating me is just a side effect.
I sympathize with your frustration, but the reason for the prerequisites could just as easily be that they don't believe they can create a test which properly encompasses everything a lawyer should know.
Also, at least in San Francisco, the job market seems to be saturated with lawyers, even before the economy went south.
Actually, there are still a few states where you can join the bar after clerking for a number of years and passing the bar exam.
See, for example: http://www.wsba.org/lawyers/licensing/faq-rule6.htm
This untrue, throughout history companies get laws to make upstarts more difficult. There is no reason you need to go to law school or even pass the bar, if the buyers don't think it is a good tool they won't use it.
In fact things can work the other way, you are protected the few who may be swindled (they're clearly visible), but ignore all those who are harmed by the lack of new products. It's very hard to look at the other side of the equation, but it is normally quite significant.
Unless a company already has lawyers on staff, they have no way of determining whether a legal expert system is a good product or not. For that reason, it cannot be a substitute for a living, breathing lawyer. It could certainly be a tool for lawyers, and streamline the hell out of most legal processes, but to treat it as something more is to give up on any lowest common denominator for legal advice. And while this would certainly harm lawyers, it would also harm a great many other people.
The recent mandates on testing toys for lead, has pretty much outlawed small toy producers. You can't prepare food at your house and legally sell it (even if you say this was cooked at my house). The FDA debacle with juice pasteurization vs more modern UV processes.
> And while this would certainly harm lawyers, it would also harm a great many other people.
Once again you make a statement that claim to be true with no real backing. Say 1 person is harmed by this newer cheaper law advice, and 10,000 are saved due to the reallocation of resources to medicine -- this is of course a hypothetical example, but it has just as much grounding as yours.
Not: we need the government to be our nanny. That results in all kinds of really bad side effects, including those illustrated by the person who started this thread.
Thanks Mark
One question is why so many things require generating legal documents.
And not just Congress:
http://pajamasmedia.com/instapundit/76701/
>> their lawsuits tend to destroy startups before government regulation does.
In the broad sense, this is government regulation as well, but with the laws being written to transfer the regulatory function from the Executive branch to the Judicial branch.
To build on this comment, I disagree with pg's statement that startups have and will spread somewhat randomly. The biggest defining factor is having a (more) free market in a given place (inc. lower taxes and a /proper/ legal system).
In fact, that's largely why northern Europe had the Industrial Revolution and why most startups are in the US today. Because the US seems to be becoming more statist, that could definitely change.
Government was much smaller at the time of the Industrial Revolution.
The theory of "regulatory capture" says that government is responsive to those firms that are affected by government regulation and have the money to buy favorable legislation.
Thus, it's much easier for big-dumb-and-slow firms to use government to put roadblocks in the way of startups than it was for inefficient firms to put roadblocks in the way of factory production 200 years ago.
Want to sell wine over the Internet? The established players will make sure that it's illegal for you to do so.
Want to cut a deal with your early stage employees where they get no pay for 6 months? It's illegal in most places to not pay someone a wage. In MA it's illegal to fire someone for blatant incompetence and they pay them their final paycheck on the regularly scheduled payroll 4 days later - you need to hand them a physical check then and there.
Want to buy a bunch of servers? In a lot of locales (MA, again), you have to pay taxes on the assets every year.
Want to sell real estate on the Internet? Hope you're a licensed broker!
Want to write an expert system that generates legal documents? You'd better have passed the bar exam. Actually, wait, even though that was good enough for Lincoln, these days you need to have actually ATTENDED lay school - a mere demonstration of proficiency is not enough.
Etc., etc., etc.
If this is how things are in the free-wheeling US, I imagine that it's far worse in Europe.
I think that people across the globe have what it takes to launch startups. I just think that the legal culture makes it very hard in most places.